Tuesday Night Massacre: Anti-Redistricting Indiana Republicans Go Down
On Apr. 5, 2026, six of the eight Republicans in the Indiana State Senate who opposed a proposed redistricting bill were defeated by primary challengers, with the support of President Trump and his allies. Just one of the state Senators won renomination, while the eighth race is still too close to call. (RELATED: What Happened in Indiana Wasn’t a Win for Trump. It Was a Win for the People.)
When Indiana took up redistricting towards the end of 2025, several states, including Texas and California, had already approved new maps to benefit their majority party. Several more, including Virginia and Florida, would later follow. Trump and national Republicans viewed Indiana, which currently sports seven GOP seats and two that at least lean Democratic, as a prime opportunity for the GOP to garner two additional districts likely to favor their party. (RELATED: How Democrats Overwhelmed Rural Virginia)
Most Indiana Republicans got on board, including Gov. Mike Braun and Sen. Jim Banks. The Indiana State House dutifully passed a new map that, as expected, would have drawn nine congressional districts that strongly favored Republicans. (RELATED: Republicans Set to Best Democrats in Mid-Decade Redistricting War)
The hurdle, however, proved to be the Indiana State Senate. Senate president pro tempore Rod Bray repeatedly refused to call a special session to take up the bill, saying that there were not enough votes to pass it. When he finally called a special session in December of 2025, the redistricting bill failed by a vote of 19 to 31, despite Republicans holding a 40-seat to 10-seat majority in the chamber. Twenty-one Republicans, including Bray, had joined all Democrats in opposing the map. (RELATED: The Democrats May Not Survive Callais Ruling)
Bray explained his reasoning in an interview with Politico, which reported him saying that “‘[i]t seems like the public is talking about this in terms of a binary choice: either 7-2 or redistricting and get 9-0. That is not clear at all to me, because we don’t know who’s going to run… In fact, I mean, if you really got too cute, you could find yourself at 6-3.”
Under the map approved by the Indiana State House, and rejected by the Indiana State Senate, the closest congressional seat would have voted for Trump by 12 percentage points in the 2024 presidential election. All of the others would have voted for the president by at least 17 percentage points. In other words, if Republicans were in any real danger of losing those sorts of seats, they’d be doomed no matter how they drew the lines. However, in anything resembling a close national environment, Republicans would be expected to easily win all 9 seats.
Bray’s stance quickly and predictably earned Trump’s wrath. In a post on Truth Social, the president wrote that “[u]nfortunately, Indiana Senate ‘Leader’ Rod Bray enjoys being the only person in the United States of America who is against Republicans picking up extra seats, in Indiana’s case, two of them. He is putting every ounce of his limited strength into asking his soon to be very vulnerable friends to vote with him.” Trump and his operation moved to assemble primary challenges against those Republicans up for reelection in 2026 who opposed the map.
Braun and Banks quickly joined in, as did Indiana Lt. Gov. Micah Beckwith, who released a statement saying that “[t]he people of Indiana did not elect a Republican supermajority so our Senate could cower, compromise, or collapse at the very moment courage is required. Yet, here we are again. The Indiana Republican-controlled Senate is failing to stand with President Trump, failing to defend the voice of Hoosier voters, and failing to deliver the 9-0 conservative map our citizens overwhelmingly expect.”
Indiana Republican voters, apparently, agreed. Just one of the eight anti-redistricting Republicans who were up for reelection this year was able to win renomination. Another is clinging to a lead, as of this writing, of 4 votes. That will almost certainly go to a recount. The other six were defeated, many by lopsided margins. (RELATED: The Left Is Melting Down Over Callais)
While Indiana won’t be able to redraw its map this cycle, the defeat of so many anti-redistricting incumbents may allow the state to do so in the run-up to the 2028 elections. Perhaps more importantly, other Republican state legislators across the country are right now considering further redistricting after the Supreme Court’s recent Calais decision. They have now been reminded, yet again, that Trump’s endorsement is a formidable tool and that the president is willing to use it.
READ MORE from Stephan Kapustka:
Back to Basics on Capital Punishment
How Democrats Overwhelmed Rural Virginia
Eric Swalwell, California Psycho