'Fatal Frame 2: Crimson Butterfly Remake' Review: A Horror Legend Reborn

Author's Note: The author was provided a Steam code by the publisher for the purpose of this review.

Young twin sisters lost in the dark--trapped in a village full of twisted secrets. They have nothing but each other and a mystical camera to fight their way back home. The perfect setup for dread and horror around every corner. In almost every way, Fatal Frame 2: Crimson Butterfly Remake is an improved version of the PlayStation 2 classic, featuring expanded combat options, added character relationship layers, meaningful new lore dropped in the form of side missions, and just the right blend of exploration, combat, and puzzles.

Some of the combat encounters may go on a bit too long, and some of the spirits the sisters face may have a tad too much health, but all in all, survival horror fans have yet another impressive remake on their hands.

A Cursed Village

Fatal Frame 2: Crimson Butterfly Remake sees twin sisters Mio and Mayu Amakura accidentally wandering into an unspoken village after Mayu follows a crimson butterfly. The sisters are close, but their relationship at the beginning of the game is fractured due to a prior event that led Mayu to injure her leg. Mio follows, and the twins are transported to Minakami Village, which then traps the two of them. Mio must then find Mayu, unravel the village's dark secrets, and escape, with nothing but her sister as comfort.

The premise of the game is the perfect setup for a survival horror experience--two young characters with little to no combat experience, completely isolated from the "real world," and being terrorized by the angry spirits of the village. Mio and Mayu do eventually discover why they were summoned to the village, and the lead-up to it is full of tension, dread, creative scares (and some cheap jump scares), and a feeling of isolation.

The whole game takes place inside Minakami Village, making it feel like a huge puzzle box of sorts, with the game's specific locations, such as specific houses, shrines, and mountain sides, feeling like smaller puzzle boxes that must be solved to get a piece that is needed to solve the huge puzzle of the village. All classic survival horror stuff, very similar to the early Resident Evil games.

The narrative is mostly the same as the original game. Players control Mio while searching for Mayu. New for the remake is the ability to have the sisters hold hands (when Mayu is present with Mio), which generates health for Mio. That simple concept actually adds a lot to the experience and strengthens the bond between the sisters.

Without spoiling anything about the story, most of the game's narrative is told via notes that Mio can find (again, very similar to classic survival horror). The dark secrets of the village are slowly revealed to the player via the notes and the real reason the sisters ended up in the village at all. The narrative is one of the game's strongest points, presenting a tale about survival, secrets, complicated relationships, and the impact the dead can have on the living.

Also new to this remake is Side Stories. While exploring the village, Mio will sometimes come across a note or see a spirit that will lead her to a series of locations that reveal more information about the village, the inhabitants, and can sometimes even lead to mini-boss-like encounters with spirits. The Side Stories are optional; they offer decent rewards, but the real prize is the additional lore and story that makes the narrative even more disturbing. It's a great new addition that even Fatal Frame 2 veterans will likely want to complete.

Tense and Dangerous Exploration

Exploring Minakami Village is a tense experience. There is an in-game map that will appear on the game's UI, but it can be switched off for players who want to preserve a classic survival horror experience. Even when picking up needed items in the environment, like film (which operates as ammo for the Camera Obscura, the only weapon in the game) and health items, there is a constant risk to everything you choose to do. When picking up some items, you may get attacked by a spirit. When exploring side areas for needed supplies, you may run into a group of spirits that either need to be dispatched or stealthily snuck by. That risk-versus-reward gameplay choice is survival horror at its finest.

Eventually, there is also the presence of a "stalker" spirit that will chase Mio and stop her from being able to fight back at all. The first time, the chase is thrilling. After that, the spirit becomes more of an annoyance than anything else. Thankfully, those sections are quite brief. There is also a neat side story about the "stalker" spirit that I found to be one of the strongest in the game.

Sound design is one of the key components of a successful survival horror game, and Team Ninja and Koei Tecmo Games knocked that element out of the park. Often, I found myself looking over my shoulder in the dark in my apartment because of how excellent the sound design is.

