I tried on coats at Gap, Banana Republic, and Old Navy. The experience reminded me that a great piece is worth investing in.

I started my day with a trip to Gap.

I started my search for a stylish and well-constructed peacoat at Gap.

When I walked in, I appreciated that the store was easy to navigate and neatly organized. Plus, I found the coat I was looking for almost immediately.

However, I wasn't blown away by this option.

I tried on the wool-blend wrap coat and could tell right away that it offered a nice shape and structured fit that would fit easily over layers.

I liked the thick-notch lapels, and thought the material (52% recycled wool, 40% recycled polyester, 8% other) felt warm without being overly bulky. However, the wool blend felt a bit itchy, especially around the neck area where it directly touched my skin.

Plus, there were no buttons and the pockets were hidden, making it look somewhat like a bathrobe.

Although it was a good, basic option, I wanted something with a little more flair. I also had a hard time justifying the price of $248 for a coat that was 40% polyester.

Next, I went to Banana Republic.

After striking out at Gap, I decided to try Banana Republic for another option. The store was neatly organized, and I was able to locate a black peacoat easily.

This coat was pricey, but I think it would be worth the investment.

When I saw the $550 price tag on the Italian-wool cashmere wrap coat, I thought, "There is absolutely no way I would pay that much for a coat." But after trying it on, I reconsidered.

I could immediately tell that the quality of the material (made with 91% wool, 6% cashmere, and 3% other materials) was thick and warm, with no polyester in sight. The inside lining was also silky and smooth, and the overall fabric felt soft and comfortable without itching.

I also loved the overall design of this coat. The pointed collar and large pockets added chic touches that were flattering yet functional.

This try-on reminded me that it's important to invest in pieces that will actually last a long time. I know this coat is something I would wear every winter for years.

I made one last stop at Old Navy before heading home.

I'm a big fan of Old Navy because it offers both basic and trending styles for an approachable price.

However, my local Old Navy was less organized than the other stores I visited, so it took me a bit longer to find a black peacoat. Thankfully, I was able to find one and brought it to the fitting room.

I didn't love how the Old Navy option felt.

The first thing I noticed when trying on the oversized twill overcoat is that it didn't have a waist tie, which, to me, feels like a must for adding shape and style to any peacoat.

The coat was also made of 100% recycled polyester, so I'm not sure how warm it would actually keep me during winter. The fabric also felt less flexible than the others I tried on, leaving less room for layers underneath.

I did like the overall style, though — it had a spread lapel and the buttons featured an eye-catching texture.

This was my least favorite coat out of the three, but for $90, I think it's a solid option for anyone shopping on a budget.

I'd be most likely to buy the coat from Banana Republic.

Overall, the Banana Republic coat impressed me most, thanks to its durable fabric blend, comfortable fit, and elegant design.

This shopping day reminded me that high-quality staple pieces are worth investing in.