Mary-Kate Olsen’s Super-Rare Outing Sparks Romance Rumors With Demi Moore’s Ex
25
Mary-Kate Olsen just made a super-rare outing, and it has everyone talking.
In case you missed it, earlier this week, Olsen was seen with actor Vito Schnabel. DeuxMoi posted the photos to their Instagram with the caption reading, “DEUXMOI EXCLUSIVE…Mary Kate Olsen with Vito Schnabel early yesterday AM in NYC ????@backgrid_usa.”
While many instantly thought they could be a couple, it’s not all what it seems.
Now, Schnabel has a truly star-studded relationship history. Schnabel has been in relationships with Amber Heard (2018-2019), Heidi Klum (2014 – 2017), Demi Moore (2012), Liv Tyler (2010 – 2011) and Elle Macpherson (2008).
RELATED: Amber Heard’s Entire Dating History: Johnny Depp, Elon Musk, & More
Schnabel and Heard were together for a bit under a year, making their public debut in July 2018 at the Wimbledon Championships. However, they broke it off in early 2019 due to long distance, per Us Weekly. Schnabel and Klum dated for three years, with Klum saying after the breakup, per People: “I believe that it is important to take time to pause and reflect.”
As for him and Moore, they met in 2012 at the lavish birthday bash Naomi Campbell threw for her boyfriend Vladimir Doronin, and were seen extremely flirty with one another. However, it was quite short-lived. A source told New York Post via Entertainment IE, “Vito has worked very hard to be taken seriously in the art business and doesn’t want to be seen as somebody who dates celebrities. He hated having photographers follow him around after work got out about him and Demi.”
He had a low-key relationship with Tyler and a rather public romance with Macpherson.
However, Schnabel actually married! Per Page Six, Schnabel actually secretly married model Helena Althof in 2024.
As for Olsen, Olsen was previously married to businessman Olivier Sarkozy from 2015 to 2020, divorcing in 2021. Her last relationship was with businessman Pc Valmorbida, whom she started dating in 2023, but it’s unclear if they’re still together. (She did spark dating rumors with Sean Avery back in 2025, but he spoke about their long-time friendship.)
RELATED: Sean Avery Finally Addresses Those Viral Mary-Kate Olsen Romance Rumors