The state is lecturing its citizens about the supposed danger of their diets, again
Here comes the 1st battalion of desk jockeys to lecture you about your dinner’s carbon footprint.
Daily life in France used to be simple, until the government decided to appoint itself Mother Nature’s personal bodyguard, and the average citizen was declared her number one threat. Their latest salvo is to make the climate more resilient, even if it means that you end up less so.
The newly published ”national strategy for food, nutrition, and climate: 2025-2030” points out that “32% of the adult population consumes too much meat other than poultry,”“63% too much cold cuts,” and not enough fruits and vegetables. You can probably guess what comes next.
“Yep, here come the lectures about cow farts and deuces again!”
Correct!
Did you know, for example, that “products of animal origin are responsible for the majority of food’s carbon footprint” at 61%? If not, the French government would like to remind you. And yes, your own meateater farts are under scrutiny, too. Citing a British study, the report notes that “the greenhouse gas emissions of vegans represent 25% of those of heavy meat consumers in CO2 equivalent.” Excuse you, sirs! No, really, excuse yourselves. Assuming, of course, that all the authors of this screed masquerading as a policy paper are militant vegans – in which case, 30% of your own beans and legumes also end up in the atmosphere, post-digestion, as a giant jackboot of carbon dioxide stomping on a polar bear by your own definition. Is this really the moral superiority contest that we want to have? You’re talking like all these objectively useless machinations are actually achieving anything. The evidence seems to suggest otherwise.
So what will they do? Whip the steak off your plate? Not quite. Not directly, anyway. Instead, they’ll hound the meat producers – the farmers already buried under French and European regulations, spending ever more hours ensuring their reported activities match the spy photos taken of their land by the EU’s Copernicus satellites. “The EU spends some 40% of its budget on agriculture subsidies, and whether farmers are declaring everything correctly can be checked through satellite data. The Sentinels are explicitly designed to support the implementation and monitoring of European policies, such as the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) that aims to improve agricultural production and sustainable use of natural resources,” the EU explains.
France’s national low‑carbon strategy (SNBC) and associated plans also envision major reductions in agricultural emissions by 2030 and until 2050, implying that livestock production must adopt measures to be lower‑carbon, more efficient, or transform practices, all of which require spending cash that they increasingly don’t have.
Just to hammer the point home, this month’s new food and climate report underscores that their plans to “rebalance” protein intake, “along with a shift towards more sustainable models, can also help to better address the challenges of…reducing the carbon footprint of food.”
So, on top of this ever-burgeoning bureaucracy – which French farmers say is more strictly enforced than anywhere else in the EU – meat producers must also contend with the government trying to convince consumers to ditch their product, killing demand and depressing their revenues. You’d think the French state was dealing with hard drugs here, a Class A substance rather than steak. Why not just have special forces raid butcher shops, already?
Look, this green agenda made more sense when everyone had the cash to indulge in lifestyle experiments. Now that most people are either broke or heading in that direction, they’ll be eating whatever they can get their hands on – increasingly not steak and red meat. So how about just leaving those who can still afford it alone?
The French government mismanaged its energy policy by attempting to appease the greenies by trying to wind down nuclear energy (less drastically than Germany, but still), then let the EU lead it by the nose in switching out cheap Russian energy for pricier American LNG. Even baguette makers are struggling – let alone folks raising beef.
This report acts as if beef is still a choice, when it is increasingly a luxury.
Meanwhile, the government has also noticed that people are getting fat and lazy, and is intent on giving them a swift jackboot to the chair. How? By creating more bureaucratic initiatives pushing people to move and exercise. I’m sure this nanny statism will work as well as those train-door signs reminding people not to leave their bags behind, even as train delays pile up because of all the innocuous abandoned backpacks.
This is all just the latest in an endless series of ecological and ideological pestering that has become pervasive in French society. From scolding citizens for air conditioning in the summer to telling them to recycle (even as an estimated 30% of plastics “recycled” still end up in landfill anyway), to geothermal pools that can’t hold a steady temperature like the old man turning a dial, the message is clear: the state knows better than you. That’s worked out great so far, if current reality is any indication.
Perhaps they should try butting out instead. Then maybe they wouldn’t be in a position of having to unscrew all their previously engineered screwups.