In Defense of Mass Deportations
It is difficult to overstate how significantly political discourse has shifted on the right over the past decade. When businessman, real estate mogul, and reality television personality Donald Trump first showed up on the political scene in 2015, his comments on immigration sparked backlash, with even some from within the GOP’s ranks deriding him as racist and xenophobic. In the 1990s, Patrick Buchanan’s warnings against mass migration were largely ignored and sidelined, and now Trump rose like a specter of Buchanan spouting the same immigration alarmism. Yet Republican voters managed, in 2016, to reject the whims of the donor class and not only choose Trump as their presidential nominee, but send him to the White House.
In 2015, Republicans still campaigned on the threat of socialism and the need for small government and big tax breaks. The national debt was a major talking point, as was job creation. Few were willing to address the existential threat that mass immigration, including illegal immigration, posed to the U.S.
Fast forward to 2024, nearly one decade after Trump rode that golden escalator. The Republican National Convention that year was packed with voters waving signs that said, “Mass Deportations Now!” This was not a fringe group of Buchananite holdouts hoping that their theatrics might prompt at least 30 seconds’ discussion of the issues they considered important; this was the bulk of the GOP voter base cheering on one of Trump’s core campaign promises: the mass deportation of illegal aliens from the U.S. interior.
Now, after a little over a year of far too many headlines centered on Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and far too few actual deportations effected, GOP leadership is plotting to abandon the mass deportation agenda that largely propelled Trump to a historic victory: a second White House term, flanked by a Republican majority in both the House of Representatives and the Senate, both the electoral college and the popular vote, all after nearly a decade of being smeared as Adolf Hitler reincarnate. Trump supporters had long been castigated as “fascists” or even “Nazis,” but after Joe Biden took office in 2021, political persecution began, with January 6 protestors and everyday pro-lifers being arrested and imprisoned and prominent Trump allies being blacklisted, censored, and debanked. Yet Trump’s base not only shouldered these burdens, but voters turned out in massive numbers to send “Hitler” back to the White House.
House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) suggested this week that “a little hiccup” in polling with Hispanic voters on Trump’s “overzealous” immigration enforcement will prompt a “course correction” on the mass deportation front. Uh oh.
White House Deputy Chief of Staff for Legislative, Political, and Public Affairs James Blair went even further, clarifying in a social media post Tuesday that mass deportations are on their way out. Instead, only “violent” illegal aliens will be targeted for arrest and deportation. The millions upon millions of others who violated American immigration law, took jobs that belong to Americans, took housing that belongs to Americans, and have evaded law enforcement for years — they can stay. According to Axios, Blair has privately advised congressional Republicans to drop “mass deportations” from their campaigning ahead of November’s midterm elections. Oh no.
Citing Department of Homeland Security (DHS) insiders, AF Post reported that incoming Homeland Security Secretary and outgoing Senator Markwayne Mullin (R-Okla.) is expected to “shelve” mass deportations and largely shift DHS’s focus to arresting and deporting violent illegal aliens. Yikes.
A “course correction” that results in nixing the mass deportation program promised by Trump would be disastrous for Trump, the historic coalition he has formed, the Republican Party as a whole, and the American people. First of all, mass deportations were and still remain incredibly popular. In a 2024 CBS News survey, over 60 percent of Americans reported their support for deporting “all undocumented immigrants currently living in the U.S. illegally.” (Emphasis added.) According to a 2024 Gallup poll, 55 percent of Americans endorsed “deporting all immigrants who are living in the United States illegally back to their home country.” (Emphasis added.) A Scripps News survey that same year found 54 percent supported mass deportations.
But that was nearly two years ago! Public opinion may be fickle, but on an issue of such grave importance as the survival of the nation, it has proven to be somewhat more stalwart. An October 2025 Harvard-Harris poll found that 56 percent of voters still support “deporting all illegal aliens.” (Emphasis added.) Even the New York Times couldn’t avoid finding 54 percent support for mass deportations in a September-October 2025 survey. Even after a controversial and high-profile ICE operation in Minneapolis, mass deportations remain popular. Last month’s Harvard-Harris poll found that while 75 percent of voters back the arrest and deportation of illegal aliens who have committed crimes within the U.S., a sizable majority (nearly 60 percent) back “deporting all immigrants who are here illegally.” (Emphasis added.)
Reneging on the promise of mass deportations will have catastrophic consequences for the GOP and will be read as betrayal by the American voters who suffered political persecution, legal retaliation, and ostracization for years over their support for Trump’s agenda — not to mention the many women and children who have been raped and murdered by illegal aliens, the American fathers who cannot support their families because illegal aliens are willing to do the same job for a fraction of the pay (often producing only a fraction of the quality), the American families who cannot find a home because all of the apartments have been rented at inflated prices by illegal aliens and all the single-family homes are being bought up by major investment firms who then rent them out at inflated costs to illegal aliens.
American voters went through hell to put Trump back in the White House, almost entirely on the strength of his mass deportation pledge.
American voters went through hell to put Trump back in the White House, almost entirely on the strength of his mass deportation pledge. There were plenty of reasons to vote for Trump in 2024, of course, but millions of American citizens recognized that the country which their forefathers had fought, bled, toiled, sweat, and even given their lives to settle, define, build, expand, preserve, and pass on to future generations was (and still is) being choked to death by mass immigration. An about-face on mass deportations will shatter the historic coalition built by Trump and decimate any chance the Republican Party might still have at retaining the White House in 2028.
Politics aside, allowing millions (estimated tens of millions, actually) of illegal aliens to simply invade the U.S. and then settle down and face no repercussions, no consequences, no deportations will mark the end of America as a nation. At that point, America will become nothing more than a mission statement: If you agree, more or less, with a certain set of ideas or principles, then you can live and work here and make plenty of money to send back to your home country in untaxed remittances. That is not a nation.
A nation is a people who share a flag, a history, a culture, a morality, a religious ethos (if not a strict religion). There are Americans who can trace their presence in the New World back to the Mayflower Pilgrims and the Plymouth Colony, to the Jamestown settlers, to the unsung heroes of the Revolutionary War, to the fathers and sons and brothers who fought in the Civil War. Does their heritage and history mean nothing? If anyone from the third world can violate the first U.S. law they encounter and profit from it, with impunity, then yes, the heritage that Americans spent 250 years building and cultivating and safeguarding is meaningless.
The U.S. Constitution, the nation’s foundational legal document, clarifies that the U.S. is not an international jobs market nor merely a “propositional nation.” The cornerstone of the preamble — “for ourselves and our posterity” — makes abundantly clear that the U.S. is its own nation, its own, who have spent the better part of the past 250 years curating and defending a shared flag, history, culture, morality, and religious ethos, protecting the American homeland to entrust to the care of the next generation of Americans, not to hordes of “new arrivals” who do not share a flag, a history, a culture, a morality, a religious ethos, or even a language with Americans.
Abandoning a policy of mass deportations will not only hurt the GOP politically; it will effectively end the United States of America as a nation. Oh well, 250 years was a good run.
READ MORE from S.A. McCarthy: