Pedestrian's death reignites debate about e-bike safety in NYC

NEW YORK (PIX11) -- E-bikes have become an increasingly popular mode of transportation in New York City, offering a convenient and eco-friendly alternative to cars.

However, their rapid rise has also brought pressing safety concerns to neighborhoods like Greenpoint, Brooklyn. Residents are now grappling with how to balance the benefits of e-bikes with the challenges they pose to pedestrian safety.

The recent death of Luis Cruz, a 49-year-old man struck by an e-bike while crossing Franklin Street near India Street in Greenpoint, has reignited debates about e-bike safety. The accident occurred last Friday evening, leaving Cruz with fatal head injuries. The e-bike rider remained at the scene, and no charges have been filed as the investigation continues.

This tragic event underscores growing concerns among residents about reckless e-bike usage. Alisa Etschork, a Greenpoint resident, expressed frustration over the lack of helmet use and proper regulation among riders. “The people who ride e-bikes tend to not have helmets, which makes me think they're not normal bike riders,” she said.

While pedestrian fatalities involving e-bikes remain relatively rare — totaling six between 2021 and 2024 — there were 923 pedestrian injuries involving all types of bikes during this period.

In response to incidents like Cruz’s death, city officials are considering new legislation to improve accountability for e-bike riders. A proposed bill known as "Priscilla's Law" would require all e-bikes and e-scooters to be registered and display license plates. Advocates argue that such measures would help curb reckless behavior and ensure safer streets for all road users.

Nate Cosby, an e-bike rider and Greenpoint resident, supports better regulation. “I cannot go successfully 20 mph for a long amount of time on my own, but my bike allows me to do that, so I have to be extra cautious,” he explained.

To address safety concerns, the Department of Transportation (DOT) launched its "Get Smart Before You Start" campaign last year. The initiative educates riders on safe e-bike operation, including proper acceleration, braking techniques, and speed control. Additionally, the DOT has issued guidelines for riders:

• Stay off sidewalks
• Wear helmets
• Yield to pedestrians
• Watch for turning vehicles