Who Is the Best Manager Barnsley Haven't Had?
Calling all Reds fans! Some former Barnsley players went on to enjoy impressive managerial careers but never returned to Oakwell in the dugout. From promotion winners to record-breakers, these ten names made their mark elsewhere—so who is the best manager Barnsley haven’t had? Take a look at the contenders and cast your vote!
1. Alan Little
A tough‐tackling midfielder at Oakwell in the early 70s, Little guided York City for six seasons, forging a respectable win ratio. He passed away on 8 August 2024, aged 69, but remains a revered name in lower‐league management history.
2. Neil Warnock
Warnock’s time in the red shirt (1976–1978) might be overshadowed by his incredible managerial odyssey. From Notts County to Sheffield United to Cardiff—and back again—he’s gained promotions and turned clubs around more times than most. Controversial, charismatic, and always entertaining.
3. Mick McCarthy
A true Barnsley lad who came through the ranks, McCarthy patrolled the Oakwell defence in the late 70s and early 80s. Later, he found success at Millwall, Sunderland, Wolves, and with the Republic of Ireland. Renowned for no‐nonsense tactics and inspirational man‐management.
4. Ronnie Moore
A prolific striker for the Reds during the early 80s, Moore made his name in the dugout at clubs like Rotherham, Oldham, and Tranmere, regularly punching above their weight. His knack for getting the best out of players saw him sustain a respectable win ratio.
5. Sam Ellis
Ellis marshalled Barnsley’s defence from 1979 to 1983 before embarking on a lengthy stint as Blackpool manager. In seven seasons at Bloomfield Road, he maintained a competitive edge, instilling fight and discipline in his teams.
6. Peter Shirtliff
A dependable presence in Barnsley’s backline from 1986 to 1989, Shirtliff dipped his toes into management with Mansfield Town. Despite a short spell there, he notched a tidy win percentage and showed he could handle the pressure from the touchline.
7. Russ Wilcox
Once a defender at Oakwell in the mid‐80s, Wilcox grabbed headlines at Scunthorpe United, guiding them on a record‐breaking 28-game unbeaten run. His career may have been up‐and‐down afterward, but that historic streak still shines brightly.
8. Alex Neil
Recommended to Barnsley by neighbour Peter Hetherston—who knew boss Dave Bassett—Neil arrived after a bright start at Airdrieonians. A committed midfielder from 2000 to 2004, he has thrived in management at Hamilton, Norwich, Preston, Sunderland, and Stoke.
9. Garry Monk
His loan spell at Barnsley in 2002 was brief, but Monk eventually showed his tactical chops at Swansea City in the Premier League, as well as Leeds, Boro, Birmingham, and Sheffield Wednesday. Known for his methodical approach and modern coaching style.
10. Darren Moore
An imposing centre‐back for Barnsley in the late 90s, Moore made headlines as an astute caretaker‐turned‐manager at West Bromwich Albion and later at Doncaster and Sheffield Wednesday. His calm demeanour and track record of improving squads has made him a rising star in management.
Now it’s over to you—which of these ex‐Reds players do you wish had come back to manage Barnsley? Cast your vote in our “Who’s the best manager Barnsley haven’t had?” poll and let’s see who tops the fan rankings!