Amsterdam Club Slammed for ‘Gaslighting,’ ‘Lying,’ Succumbing to Pressure to Cancel Israeli Comedian’s Shows

An improv theater and comedy club in The Netherlands is being heavily criticized for “caving” to pressure from pro-Palestinian activists and making an “outrageous” decision to cancel performances by an Israeli stand-up comedian, while also allegedly lying about security concerns expressed by local police.

Israeli stand-up comedian Yohay Sponder was originally scheduled to perform two shows on Jan. 25 at Boom Chicago, located in Amsterdam, as part of his world tour called “Self-Loving Jew.” Sponder, who is based in Israel, is beginning the European leg of his tour in London this week and the second stop was scheduled to be in Amsterdam.

“Sponder is a comedian; his mission in life is to bring joy and laughter to people. He’s not looking for a fight. That being said, he is unapologetically proud to be Jewish and Israeli,” Kayla Sponder, who is the comedian’s booking manager and wife, told The Algemeiner on Monday. She added that her team is “incredibly disappointed” by Boom Chicago’s decision to cancel Yohay’s two shows after it faced criticism and backlash from pro-Palestinian activists.

“I knew that there would be feelings and reactions to a show that’s called ‘Self-Loving Jew,’ even though the message is self-love,” she explained. “We’re not tone deaf to the climate in Europe and the world, so we knew this was coming, I just didn’t expect it from club owners and venues. I expected protests and pushback, but it’s very disappointing. It’s a sad day not just for the Jewish community, but for culture and the arts when freedom of expression and freedom of speech is silenced and it’s not backed up.”

“I think they were honest about the concerns that were raised,” she added about Boom Chicago. “I think the concerns were real … [But] I think they made the wrong decision. They caved.” The venue’s decision even sparked backlash from politicians in The Netherlands who called the move “outrageous” and demanded that the country’s minister of education, culture, and science get involved to protect Jewish artists like Sponder.

Kayla explained to The Algemeiner that she had been working with Boom Chicago for roughly the last two months to coordinate Yohay’s performances on Jan. 25 at the venue. The first show sold out and the second show was nearly sold out.

“Everything was great. We had a great working relationship [with Boom Chicago]. Everything was running really smoothly until about two weeks ago,” Kayla said, before explaining an incident that took place at the comedy club.

A pro-Palestinian activist had walked into Boom Chicago, criticized the venue for allowing a Zionist Jewish comedian to perform there, and declared “Free Palestine.” After the incident, Boom Chicago’s sales and events coordinator told Kayla that Yohay’s performance at the venue would move forward but the club had some security concerns they wanted to discuss with her over a Zoom call.

Kayla said she and her team were already planning on hiring private security even prior to the incident, “because we’re not tone deaf to the current climate in Europe.” Only two months ago, fans of the Israeli soccer team Maccabi Tel Aviv were targeted with antisemitic violence and physically assaulted, and even run over by cars, in the streets of Amsterdam.

“The security and safety of Yohay’s fans, staff that is working with him, and of course his own safety is top priority,” Kayla said.

When Kayla had a Zoom meeting with two staff members of Boom Chicago, including its head of sales and events, they told her the pro-Palestinian activist who entered the club sent them an email and informed them about more organized efforts by anti-Israel groups to protest and boycott Yohay’s shows on Jan. 25. Online groups, such as one called Student Intifada NL, baselessly called Yohay a “genocide glorifier” and an “ultra-Zionist” who “makes jokes based on Israeli propaganda.”

In response, Kayla told Boom Chicago her team would be in touch with private security companies, increase security at the shows on Jan. 25, and pay for it out of pocket. At the time of the Zoom call, the venue still gave her the impression that the shows would take place, she told The Algemeiner. 

On Friday morning, however, Boom Chicago’s director Andrew Moskos sent an email to Kayla. He said that after speaking to police in Amsterdam, the venue decided to cancel Yohay’s shows for security reasons.

