Vatican Stops UN From Promoting a “Right” to Abortion

The 59th session of the United Nations Commission on Population and Development ended the way too many UN negotiations now end: not with agreement, but with collapse. On Friday, April 17, the Commission failed to adopt a consensus resolution because radical pro-abortion delegations would not retreat from their obsession with so-called sexual and reproductive health and reproductive rights.

The session’s actual theme concerned population, technology, and research in the service of sustainable development. But once again, abortion ideology hijacked the room.

That failure did not happen by accident. It happened because the abortion lobby and its state allies treat every negotiation as a chance to smuggle in contested language, rewrite settled agreements, and pressure sovereign nations into surrender. When countries refuse, the radicals blame them for blocking consensus. But the reality is that those who demand radical ideological conformity are the ones who break consensus.

Follow LifeNews.com on Instagram for pro-life pictures and videos.

Mgr. Marco Formica of the Holy See made that point with clarity and restraint. Even after negotiations failed, he noted that “notwithstanding the inability to find consensus on the outcome text, it is at least encouraging that the practice of consensual adoption has been maintained.” That is important because consensus is not some bureaucratic ritual. It protects the legitimate positions of sovereign states, especially on questions involving life, family, and moral truth.

Mgr. Formica then named the deeper problem: “The success and longevity of this Commission is contingent on the true respect for the positions of sovereign states, especially with regard to sensitive issues.” That is exactly right. If UN commissions become instruments for imposing abortion ideology on unwilling nations, they will lose both legitimacy and purpose.

This year’s session should have focused on the real needs of peoples and nations. Instead, as Mgr. Formica said, “We have witnessed an increasingly inordinate focus on issues related to sexual and reproductive health and reproductive rights,” a fixation that diverted attention from matters actually relevant to the Commission’s theme.

He warned that this shift pulls discussion away from the principles of the ICPD [International Conference on Population and Development] Program of Action (POA) and prevents the Commission from fulfilling its mandate “to promote an integrated approach in the implementation of the POA and make recommendations thereon.”

That is not a minor procedural complaint. It is an indictment. The Commission on Population and Development cannot do its job when a single controversial agenda swallows everything else. Nations came to discuss development. Too many delegations came to litigate abortion.

Mgr. Formica also rejected one of the abortion movement’s favorite lies: that “reproductive rights” stands at the center of the Cairo consensus. It does not. In his statement, he said plainly that language on reproductive rights “has always been controversial, including at Cairo in 1994.” He added that presenting reproductive rights as “a central tenet of the ICPD” amounts to “a rewriting of the POA” and “diminishes the actual principles agreed by Member States.”

That line deserves to be repeated. The abortion movement survives on revisionism. It loses the argument on the merits, so it tries to fabricate history. It pretends old compromises said what they never said. It treats disputed language as settled law. It insists that abortion must sit at the center of women’s dignity, international development, and human rights.

None of that is true. Member states never agreed to an international right to abortion. They have not agreed to one now.

The Holy See offered something better. Mgr. Formica said his delegation “continues to support much stronger language promoting the flourishing of women and children and healthcare oriented toward protecting all human life at all stages.” There is the real dividing line. One side wants to protect women and children together. The other treats the child as disposable and calls that “progress.”

In the end, Mgr. Formica reaffirmed the Holy See’s commitment “to work constructively with all delegations in a spirit of mutual respect and dialogue.” He expressed hope that future sessions would produce “a resolution which every delegation can fully support.” That hope is honorable. But it will remain out of reach until pro-abortion delegations abandon their coercive tactics and accept a truth they hate to hear: sovereign nations do not exist to ratify abortion ideology.

What happened at the 59th session of the United Nations Commission on Population and Development should serve as a warning. The United Nations cannot keep narrowing every debate to abortion and still pretend it serves the common good. It cannot keep rewriting past agreements and still claim fidelity to consensus. And it cannot keep bullying pro-life nations and still speak the language of mutual respect.

The Commission failed because abortion radicals would not soften their demands. That is the story. Not obstruction by pro-life states. Not stubbornness from nations defending sovereignty. The breakdown belongs to those who would rather wreck agreement than accept limits on their ideology.

If the UN wants consensus in the future, it needs fewer lectures about “rights” invented by activists and more respect for the child, the mother, and the sovereign nation. Until then, every failed negotiation will expose the same ugly truth: the abortion lobby would rather burn down the process than let the world protect life.

LifeNews.com Note: Raimundo Rojas is the Outreach Director for the National Right to Life Committee. He is a former president of Florida Right to Life and has presented the pro-life message to millions in Spanish-language media outlets. He represents NRLC at the United Nations as an NGO. Rojas was born in Santiago de las Vegas, Havana, Cuba and he and his family escaped to the United States in 1968.

The post Vatican Stops UN From Promoting a “Right” to Abortion appeared first on LifeNews.com.