Man Utd Player Ratings: One flawless 10/10, four 9/10s deliver ultimate response to pundits vs City

Manchester United delivered a statement performance by defeating Manchester City 2–0 in the Premier League at a roaring Old Trafford on Saturday.

Michael Carrick set his side up in a disciplined yet aggressive 4-4-2 shape.

From the opening exchanges, the hosts looked sharper, stronger and far more purposeful for large spells of the contest.

United thought they had struck twice, only for both celebrations to be cruelly cut short by the raised offside flag.

The Red Devils kept the pressure relentless, and their persistence was finally rewarded as Bryan Mbeumo broke the deadlock just before the hour mark.

The momentum never dipped, and Patrick Dorgu doubled the advantage after a moment of brilliance created by substitute Matheus Cunha.

Mason Mount even marked his cameo with a first-touch finish, but once again the offside flag spared City further embarrassment.

Following days of relentless and often unfair criticism from pundits, United’s players produced the ideal on-pitch reply, silencing the noise in emphatic fashion.

Player Ratings

Senne Lammens – 7/10

His third clean sheet of the season in a game where he was hardly troubled.

Diogo Dalot – 5/10

Fortunate to escape an early red card after a high challenge on Jeremy Doku.

Did offer some attacking threat, flashing a dangerous cross across the face of goal that narrowly evaded Dorgu.

Harry Maguire – 9/10

Making his return to the starting XI, Maguire shook the crossbar with a towering header. A dominant presence in the air, winning possession back for the opening goal.

Lisandro Martinez – 9/10

He thought he had an assist for Fernandes before the offside flag intervened. Then came a crunching, perfectly timed slide to shut down Haaland. Paul Scholes and Nicky Butt, where are you?

Luke Shaw – 8/10

Started at left-back and made a vital block to prevent Phil Foden from getting a free shot following a mistake from Amad Diallo.

Casemiro – 7/10

He could have shown more composure when attempting to chip Donnarumma, but he dominated the midfield throughout.

The Old Trafford crowd gave him a deserved ovation when he was substituted.

Kobbie Mainoo – 7/10

Making his first start of the season, the England international showed why he deserved far more game time under Amorim. Calm and composed in central areas, he kept things tidy and brought control in possession .

Bruno Fernandes – 10/10

Orchestrated everything United did well. His perfect corner was wasted by Maguire’s header off the post, while a sensational first-half cross begged for a finish.

He hould have shot when City gifted possession, but his creativity carved open the defence for United’s opener. Simply the standout performer.

Patrick Dorgu – 8/10

Proved to be an attacking outlet on the left and took his goal well after beating his marker.

Amad Diallo – 7/10

Caught offside before finishing in the first half and later opted to shoot when a cut-back for Fernandes was the better option. Almost made amends late on, striking the post after a brilliant solo run.

Bryan Mbeumo – 9/10

Mbeumo pulled off a stunning save from Donnarumma before putting United ahead with a sublime, precise left-footed strike.

Substitutes

Matheus Cunha – 9/10

A stellar cameo from Cunha. He earned an assist and could have had another if not for a marginal offside.

Manuel Ugarte – 7/10

His one cross field pass drew applause from Old Trafford crowd.

Mason Mount – NA

Too late to rate.

Ayden Heaven – NA

Too late to rate.

Article written by Sanidhya Bhardwaj .