Jeff Arcuri reveals how 'Bachelorette' wife’s cancer fight transformed his comedy — and their marriage
Life can be uncomfortable. Jeff Arcuri has built a career on finding the joke in uncomfortable moments.
"I think you can make anything funny. You can make awkwardness funny if you’re just honest. People respond to the honesty," the comic told Fox News Digital.
That philosophy has been shaped by nearly two decades of stand-up, but the last few years have tested it in ways Arcuri could not have scripted. As his career surged toward his first special, "Jeff Arcuri: Nice to Meet You," now streaming on Netflix, his personal life grew more complicated when his wife, "Bachelorette" alumna Katie Thurston, was diagnosed with stage IV breast cancer.
"The past two years with my wife kind of grew me up a little bit," Arcuri said. "So my comedy kind of matured, and that’s what the special is. The first half is the stuff that I found funny, and the second half is a lot of s--- that really happened to me."
LAWYER-TURNED-SOCIAL MEDIA SENSATION IS BETTING IT ALL ON GOD, LOVE AND GRIEF
Rather than rely on material he had accumulated over years, Arcuri said he wanted the special to reflect the reality he was actually living.
"There’s no way I’m going to do a special not talking about what’s going on in my current life right now."
Long before Arcuri applied that philosophy to deeply personal material, it was central to the crowd work that helped him gain a following online.
He said he often prefers engaging with someone who appears reluctant to participate rather than the person eager to become part of the show.
"I want him, because now if he laughs, I win," Arcuri said. "He’s going to answer honestly, thinking it’s going to throw me off. But in reality, he’s probably going to only build it, because a truthful audience member is the most valuable, hilarious thing."
That belief in honesty created a challenge in "Nice to Meet You": telling jokes that were true to his experience without bumming out the crowd. He needed to make it safe for viewers to laugh when the subject matter became serious.
Arcuri recalled saying during the special that one of the hardest parts of his wife’s illness was getting her to laugh, "because that’s all I got."
The line was not necessarily intended as a joke, he said, and audiences at most of the tapings did not treat it like one. But one crowd laughed.
"I guess I’m that good," he jested, noting that small adjustments in delivery can make huge changes in the show. It didn't mean pretending the underlying experience was not serious.
That approach extended beyond the stage. Asked whether he was comfortable discussing his wife’s diagnosis, Arcuri responded plainly, "Yeah. I put it on Netflix."
He said he and Thurston have found value in talking openly about what they are experiencing rather than treating cancer as a forbidden subject. Thurston shares cancer updates on her Instagram account, which Arcuri said is followed by a lot of women going through their own experiences with illness. She tends to be very transparent about her diagnosis and treatment — perhaps too transparent.
Arcuri said he sometimes learns updates about his wife through her Instagram broadcast page. "Call me first!" he joked.
Poking fun at the situation is key to the couple's coping strategy. He recounted one of his wife's quips that made his father spit his food out.
"My wife gave me Lactaid at the dinner table because I forgot it in my hotel room ... I go 'Oh, thank you, my angel.' And she said, 'Don't call me that, I ain't dead yet!'"
Arcuri resisted describing that material as "dark comedy," since he didn't write it with that in mind. Rather, he simply wanted his act to be true to his life.
"If anything, I had to make light of something hard," he said.
WITH 10 KIDS AT HOME, COMEDIAN KOUNTRY WAYNE SAYS REAL LIFE WRITES THE JOKES
Arcuri’s current ease onstage came after years in which success was far less certain.
The comic got his start in comedy around 2009 or 2010, he said, after which he spent some time telling jokes in Michigan before moving to Chicago for more stage time and then to the Big Apple, where he got the opportunity to appear on "The Late Show with Stephen Colbert."
"I did a s---ty job at that. I did a bad job."
What followed was what he described as "the most depressive comedy years of my entire life."
"I thought I was going to make it when I came here, and I just ate it for two years straight."
But booking shows on cruise ships and developing relationships with other New York comedians culminated in an audition for the famous Comedy Cellar, and performing there gave him the confidence to start posting his work online.
The past two years also forced Arcuri to recognize that humor could not carry every emotional burden.
While his career took him around the world, Thurston was navigating cancer treatment. Arcuri said therapy helped him manage what it meant to support someone through that experience while handling his own fear.
"I was her person and she was my person, but also there’s a lot you go through being adjacent to somebody that’s going through that," he said.
He found himself repeatedly reassuring his wife that things would be all right.
"I’m telling her that, ‘We’re going to be OK,’" he said. "But I’m telling her that — who’s telling me that?"
Eventually, he told Thurston something he had struggled to admit.
"I’m afraid about your health and it freaks me out. And sometimes I pretend to be stronger than I am."
Arcuri said he had worried that showing that fear would change how his wife saw him.
"I was so scared she wouldn’t see me as a man if I wasn’t like, ‘It’s going to be okay.’"
Instead, she thanked him for saying it.
For a comedian whose instinct is almost always to seize the funny moment, it was another kind of honesty.
For all the ways Arcuri says his comedy has matured, his instinct to find the joke has not gone anywhere. And Thurston helps him turn real life into new material.
He called her "my muse and my biggest inspiration and my biggest motivator with comedy."
Arcuri recalled walking out of the bathroom in a revealing robe when Thurston reacted by calling him "Flabio" instead of "Fabio."
"Your subconscious roasted me. You said 'Flab-io' and you didn't realize," Arcuri recalled saying to his wife.
"She was mortified. And then the next thing she said was, 'Write that down.'"
Even the title of his debut special was inspired by a real habit he hadn't planned. His manager pointed out that the comedian routinely said, "Nice to meet you," to people he called on in the crowd during his shows.
"I watched through it, and it’s like, ‘Hey, nice to meet you. I’m Jeff,’" over and over, he recalled.
"It’s also my debut special," he added. "So it’s those two things mixed in."
CLICK HERE FOR MORE COVERAGE OF MEDIA AND CULTURE
After years of trying jokes, bombing, rebuilding and finally finding an audience, the title doubles as a fitting introduction to the next phase of his career.
And if Arcuri’s philosophy holds, whatever comes next — awkward, difficult or otherwise — will probably end up in the act.