A ‘Sputnik Moment’ for America’s Schools
The stock market panicked at the end of January on news that the Chinese start-up DeepSeek had made an artificial intelligence model that is more efficient than anything American companies have produced thus far. In response, former presidential candidate Vivek Ramaswamy posted to X, “Sputnik-like moments are a good thing,” referring to the episode that kicked off the Space Race in 1957, when the Soviet Union was able to outcompete America by launching the first-ever satellite into space. “We don’t need to freak out; we just need to wake up,” Ramaswamy continued.
“If our schools fail, it will not be because we care too much for our ideals but because we care too little.”
A few days later, another piece of news broke that confirmed Ramaswamy’s intuition: last year’s results from the National Assessment of Educational Progress revealed that American eighth graders’ reading skills have fallen to the lowest they’ve ever been in the exam’s three-decade history. While the abysmal performance of our schools didn’t set off any stock market jitters, maybe it should have: if today’s children aren’t able to read proficiently, tomorrow’s American innovation economy — including but not limited to AI — will inevitably decline, and with it our global standing.
But it doesn’t have to be this way — and in fact, the Space Race that Americans started out losing but eventually won provides precisely the blueprint for how our approach to education must change if we don’t want to fall behind.
President Eisenhower initially downplayed the Sputnik crisis, to the point of calling the satellite “one small ball in the air” and claiming that the Soviets might have gained a “psychological advantage” on a political level but not on a scientific level. Whether or not he was right in a purely technical sense was irrelevant: it was ultimately political and psychological motivation that drove America to land the first man on the moon 12 years later.
Aviation Week Editor-in-Chief Robert Hotz called for an investigation in the aftermath of Sputnik in a scathing editorial criticizing the government and the public: “[Americans] also have a right to make the decisions as to whether they want their government to maintain our current leadership of the free world regardless of time, cost in dollars and sweat, or whether they wish to supinely abdicate this position in favor of enjoying a few more years of the hedonistic prosperity that now enfolds our country.”
In other words, the question Americans had to ask themselves then was the same question Americans must ask ourselves today: Do we maintain our economy, our standing, and our self-respect, or are we content to free ride off the accomplishments of our hardworking predecessors and let the rest of the world outcompete and outperform us? Thankfully, when confronted with potential Soviet ascension, Americans — government officials, yes, but also ordinary citizens — could not have more firmly rejected the latter option or more strongly embraced the former.
Understanding that there would be no American technological advancement without good schools, Americans turned to reforming the education system. One of the most-read magazines of the time, Life, ran a four-part series in 1958 shedding light on the various problems in American schools that were making America lag behind the Soviet Union. Science fairs and clubs became more common, as did comprehensive career preparation for students with scientific aptitude. Schools also taught democratic values so that students would grow up to be good, productive citizens who believed in their country and its promise.
As the President’s Science Advisory Committee wrote in a 1959 report titled, “Education in the Age of Science,” the great — and unique — proposition of the American education system has always been simple: “that most of our children shall have a long educational experience, that no child shall be deprived of the fullest opportunity to develop his own talents, and that the people of each local community shall, to a large degree, be autonomous in the decisions they make about the education of their own children.”
They acknowledged that the best part of such a system was that no one in it would be considered superior or inferior simply on the basis of his or her talents. The downside, however, was that healthy unpretentiousness could sometimes devolve into an unhealthy “[fear of] the word ‘excellent,’” as the Committee warned, and a subsequent satisfaction with mediocrity. This observation, from over six decades ago, rings true even today: if a third of eighth graders can’t read, as the latest data shows, that means we have tolerated not just mediocrity but outright failure in the name of sparing feelings and maintaining the status quo despite its rapid decay.
America Must Respond
Today, we can look back on the reaction to Sputnik with the chuckle of hindsight, knowing that America not only won the Space Race, but the Cold War. That victory, however, was only possible because of the efforts Americans made, starting with their acknowledgement that their school system was failing, and their decision to fix it.
This should give us hope: it’s still possible for Americans today to create a system in which schools are held accountable for instructing their students, in which good teachers are valued, in which students’ academic gifts are honored, and in which we expect and demand excellence. Accepting anything less than that is not only unacceptable but un-American.
As novelist and education reformer Sloan Wilson put it in a 1958 Life issue on the differences between American and Soviet education, “The United States was the first nation in the world to provide schools for all children, and that is one reason we have prospered. If our schools fail, it will not be because we care too much for our ideals but because we care too little.”
READ MORE on Education:
America’s Promise: Classically Educated Kids
When DEI Ends, Just Call it Something Else
Neeraja Deshpande is a policy analyst and engagement coordinator at Independent Women’s Forum (iwf.org).
The post A ‘Sputnik Moment’ for America’s Schools appeared first on The American Spectator | USA News and Politics.