‘Schools need to wake up’: Jewish student sues TMU for $1.3M over alleged ‘poisoned’ learning environment
A Jewish student is suing Toronto Metropolitan University (TMU) for more than $1.3 million, alleging the school created a “poisoned environment” and disregarded several instances of antisemitism and harassment following the October 7 terrorist attacks in Israel.
“I think I need to be a voice for all Jewish students who otherwise feel isolated and alone,” Liat Schwartz told National Post. “I have a very powerful voice, and I think I can make change, or hopefully make change, because (Jewish) students can’t go on living like this. It’s not fair. And the schools need to wake up.”
On March 13, the child and youth care student filed a statement of claim in Ontario’s Superior Court of Justice seeking $1 million in punitive damages and $300,000 in general damages, as well as special damages to be determined by the court and an order that the university apply its conduct policies “in a complete and non-discriminatory manner to any and all conduct involving the Plaintiff and other Jewish TMU community members.” The lawsuit was originally filed in October 2025, but was updated following additional incidents.
The lawsuit alleges that TMU failed to uphold its Student Code of Non-Academic Conduct, Discrimination and Harassment Prevention Policy, as well as other rules governing the use of campus space and civility.
“TMU’s self-proclaimed TMU Commitments and TMU Conduct Policies” are “mere platitudes,” the lawsuit states. It alleges that the university’s failure to apply rules equally “has created a poisoned environment at TMU for the Plaintiff.”
“Since October 7, 2023, there have been extensive, repeated and ongoing violations of the TMU Conduct Policies impacting Liat and other Jewish TMU community members with whom she engages, for which TMU ignored, condoned, justified or otherwise failed to adequately apply or inadequately applied the TMU Conduct Policies,” the statement of claim alleges.
The university told National Post in a written statement that TMU “cannot comment on individual cases before the courts, other than to say it will vigorously defend itself against these allegations.”
“Any instances of antisemitism at TMU are not tolerated, allowed, or ignored. The university takes antisemitism seriously and addresses complaints through a structured and consistent process, including strong policies. Every single reported complaint of inappropriate behaviour is thoroughly reviewed, and where appropriate, investigated by relevant teams,” the school said.
The university has not yet filed a statement of defence.
The lawsuit documents several incidents Schwartz says she experienced during her time at TMU’s campus in downtown Toronto, particularly after she joined a local chapter of Students Supporting Israel (SSI) in September 2024. Since then, she’s become a visible advocate for the Jewish state.
The lawsuit claims that TMU allowed students to use slogans such as “From the River to the Sea Palestine will be free” and “Only one solution, intifada revolution” in signs and graffiti and at rallies. These slogans were “perceived as direct threats to Liat’s personal safety and that of the other Jewish TMU community members,” the lawsuit claims.
Many incidents cited in the lawsuit involve Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP), an official student group on campus. After Students Supporting Israel hosted an off-campus event with two Israelis, the SJP group circulated a group photo of TMU student members and Schwartz that had inverted red triangles over the heads of the guest speakers, a symbol used by Hamas to denote enemy combatants. While the red triangles were later removed, when the image was reposted by SJP, it received comments including, “maybe sjp tmu can bring in Hamas fighters to rape students! That would be fitting rejoinder,” the lawsuit alleges.
The lawsuit states that Schwartz raised this conduct with TMU but “no action has been taken.”
Last November, protesters were arrested after disrupting an off-campus event hosted by SSI that featured two former Israeli soldiers speaking about their experience following the October 7 attacks. SJP TMU activists were allegedly among the protesters. After a glass door was broken, injuring attendees, Schwartz called Toronto police.
The “attack was a directly foreseeable consequence of TMU’s failure to enforce its own policies with respect to actions and conduct of TMU community members since October 7,” the lawsuit alleges. An external review of the attack is not expected to be completed before the end of the school year, the lawsuit states.
Following the incident, Schwartz said she no longer felt safe on campus and the third year student has since stopped physically attending classes. She plans to go to a different university in the fall to continue her studies.
“Given TMU’s failures that foreseeably led to the November 5, 2025 Attack and TMU’s inadequate response following November 5, 2025 Attack, Liat has no confidence in TMU’s ability to create a safe learning environment for her at TMU,” the lawsuit reads.
“The poisoned environment created by TMU’s actions and inaction has led to Jewish TMU students abandoning their studies at TMU, including Liat who, following the November 5, 2025 Attack, initially began a leave of absence from TMU for the remainder of the 2025/2026 school year and then determined she could no longer continue studies at TMU thereafter.”
The university said in its statement that it “encourages any community members who are impacted by discrimination and harassment to reach out so we can investigate, and to access available supports, such as counselling, security planning or human rights resources.”
When asked about the consequences of the November incident for the students involved and whether it has impacted SJP TMU’s standing on campus, the university said the “investigation is still ongoing” and that “due to confidentiality and privacy obligations, TMU cannot comment on specific human rights decisions involving members of our community.”
SJP TMU did not respond to the Post’s request for comment.
Schwartz’s lawsuit is supported by the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA).
“Canada’s Jewish community is facing a tidal wave of antisemitism, intimidation, and attempts to push us out of public life and deny our identities,” CIJA’s senior vice president and general counsel Richard Marceau told the Post in an email.
“Extremism is no longer confined to the margins — it is organized, deliberate, and targeting Jewish Canadians across every aspect of society. On campuses, Jewish students are being harassed and singled out, threatening not only their safety, dignity, and ability to freely express their identity, but also the kind of country Canada is — and must remain.”
Schwartz joins a growing list of Canadian Jewish students who have taken universities and colleges to court since October 7, alleging school leaders have failed to ensure a safe learning environment. After the October 7 attacks, multimillion dollar class action lawsuits alleging “negligence, specifically in failing to address anti-Semitic incidents” were filed against TMU, Queen’s University, the University of British Columbia and McMaster University.
Similar legal actions were taken by a Jewish student at the Ontario College of Art and Design University (OCAD) in May 2024 and, last April, Nicole Szweras filed a $1.3 million lawsuit against TMU, also alleging a “poisoned antisemitic learning and work environment.” CIJA confirmed to the Post that the latter case is currently in the discovery phase and that “mediation has been scheduled as well.”
Schwartz was torn when asked whether Jewish students should continue attending TMU. “I am not going to say, like, ‘Oh, they shouldn’t come to TMU.’” Schwartz feels that young Jews should consider TMU if they are interested in specific programs for which there are few alternatives in Canada, such as fashion or sports.
“But if you’re in, like, business or psychology or science where you could go somewhere else and get a better education without being scared of being Jewish, do that.”
Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and sign up for our newsletters here.