Utah Supreme Court Justice Allegedly Caught Having an ‘Inappropriate’ Relationship With Leftist Attorney Who Helped Dems Steal a Congressional Seat

A massive scandal may be unfolding in Utah that could have influenced a highly critical case involving redistricting.

As The Gateway Pundit previously reported, an activist judge on The Utah Third District Court struck down the all-Republican congressional map crafted by the Republican-led state legislature last November, labeling it an unconstitutional “gerrymander” and replacing it with a map drawn by left-wing plaintiffs.

Despite this ridiculous ruling, both the Utah Supreme Court and the federal courts refused to intervene, guaranteeing a Democrat pickup in heavily Republican Utah this year.

The Utah Supreme Court previously declared in July 2024 that Utah lawmakers violated Proposition 4 with their map. Proposition 4 is a left-wing ballot initiative approved by Utah voters that purported to ban gerrymandering.

Now, KSL News revealed that a man named Tobin Hagen has alleged that his ex-wife, Utah Supreme Court Justice Diana Hagen, was engaging in an possible romantic relationship with David Reymann, one of the leftist attorneys who successfully argued in favor of giving the Dems a congressional seat.

Tobin Hagen says that he discovered text messages between the two which began somewhat innocently but then became sexual in nature.

The alleged relationship seemingly started no later than February of 2025, when Tobin Hagen discovered the messages.

An attorney received the allegations from Tobin Hagen via Facebook and filed a complaint with the Judicial Conduct Commission in December 2025.

KSL News reported:

The allegations originally come from Hagen’s ex-husband, Tobin Hagen, who said he suspected the justice began having an inappropriate relationship with Reymann, one of the attorneys representing the plaintiffs in the lawsuit over Utah’s redistricting maps.

Tobin Hagen allegedly described the circumstances surrounding his divorce proceedings to another attorney, including allegations that Diana Hagen had exchanged text messages with Reymann, which Tobin Hagen said began as “silly” and then became “more suggestive.”

The case, League of Women Voters of Utah v. Utah State Legislature, is arguably the highest-profile legal case to reach the Utah Supreme Court in years. The justices issued a unanimous ruling in July 2024 saying lawmakers overreached by changing Proposition 4, an anti-gerrymandering ballot initiative.

Attorney Michael Worley said he received the allegations from Tobin Hagen through a Facebook message, and Worley later filed a complaint with the Judicial Conduct Commission in late December 2025, saying he felt his role as an attorney of the bar required him to disclose the information. Tobin Hagen did not approve of the complaint being filed with the commission, according to documents, but “acknowledged its accuracy.”

Justice Hagen, not surprisingly, has called the allegations “false.”

KSL News notes that the Judicial Conduct Commission investigated the allegations and interviewed Tobin Hagen but decided to sit on their hands.

But Justice Diana Hagen’s troubles are not over. Utah Governor Spencer Cox, Senate President Stuart Adams and House Speaker Mike Schultz told KSL in a joint statement on Thursday that an investigation is coming:

An initial review by the Judicial Conduct Commission and the court left important questions unresolved. Allegations of this nature, especially involving public officials, must be examined with transparency and accountability to establish the facts and to maintain public confidence.

We will move forward with an independent investigation to ensure the facts are fully examined. This process will be conducted objectively and thoroughly, because maintaining trust in our institutions is essential.

The post Utah Supreme Court Justice Allegedly Caught Having an ‘Inappropriate’ Relationship With Leftist Attorney Who Helped Dems Steal a Congressional Seat appeared first on The Gateway Pundit.