We Tested Every Major Supplement Brand to Find the Highest Quality Protein on the Market. Momentous Is the Best Overall Protein Powder of 2026
Men’s Journal aims to feature only the best products and services. If you buy something via one of our links, we may earn a commission.
We’ve burned through more protein tubs over the years than we can possibly count. In our younger years, we were just gym rats scavenging the aisles of GNC for the cheapest tubs we could find to hit a macro goal. Our standards have definitely evolved since those chalky days. Now we trade the mystery blends for third-party testing and high-quality ingredients that actually do the body good. We also look for a much cleaner profile in terms of taste. We want a recovery drink that feels like a reward and stays light on the stomach rather than a thick dessert that sits like a brick after a heavy set.
As self-proclaimed protein snobs, we don’t take recommendations lightly. When we began searching for the gold standard for our Men’s Journal 2026 Fitness Awards, we didn't assign the best overall title on a whim. While most powders are crammed with artificial sweeteners or have a chalky texture you wouldn’t dare mix with just water, Momentous Whey Protein Isolate stands alone at the top of the list for its clean ingredient profile, effortless mixability, and superior flavor.
Best Protein Powder Overall: Momentous Whey Protein Isolate
Courtesy Image
Momentous Whey Protein Isolate is our choice for the best overall protein powder. From the high-quality protein sourced from European grass-fed cows to the excellent taste and mixability, this protein powder is hard to beat. Each serving delivers 20 grams of protein, making it a simple and effective way to hit your daily protein targets.
Starting with the packaging, this supplement comes in a slim white container with a screw-top lid that’s easy to open and close. The narrow design fits neatly in my pantry without taking up a lot of space, and the label, which is clean and easy to read, features both the supplement facts and a typical amino acid profile. It also highlights the NSF Certified for Sport badge, which confirms that the product is third-party tested and verified to be banned-substance-free.
For testing, I tried both the Chocolate and Vanilla flavors since they’re usually the most popular. Momentous also offers six other flavors, including Mint Chocolate, Spiced Chai, and Chocolate Coconut, for those who like variety. The first thing that stood out was how fine the powder was and how easily it mixed in a standard shaker bottle. Both flavors dissolved completely in under 30 seconds of vigorous shaking, creating a smooth, clump-free shake. The Chocolate was rich and cocoa-forward, while the Vanilla was creamy and satisfying. Both tasted natural, with a balanced sweetness from monk fruit and stevia rather than the artificial sweeteners common in other brands.
Key Product Features
- Protein Per Serving: 20g
- Protein Source: Grass-fed whey protein isolate
- Flavors: Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, Mint Chocolate, Spiced Chai, Chocolate Coconut, Pure Cinnamon, Unflavored
- Price Per Serving: $2.39 one-time purchase, $2.15 subscribe-and-save discount
Why You Should Trust Us
Men’s Journal has been a trusted source of fitness and outdoor gear reviews for over 30 years. Our recommendations are based on hands-on testing, the guidance of qualified experts, and verified customer reviews. And our buyer’s guides are updated regularly to ensure they always include the latest and greatest.