Tinder and Hinge recommended serial rapist to women, lawsuit claims
Match Group, the conglomerate that owns dating apps Tinder and Hinge, knew a serial rapist was on those apps — and recommended him as a match to women anyway, a lawsuit filed Tuesday alleges.
Stephen Matthews, a Denver-based cardiologist, was convicted of drugging and/or sexually assaulting 11 women between 2019 and 2023, and sentenced to 158 years to life in prison in October 2024.
A bombshell investigation by The Markup and the Pulitzer Center's AI Accountability Network, reported in February, revealed that women had reported Matthews on apps like Hinge, but that he was still allowed to remain on the app.
"Match Group fails to have effective systems to institute bans not only within its products, but across products when abusers migrate from one product to another," the new complaint says. The action has been brought by six women against IAC, Inc. (which owned Match until 2020), Match Group, Hinge, Tinder, and Matthews himself.
The suit claims that Match Group began receiving complaints about Matthews drugging and raping women via Hinge no later than September 2020, and that Match "knowingly continued to welcome Matthews on its apps" despite learning its products "were facilitating his rape spree."
The six plaintiffs are women whom Match Group apps recommended to Matthews, and vice versa. Five were drugged and raped after Matthews matched with them on Hinge, and one on Tinder, the suit states.
In September 2020, one of the women reported her incident with Matthews on Hinge the day after it occurred. Hinge Trust and Safety confirmed receiving her report — yet in January 2021, Hinge recommended Matthews to the same woman, the suit alleges. She reported him again, and warned Hinge that it was introducing "a potential threat to other women within the Hinge community."
Hinge Trust and Safety confirmed it received her previous report, the suit says. It also assured her Hinge already banned Matthews and that he'd be banned again, and responded by saying it was taking steps to ensure he'd be permanently banned. But Matthews concurrently used Tinder.
"For the three years that followed, Match Group was armed with knowledge that Matthews was raping its members, yet it continued to give Matthews full access to its products and recommended Matthews to other members and other members to him for in-person romantic encounters," the lawsuit states.
It also says Matthews used his real name, the same photographs and descriptions of his job, and the same phone number for his profiles.
Matthews was arrested in March 2023 after one woman reported him to the Denver police. Nine more women came forward to the police with similar allegations dating back to 2019.
A website called matchgrouplawsuit.com has been set up by the plaintiffs' counsel, encouraging other survivors of Matthews to get in touch.
"Any report of sexual assault or violence is heartbreaking and deeply concerning," a Match Group spokesperson told Mashable. "Safety is foundational to the trust our users place in us and is critical to the success of our business, which is why we have a comprehensive suite of safety tools in place and continue to invest heavily in this area."
The spokesperson continued: "We are committed to strengthening our safety efforts, building innovative new technology, and working closely with industry partners to help protect our users. We will always look for ways to improve our systems and help our community stay safe both online and when they connect in real life."
If you have experienced sexual abuse, call the free, confidential National Sexual Assault hotline at 1-800-656-HOPE (4673), or access the 24-7 help online by visiting online.rainn.org.