Bearaby vs. Silk & Snow knit weighted blanket, the original and a popular dupe

When you buy through our links, Business Insider may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

I'm a lover of the best weighted blankets, but unfortunately, they aren't always the most aesthetically pleasing. For anyone looking for a throw that adds a bit of style to the couch or bed and provides that signature hefty feel, I always recommended knit weighted blanket. You can't even tell that these blankets are weighted, but an attractive design isn't all they have to offer — made with a heavyweight yarn, the weight stays evenly distributed without shifting, uncomfortable glass or lead beads.

Bearaby's Cotton Weighted Blanket is the top name in the knit throw category, but we've recently discovered a near-perfect dupe: the Silk & Snow Hand Knitted Weighted Blanket. Though they share a similar design, there are subtle differences that set these two blankets apart. Below, I've compiled the similarities and differences, from design to value, to help you pick the best knit weighted blanket for you.

Bearaby vs Silk & Snow: Overview

Bearaby vs Silk & Snow: Design

Silk & Snow's weave is more relaxed, while Bearaby's design is tight. When I was testing these two weighted blankets, I noticed that the fabric of the Silk & Snow blanket had a looser, more distressed weave. The fabric itself is also looser, so it has a relaxed look and feel. I noticed that this loose knit also means the loops are prone to stretching out during use. It's also altogether chunkier than the Bearaby blanket. On the other hand, Bearaby's Cotton Napper has a tighter knit with a plump cotton fabric. When placing the two blankets side by side, there's an obvious difference between the designs of the fabric.

Silk & Snow's blanket skews larger than Bearaby's version. Even when the weights are the same, the Silk & Snow blanket is one to eight inches longer and wider than the Bearaby blanket. You'll get more coverage from Silk & Snow, but the Bearaby blanket is more compact for tossing on the couch. In addition to the personal throw sizes, Bearaby offers its blanket in queen and king sizes too, which weigh in at 20 and 25 pounds respectively.

Only Bearaby's blanket is certified organic, but both are eco-friendly. Also of note, Bearaby's Cotton Napper is both GOTS- and Oeko-Tex certified, which means it's organic and free of harmful substances like chemicals or pesticides. Silk & Snow's Knitted Weighted Blanket is made with natural cotton and Oeko-Tex certified, but it isn't certified organic.

You'll find brighter colors at Bearaby and earthy tones at Silk & Snow. Both are available in eight colors. Silk & Snow's color range skews very neutral and earthy. Bearaby's is also quite muted, but standout colors include a matcha green and a light pink.

Bearaby vs Silk & Snow: Comfort

Knit weighted blankets are incredibly comfortable. I love knit weighted blankets for their calming pressure without the feel of glass or lead beads. Both of these blankets are extraordinarily comfortable and helped me relax at the end of a long day, whether I kept it on the couch or brought it to bed with me. Plus, the knit construction means the blanket is breathable, so there weren't any worries about overheating.

Bearaby's blanket reigns supreme in terms of comfort. In general, I found Bearaby's Cotton Napper to be more comfortable than the Silk & Snow Knitted Weighted Blanket. As I mentioned in the design section, the Cotton Napper has a tighter knit with smaller cotton fabric. I preferred this feel, as it kept my temperature regulated and provided even weight across my body. The weight distribution felt less even with the Silk & Snow Knitted Weighted Blanket, since there were more empty spaces in the blanket weave. The large holes in the Silk & Snow blanket also aggravated one of the few downsides of knit weighted blankets: my toes and fingers got stuck in the knit as I used the blanket. This happened with the Bearaby Cotton Napper, too, but the smaller weave meant it was less prevalent.

Bearaby vs Silk & Snow: Care

Both can be machine-washed, but check your washer's weight capacity. The Cotton Napper and Knitted Weighted Blanket are both technically machine washable, but be sure to check your washer to ensure it can support their weight. Both brands recommend washing the blanket in cold water and tumble drying on low. For instance, Bearaby recommends taking blankets 20 pounds and heavier to a commercial laundromat. Also, be careful not to hang either blanket to dry since it will stretch the loops. Silk & Snow notes that their blankets should not be cared for in top loading washers and dryers.

For more information on caring for your weighted blanket, see our article on how to wash weighted blankets.

Bearaby vs Silk & Snow: Value

Silk & Snow's blanket has better return and warranty policies. When comparing the two brands based on their value, Silk & Snow comes out on top. All of its bedding products are covered by a one-year warranty, which covers any manufacturing defects that appear after normal use. The Knitted Weighted Blanket also comes with a 100-night trial, so you're able to try it out and return it if you aren't a fan. Bearaby has a one-year warranty for its weighted blankets, but its return period is only 30 days. Only unwashed items are eligible for return, and a fee is deducted from your return depending on the weight of blanket that you're returning.

Silk & Snow's version is also cheaper. Comparing price, a 15-pound Bearaby blanket costs $269 while the same 15-pound Silk & Snow blanket is $230, and is frequently marked down to just under $200. The difference is marginal, but noticeable, especially when there is a sale. Between the price and the policies, if you're trying a weighted blanket for the first time and aren't sure if you'll like it, Silk & Snow is the best choice for its policies and price.

The bottom line

While these blankets may look extremely similar, there are subtle difference in the design and value that set them apart. If you're looking for the ultimate comfort in a weighted blanket, I recommend opting for Bearaby's Cotton Napper. For the best value, including a cheaper cost and better trial and warranty policies, I recommend the Silk & Snow Knitted Weighted Blanket. Either way, you'll sleep easy with either of these knit weighted blankets.