Out of all the options I tried on, I'd consider buying the one from Gap.
Chloe Caldwell
I tried on wedding guest dresses at Gap, Banana Republic, and Old Navy.
All the dresses were nice, but I thought the one from Gap was the most versatile.
The Old Navy dress was a little thin, and I didn't think it would be a great long-term investment.
As a late 20-something, I've spent the past few years attending countless bachelorette parties, bridal showers, and weddings. This summer alone, I have five wedding weekends to attend.
Of course, this means shopping for a new dress for every occasion — and attempting to do so on a budget.
I typically shop at Gap, Banana Republic, and Old Navy — all owned by parent company Gap Inc. — for casual basics and work wardrobe staples.
However, I decided to test my luck with the retailers in search of a decently priced yet elegant wedding guest dress. Here's how it went.
I kicked off my search at Gap, a brand I usually rely on for quality staples.My local Gap store had a great clearance section.
I browsed my local store but didn't find any standouts until I made my way to the sale section. I spotted a red floral beauty hanging alongside other overlooked pieces with discounted price tags.
The recycled satin maxi slip dress stood out to me because of the vibrant color and pattern, which seemed appropriate for summer weddings.
The dress was comfortable but had a few quirks.This dress would be great for outdoor ceremonies.
Chloe Caldwell
Although the material was 100% recycled polyester, it still felt lightweight and comfortable on my skin. The silhouette was loose and breezy, ideal for outdoor ceremonies in the heat.
Plus, it still managed to flatter my curves with a gentle taper at the waist and a slight flare at the hem.
However, I did notice a couple of design quirks. For example, the neckline was a bit flimsy, and the cut of the underarm area stuck out slightly.
Although it wasn't the most shapely option, it made up for this in comfort and ease. I especially loved the subtle slit on the side, which added a little extra flair.
This dress could easily be styled up or down for different dress codes, from cocktail to more formal events.
The best part? It was on final sale for just $20. Between the price and the gorgeous hue, this Gap option was a top contender right off the bat.
My next stop was Banana Republic.Banana Republic's clothing can sometimes be out of my price range.
JHVEPhoto/Shutterstock
Although Banana Republic is usually out of my price range, I'm willing to splurge for special occasions.
When I entered the store, the gathered halter maxi dress grabbed my attention because of its pretty green shade and tiered flounce hem, which looked luxurious and on-trend for summer.
The details are what sold me on taking this to the dressing room, though. I loved the high neckline and bow tie along the scooped back.
Although I loved the overall design, the baggy fit made me feel frumpy.I didn't love how this dress fit me.
Chloe Caldwell
The shape is meant to fit oversize, but unfortunately, it didn't do my petite frame any favors. I do think this style would be a fantastic option for taller women, as the flowy and comfortable fit would be ideal for hot summer ceremonies.
With the right accessories, it would be fitting for formal and black-tie gatherings.
My main gripe with the Banana Republic dress is that it costs $160 for a material primarily composed of polyester (97% polyester, 3% elastane spandex).
On a positive note, though, the dress was fully lined, so I wouldn't have to worry about it being see-through. Plus, after trying it on, I discovered it has pockets.
I made one final stop at Old Navy, which offers lots of affordable styles.The dresses I found at Old Navy were more casual.
Chloe Caldwell
Old Navy is known for its casual styles, so I was curious to see if I'd find something suitable for a more formal occasion.
There weren't many wedding guest dress options at Old Navy, and there definitely weren't any that I could wear to a black tie occasion.
However, I found a pretty patterned number that would be fitting for casual or semi-formal outdoor summer weddings. The sleeveless satin ruffled midi dress came in a few colors, but I was drawn to the yellow floral print.
Right away, I could tell that the material was thin, and I'd only be able to wear it a few times.The dress from Old Navy was see-through in certain lighting.
Chloe Caldwell
Overall, I liked the details of this dress, like the flouncy fit and the ruffles at the chest, which added a sweet touch. It was comfortable and had that effortless vibe that makes it easy to throw on and go.
It's a style I could see myself re-wearing for summer barbecues, brunches, or casual parties. But there was one major drawback: the material.
The dress was made of 100% recycled polyester and had no lining. The fabric was a single thin layer, and it looked almost see-through in certain lighting.
Although I love a lightweight material for steamy summer days, I don't want to worry about people seeing my undergarments through my outfit.
In fact, the fabric was so lightweight that I worried it might not hold up well after multiple wears.
I'd be most likely to buy the Gap dress.Out of all the options I tried on, I'd consider buying the one from Gap.
Chloe Caldwell
The Gap dress was my favorite of all three options, especially considering the significant markdown. It was comfortable, flattering, and had a nice pattern.
Overall, this shopping experience taught me that the newest items aren't always the best and that the sale section often includes some hidden style gems.