“Due to the climate in Amsterdam, public reactions, and concerns from the police, we cannot allow Yohay Sponder’s performance at Boom Chicago on Jan. 25 to continue,” Moskos wrote in an email to Kayla that was shared with The Algemeiner. “Boom Chicago has always stood for free speech. This is not a decision we take lightly.”

“The situation is tense here, we got a lot of feedback, police was concerned about the performance as well. At the end of the day we just can’t go forward with this right now,” Moskos wrote in subsequent emails. “It is just a complicated situation, it’s almost the most complicated moment of a complicated situation, those 50 Maccabi [soccer] fans certainly didn’t help the situation, that is for sure. That’s what sort of kickstarted the situation.”

Even during phone calls about the decision, Moskos repeatedly told Kayla that Amsterdam police had expressed security concerns about the performances. Kayla told The Algemeiner that when she asked Moskos directly if the request to cancel Yohay’s shows had come from police, he responded, “It has not come to that yet, but I think that that decision will and I don’t want to wait for that to come…we have negative advice is what where we are.”

However, the Amsterdam-based publication NL Times reported that Amsterdam police and the office of Mayor Femke Halsem denied any involvement in Boom Chicago’s decision. A police spokesperson was also cited as saying that they did not know about Yohay’s performances and never discussed security concerns with the venue.

“It seems like they [Boom Chicago] weren’t being honest,” Kayla told The Algemeiner. “Someone’s lying. They can’t be both telling the truth.”

Moskos also said in emails to Kayla throughout the weekend that Boom Chicago would help her team find a “Jewish venue or club space in Amsterdam that might accommodate you.” Kayla said the Boom Chicago team never ended up sending her suggestions for other venues.

“Who might be available at this late notice and willing to take the heat?” Moskos wrote in one email.

“He sent the most gaslighting email ever,” Kayla said. “I didn’t create this situation, I didn’t create the ‘heat.’ I didn’t create this ‘late notice.'”

In the aftermath of the event being canceled, Kayla said the Jewish community and pro-Israel allies have reached out and offered to help, showing what she called “an immense amount of support.” Her team tried to find an alternative venue in Amsterdam to keep Yohay’s shows on Jan. 25 but to no avail. They hope to bring his shows to Amsterdam at a later date.

In April, Boom Chicago will host a performance by Palestinian comedian Sammy Obeid, who recently concluded a tour called “Ceasefire.” Obeid has regularly posted anti-Israel messages on social media, accusing the country of genocide, comparing it to the Hezbollah terrorist organization, and criticizing US support for the Jewish state. He often makes jokes about Israel and has even done stand-up comedy routines ridiculing Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

When The Algemeiner contacted Boom Chicago for a comment, and asked for them to clarify their involvement with Amsterdam police before making the decision to cancel Yohay’s show, Boom Chicago CEO Saskia Maas referred to a statement posted on the venue’s website.

“Unfortunately, following the announcement of the show, we received significant negative reactions, both online and from our visitors. Some of these responses were outright threatening,” they said in part. “As a result, we began to worry about the safety of our performers, audience, and colleagues. Therefore, we made the difficult decision to cancel the performance.”

“We are deeply saddened that this situation has escalated into a polarized debate about Gaza,” they added. “In our 32 years of existence, we have never experienced anything like this. Very nasty criticism has come at us from all sides, even though we genuinely tried to do what was best for everyone. We are using this experience to learn and grow. In the future, we will involve the City of Amsterdam immediately whenever safety concerns arise. Thankfully, we are now working closely with them on next steps.”

Boom Chicago concluded by saying that it will host an open discussion about the role of comedy in 2025. “The goal is to foster understanding and dialogue among diverse perspectives, without restrictions. We hope we can have a future where that is possible because humor can help bring people closer: Life is better when you laugh together.”

The post Amsterdam Club Slammed for ‘Gaslighting,’ ‘Lying,’ Succumbing to Pressure to Cancel Israeli Comedian’s Shows first appeared on Algemeiner.com.