In my interview with series producer Makoto Shibata, Shibata explained how the team approached sound design for the remake, saying, " In this remake, we support up to 7.1.4 channel spatial audio, enabling players to feel the presence of Wraiths in a much more realistic way."

The stellar sound design, combined with the updated visuals, controls, and over-the-shoulder third-person camera perspective, creates a riveting exploration experience around the village. It's easy to walk into a house, start hearing noises, and go into fight-or-flight mode, with the question if anything is actually there on your mind.

Fatal Frame 2 is often regarded as one of the scariest games ever made. In this remake, I found that opinion still holds true in 2026, at least for me. I remember playing the original game a few years ago, but the remake adds just enough new scares to keep new and veteran Fatal Frame 2 players on edge. It's a dark story, full of disturbing imagery that may leave players keeping a light on at night. It's an exhilarating experience from start to finish.

Point and Shoot

As I previously mentioned, the only weapon in the game for Mio to defend herself with is the Camera Obscura. You do find various types of film for it, some of which act like a shotgun or a rapid-fire machine gun, depending on how you choose to upgrade Mio on her journey. The addition of filters and Special Shots adds a surprising layer of combat complexity that wasn't present in the original game. For example, you can use the Paraceptual Filter to increase your range. You can also manually zoom with the camera to align focal points better, to do as much damage as possible with the limited film you have.

Managing the film types you have and when to spend them is another layer of classic survival horror gameplay. Do you use your stronger film to explore an optional area? Or do you save it for a mandatory encounter? Those types of choices are present in great survival horror games, and Fatal Frame 2 Remake is no exception.

That being said, with new complexity comes a couple of frustrating elements. When you are battling just one wraith, the combat is fun. When you have to deal with several wraiths at once is when the combat becomes chaotic. All of the spirits Mio fights have individual movement patterns, sometimes fading in and out of walls or disappearing altogether. That is a scary and fun puzzle to solve when there is only one enemy.

However, there are a few required fights in the game, in a small room, against two or three enemies at once. I found those sections to be more frustrating than scary, especially if you don't have specific upgrades or film types. Those fights can even feel a little cheap at times. Thankfully, there aren't too many of those encounters in the game, and most of the game's combat is only against one wraith at a time.

Another nitpick I have with the combat is to do with the amount of health enemies have. This was a complaint I had during the preview period, and it's still present in the final game. There are some fights in which spirits can become "aggravated," and then they regain their health and are even more aggressive. There is a film filter to deal with the aggravated spirits, but those fights, as well as a few where multiple enemies join the fight in progress, last way too long, especially if you are running low on film. For example, in a late-game area, I had to fight two enemies at once. Then, once they were defeated, a third spirit joins the fight and revives the other two enemies. That fight lasted over 20 minutes for me because I used all my film on the first two enemies, thinking it was a mini-boss of sorts. There aren't too many of those encounters, but I did find them to be a chore.

Also new for the remake is the ability to equip charms to power up various filters, films, or even survive fatal blows. The charms also add an additional layer of player expression and combat depth, creating one of the strongest combat systems Fatal Frame has ever had. I just wish some of the fights didn't last as long as they do.

'Fatal Frame' Is Back And Better Than Ever

Fatal Frame 2: Crimson Butterfly Remake is a remake that survival horror fans often dream about. It maintains its classic roots while modernizing the gameplay, camera system, and graphics, and also adding in new elements that enhance the experience rather than take anything away.

The 10-hour journey across Minakami Village left me scared, disturbed, and delighted. While there are some issues with the game's combat, the game's intense exploration and occasional puzzle-solving create a survival horror experience that shouldn't be missed by series veterans or newcomers.

Now, along with the resurgence of Silent Hill and the continued success of Resident Evil, I can easily see a future for the Fatal Frame series, and it's never been a better time to be a survival horror fan.

Fatal Frame 2: Crimson Butterfly Remake releases on March 12, 2026, for PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S, PC, and Nintendo Switch 2. A free playable demo is also available now, with save file progress carrying over to the full game.