Shoppers Say This $8 Lipstick Is a ‘Longer Lasting Alternative’ to Charlotte Tilbury’s Pillow Talk

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission.

While fans of Charlotte Tilbury might be crossing their fingers for some deep discounts on the cult-favorite lip color, other shoppers have already found a near-perfect color match that won’t disappear after the first sip of coffee. Maybelline’s Super Stay Ink Crayon Lipstick in Lead the Way is a pink-beige shade that’s quietly becoming a go-to for anyone who wants staying power without the luxury price tag.

“I used the popular CT Pillow Talk every single day for work,” one reviewer wrote, “but it would barely last me 20 minutes before I would have to reapply. ‘Lead the Way’ was recommended to me by a friend as a longer lasting alternative and I have been hooked since!”

According to shoppers, the lip crayon glides on smoothly with a matte finish that looks soft, not flat. The pink-beige tone is subtle enough for everyday wear but still feels pulled together. One shopper called it “a beautiful nude color that goes with any complexion,” which explains why it’s making it has over 24K 5-star reviews on Amazon.

Maybelline’s formula is designed to hold up through real-life wear, and reviewers are noticing. “Even after coffee, lunch and a bottle of water five hours after putting it on, there’s still color on my lips,” someone noted. The built-in sharpener also helps keep the tip precise for outlining and filling in without any extra tools.

Functionally, the subtle pink lip color behaves like a lip pencil and lipstick in one. “The color is so subtle, but still looks dressy,” another shopper shared. “It’s great how you can use it as a lip pencil for the outline and fill it in. It doesn’t taste bad and even smells good.”

The texture has been called “lightweight” and “not sticky,” and while it may not deliver deep hydration, reviewers consistently said it wasn’t drying. “It feels like a lip stain and lasts long like a stain,” one person wrote. Another appreciated that even after some fading, there was still a hint of color left behind.

So if your favorite nude lip keeps bailing halfway through the day, Maybelline’s $8 Super Stay Ink Crayon Lipstick in Lead the Way might be worth trying.

Read more for lookalikes to Charlotte Tilbury’s Pillow Talk Lipstick.