How to Build a Budget-Friendly (& Cute) Beauty Easter Basket for Teens — Featuring Our Top Under-$10 Stuffers
If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission.
It’s hard to believe that Easter is almost here! If you’re just starting to plan your teen’s Easter basket, how about making it a beauty theme this year? Beauty products can get expensive, and make an Easter basket cost a small fortune, but this year, we curated a list of beauty Easter basket fillers you can snag for under $10 a piece.
Although the basket is an additional cost, staying on budget this year and creating a basket your teen actually enjoys is a breeze, thanks to retailers offering Easter basket stuffers priced at $20 or less. Start by selecting a more expensive piece, like the Icon Glass from Anthropologie. They can use it for their favorite drinks, but it also doubles as an elevated makeup brush holder, and then center the rest of the basket around it. You can also pick up affordable face masks, hair accessories, and even fragrances for only $7.
If you’re stuck, keep reading for some beauty gift inspiration. We spotted gifts for all ages and beauty interests from Ulta, Walmart, CVS, and more. You can even mix and match some of our favorite under-$10 goodies for an affordable gift that won’t disappoint. Check those out below.
The Easter Basket
HOW TO MAKE BEAUTY EASTER BASKET FOR TEENS (2026)
Easter Basket with Handle
If you need an Easter basket that is on theme and doesn’t empty your wallet, snag this wicker one. Right now, it’s marked down to only $20 ahead of the holiday.
Best Easter Basket Centerpiece Ideas
HOW TO MAKE BEAUTY EASTER BASKET FOR TEENS (2026)
Anthropology Icon Juice Glass
Anthropology’s icon glasses are a must-have for any season. If your teen doesn’t have one for Easter yet, snag this adorable chocolate bunny cup. It’s made with rextured characters that border the glass and a wide rim, perfect for serving Dr. Peppers and their other favorite drinks. They can also use it to hold makeup brushes and hair accessories.
HOW TO MAKE BEAUTY EASTER BASKET FOR TEENS (2026)
Jellycat Blossom Silver Bunny 'Bloom'
Can’t go wrong with a Jellycat! The plushies are super popular among kids, teens, and even many adults. Plus, they’d just look so cute in the middle of your basket.
HOW TO MAKE BEAUTY EASTER BASKET FOR TEENS (2026)
Hydro Flask Micro Hydro Mini 7 oz Water Bottle
Micro water bottles seem to be one of the must-have accessories this year, and you can’t go wrong with the iconic mini Hydro Flask. It comes in several sizes and colors. Plus, it’s a lot of fun to customize the look of your bottle with charms and other accessories as shown here.
HOW TO MAKE BEAUTY EASTER BASKET FOR TEENS (2026)
BaubleBar Mini Custom Bead Kit
This is a fun one for teens who like to get creative and make their own accessories. This Mini Custom Bead Kit by BaubleBar has everything they need to make one personalized bag charm. There are over 40 multi-sized beads, three smiley faced beads, one complete alphabet set, and one mixed color cord base and key ring.
HOW TO MAKE BEAUTY EASTER BASKET FOR TEENS (2026)
Miffy Mini Crossbody Series Blind Box Plushie Keychain
If your teen is into bag charms, plushies, blind boxes, and just cute things in general, we recommend this Miffy plush bag charm blind box. Such a fun Easter surprise!
Under-$10 Beauty Easter Basket Stuffers to Mix & Match
HOW TO MAKE BEAUTY EASTER BASKET FOR TEENS (2026)
Maybelline Lifter Glaze Oil Balm
This lip balm will quickly become a favorite in their beauty routine. It offers a sheer tint and all-day hydration thanks to the hyaluronic acid and acerola cherry extract in the formulation. The lip balm also gives a naturally full appearance.
HOW TO MAKE BEAUTY EASTER BASKET FOR TEENS (2026)
Daise Fragrance Body Mist
This Daise Fragrance Body Mist is an affordable fragrance that actually smells good and isn’t overpowering. It comes in a fun, preppy flower shape and features a locking mechanism on the bottle to prevent spills.
HOW TO MAKE BEAUTY EASTER BASKET FOR TEENS (2026)
LOOPS Weekly Reset Rejuvenating Mask
The LOOPS Weekly Reset Rejuvenating Mask is designed to hydrate, rejuvenate, and firm skin. The hydrogel sheet mask is formulated with volcanic ash, adenosine, honey, and rice extracts that also brighten.
HOW TO MAKE BEAUTY EASTER BASKET FOR TEENS (2026)
Lush Golden Egg Bath Bomb
Replenish your teen’s bath bomb stash with this limited-edition golden egg from Lush. It turns the bath into a lush, golden spa, leaving the skin velvety soft. Check out Lush’s other Easter bath bombs while you’re shopping!
HOW TO MAKE BEAUTY EASTER BASKET FOR TEENS (2026)
Ulta Powder Puff with Travel Case
The Ulta Powder Puff with Travel Case is a perfect gift teens can take on the go to touch up their makeup. This under-$10 set includes a soft puff and a travel case that keeps it secure and sanitary.
HOW TO MAKE BEAUTY EASTER BASKET FOR TEENS (2026)
Batiste Travel Size Hint of Color Dry Shampoo
Don’t underestimate how exciting a good dry shampoo is. Since teens are notoriously busy, gift them a bottle of Batiste’s bestselling formulas. Dry shampoo absorbs dirt and grease to rejuvenate hair. It’s specially crafted for blondes, but you can shop the brand’s other formulas.
HOW TO MAKE BEAUTY EASTER BASKET FOR TEENS (2026)
e.l.f. Monochromatic Multi Stick
Help build your teen’s makeup stash with simple and interchangeable items like this multi-stick. The versatile, creamy formula glides onto the skin and leaves a healthy glow on the lips, cheeks, and eyes.
HOW TO MAKE BEAUTY EASTER BASKET FOR TEENS (2026)
Neutrogena Fragrance-Free Makeup Remover Wipes
For a touch of skincare, snag the Neutrogena Fragrance-Free Makeup Remover Wipes, which remove all traces of makeup, even waterproof! I’ve used these for years, and now my daughter does too. The wipes are gentle on the skin and don’t cause any irritation.
Before you go, check out our slideshow below: