Add news
News Every Day |

Stir Crazy

Why are peaceful protesters getting longer sentences than violent rioters?

By George Monbiot, published in the Guardian  14th August 2024

A functioning society depends on equality before the law. If crimes are not treated equally and dispassionately by the justice system, we lose trust in democracy and each other. But as sentences begin to be passed on racists who rioted earlier this month, we see once again a blatantly unequal application of the law.

Let’s make a couple of obvious comparisons. One was highlighted this week by the Royal United Services Institute (Rusi). Had those sentenced for their part in the riots this week – who heeded the calls of racist organisers and rampaged through England’s cities – been Muslims inspired by Islamists, they are likely to have been prosecuted as terrorists, potentially facing much longer sentences. Assaulting people in the name of Islam appears to be treated as a far graver crime than assaulting people in the cause of Islamophobia.

How were the attacks on mosques, on a hotel housing asylum seekers and on those who have sought to defend refugees not terrorism? Instead, the riots have been prosecuted as though they were random thuggery, although they emerge from a long and organised campaign of hatred directed towards asylum seekers, immigrants and Muslims. Some of those convicted were reported as having been “caught up” in the disorder: they were portrayed as weak people gone astray. No such understanding is extended to jihadists. As Rusi explains, the UK has a genuine two-tier justice system. It treats some people – white, non-Muslim – as though they act from blind anger, and others – Brown, Muslim – as coordinated terrorists, even when they commit the same crimes.

Far-right terrorists and Islamist terrorists are essentially the same. Both tend to hate women, while claiming at the same time to be protecting them and protecting children. Both tend to hate Jews. Both hate any deviation from their beliefs, their culture and their demands. Both are motivated by a powerful sense of humiliation, resentment and vengeance. Both draw encouragement from agitators: Nigel Farage, Suella Braverman and Elon Musk could be seen as secular hate preachers. Both movements are connected to international networks. Yet the two are treated entirely differently.

Why? It’s not only the police who are institutionally racist, but the entire system. Islamophobia has long been used as a racist code by mainstream politicians. They cannot overtly appeal to a hatred of Black and Brown people, but they can use Islam as a proxy for race, making common cause with a grim but often electorally significant constituency. This, it seems to me, is what the Tory leadership candidate Robert Jenrick did last week.

But there’s an even more obvious comparison with the way the racist riots have been handled, and that is with the prosecution of environmental protesters. It is true that only the first clutch of riot cases have so far gone to court, and longer sentences may yet be handed down. But what we have seen is that violent disorder and assaults on the police have so far attracted shorter prison terms than those imposed for peaceful protest. In fact, the longest sentence for a rioter to date (three years) is shorter than the sentences (four and five years) imposed last month on Just Stop Oil campaigners.

As the judge in the Just Stop Oil case pointed out, the protesters caused major disruption by blocking the M25. They inflicted an economic cost of £770,000. No one, including the defendants, expected them to escape punishment. But,whether you agree with Just Stop Oil’s tactics or not, by any standards their nonviolent protest, whose aim was to protect us all from harm, was a far less serious crime than the violence on the streets this month, whose perpetrators deliberately inflicted injury and massive, indiscriminate criminal damage. The riots did not just inconvenience people, they terrorised them. When civil disobedience is punished more severely than racist rioting, something has gone badly wrong.

The inequality looks even starker when you compare the Just Stop Oil protests with the fuel protests in 2000. The first day of protest that year was organised by the Conservative party, which saw fuel taxes as an opportunity to attack the Labour government. Two months later, in September, the campaign erupted into a nationwide shutdown by a coalition of lorry drivers and farmers. They blockaded oil refineries and fuel depots across the country. Nearly three-quarters of filling stations ran dry, supermarkets began rationing food, ambulance services were severely disrupted, schools shut, bus and train services were suspended, operations were cancelled and the NHS was put on red alert.

Simultaneously, the protesters blockaded motorways with convoys of slow-moving trucks. Transport across much of Britain ground to a halt. The cost to businesses was estimated at £1bn, which in those days was real money. No one even bothered to document the missed hospital appointments, school days, work days, flights and funerals (of which the judge Christopher Hehir made so much in sentencing the Just Stop Oil protesters), as millions of people had to cancel their plans.

The result? As far as I can discover, not a single organiser or activist was prosecuted. Far from it: the first convener of the September protests, Brynle Williams, used his resultant celebrity to get elected as a Conservative member of the Welsh parliament, where he was treated as a pillar of the establishment. Six weeks after the protests, Gordon Brown, the Labour chancellor, gave the blockaders much of what they wanted, cutting fuel and vehicle taxes.

What made the difference? Sure, the Tories introduced vicious new laws in 2022 and 2023 which were used to prosecute the Just Stop Oil protesters for their far smaller disruptions. But in 2000 there were already plenty of laws criminalising the kind of actions the fuel protesters took.

The difference was that the fuel protesters had the backing of the billionaire press and other powerful players. The Tory leader, William Hague, described them as “fine, upstanding citizens”. None of this should make any difference to the way the justice system handles crime: an offence is an offence, whether or not powerful people approve. But time and again, we see police, crown prosecutors and the judiciary moved by the same fear and favour that distorts every aspect of public life, from government budgets to the BBC’s editorial decisions.

The justice system claims to be blind to identity. It claims to prosecute people for the crimes they commit, regardless of who they are. But we know this is not true. The law peeks from under its blindfold, and treats some citizens as more equal than others.

www.monbiot.com

Москва

В Москве стартовал ММКФ-2025

Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Chelsea player ratings: Filip Jorgensen anxiety personified with Nkunku no better… but Cucurella shines once again

‘World’s most controversial Wag’ goes topless and shows off major sideboob leaving fans in shock

Wayne Rooney watches travels to Spain to watch son Klay, 11, as he takes on fellow ex-Premier League star’s child

Jake Paul ‘to fight former world boxing champion and son of ring legend’ next in shock broadcasting deal

Ria.city
Реклама
I bought a watermelon in the market weighing 130kg.

but when he cut it, he was very surprised. It was inside






Реклама
Recommendations to help you get a great harvest of potatoes

Life hacks to help you get a big potato harvest: Asian farmers share tips


Реклама
Recommendations to help you get a great harvest of potatoes

Life hacks to help you get a big potato harvest: Asian farmers share tips

Read also

‘Weak Hero Class 2’ Drops Next Week (4/25)—Catch Up On Season 1 Now

Takhar Police spokesperson among four killed in Traffic Accident

Trump administration's efforts to defund Harvard divides conservatives

News, articles, comments, with a minute-by-minute update, now on Today24.pro

News Every Day

Chelsea player ratings: Filip Jorgensen anxiety personified with Nkunku no better… but Cucurella shines once again

Today24.pro — latest news 24/7. You can add your news instantly now — here


News Every Day

‘World’s most controversial Wag’ goes topless and shows off major sideboob leaving fans in shock



Sports today


Новости тенниса
Карен Хачанов

Карен Хачанов пробился во второй круг турнира в Барселоне, одолев Кэмерона Норри



Спорт в России и мире
Москва

"Спартак" разгромил "Салават Юлаев" и находится в шаге от полуфинала Кубка Гагарина



All sports news today





Sports in Russia today

Москва

Только треть российских болельщиков переживает за местные спортивные клубы


Новости России

Game News

Tempest Rising review


Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this

Russian.city


Москва

Авария в Дагестане: автомобиль столкнулся с поездом, пострадали дети


Губернаторы России
Кубок

Юные орловские футболисты завоевали Кубок РФС


Для прощения понадобилось три смерти: за что был наказан адмирал Николай Кузнецов

Relax FM: 19 лет гармонии и вдохновения

Сотрудничество в мире кино: Радио Romantika в летнем кинотеатре

Знамя Победы: в Ростове-на-Дону снова ходатайствуют о присвоении Героя Российской Федерации лейтенанту Алексею Бересту...


Игорь Бутман и его квартет: тур по Европе и гастроли в Азии в 2025 году

Волочкова опровергла информацию о продаже шестикомнатной квартиры из-за долгов

В Воронежской области завершился проект «Движение по вертикали. Памяти Станислава Говорухина»

Фестиваль «Мелодии победной весны. Трудовому подвигу сверстников посвящается» пройдет в 2025 году


Хачанов вышел в 1/4 финала турнира ATP в Барселоне

Россиянин Хачанов вышел в полуфинал теннисного турнира в Барселоне

Даниил Медведев на девятом месте ATP, Рублёв остаётся лучшим из русских

Карен Хачанов пробился во второй круг турнира в Барселоне, одолев Кэмерона Норри


Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine


Relax FM: 19 лет гармонии и вдохновения

Сотрудничество в мире кино: Радио Romantika в летнем кинотеатре

Весна в Желдорреммаше – время встречи гостей

В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов


Ким Чен Ын подарил Путину собак породы пхунсан: как они живут в России

В Воронежской области завершился проект «Движение по вертикали. Памяти Станислава Говорухина»

В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов

Патриотический автопробег пройдет по городам-героям России и Белоруссии


Олег Каторгин: Всероссийский форум «Малая Родина — Сила России» соберет лучшие практики местного самоуправления со всей страны!

Актриса Митрошина обратилась в суд из-за ДТП с самокатчиком

Мурманчанка вошла в число волонтеров Победы

Дневник редактора моды: Елизавета Базыкина снялась в Valentin Yudashkin, Джонатан Андерсон стал креативным директором Dior Men и другие фэшн-новости недели


Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine


Путин в России и мире


Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this





Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this

Персональные новости Russian.city
Певица

Певица Ольга Орлова призналась, что не восстановилась за два года после родов



News Every Day

Get Arsenal to win Champions League at 100/1 after Real Madrid heroics with talkSPORT BET




Friends of Today24

Музыкальные новости

Персональные новости