Add news
News Every Day |

‘Anomaly’ about trials under army act baffles SC judge

4

ISLAMABAD: Supreme Court Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail on Wednesday expressed surprise at an apparent anomaly in the Pakistan Army Act 1952 (PAA), observing that despite the presence of Sections 2(1)(d)(i) and (ii) that allowed the court martial of civilians, terrorists involved in crimes such as kidnapping a soldier for ransom, would still not face a military trial.

Justice Mandokhail made these remarks as the seven-member Constitutional Bench took up the intra-court appeals against the Oct 23, 2023 judgement that nullified the military trials of civilians accused of involvement in the May 9 violence.

Sections 2(1)d(i) and 2(1)(d)(ii) of the Pakistan Army Act allow the court martial of civilians otherwise not subject to the act if they are accused of seducing or attempting to seduce any army officer from duty or allegiance to the government or committed offence in relation to any work of defence, arsenal, military establishment or station etc.

In its Oct 23 judgment, the five-judge Supreme Court had declared these sections as ultra vires of the Constitution.

During the hearing, Justice Mandokhail questioned whether any nexus existed when terrorists attacked the Peshawar Army Public School (APS) in 2014 and questioned why their cases were never tried in military courts despite Sections 2(1)(d)(i) and (ii).

Justice Mandokhail wonders terrorists involved in violence against army men not liable to face military justice

Justice Mandokhail also alluded to a query previously raised by Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi, who questioned why the perpetrators of the 2009 GHQ attack or the 2011 PNS Mehran Naval headquarters attack — in which even sophisticated surveillance aircraft were destroyed — were not tried in military courts, but noted that the answer to this question lied in the 21st Amendment to the Constitution.

Justice Rizvi brought up a recent incident in which terrorists kidnapped 17 individuals, later releasing eight of them, and highlighted instances wherein certain army officers were freed following negotiations.

Khawaja Haris Ahmed, who represented the defence ministry, stated that at the time of the APS attack, the nexus was absolutely there, while also conceding that the army act and the Official Secrets Act (OSA) were in place at the time of this tragedy.

Justice Naeem Akhtar Afghan, while pointing towards the senior counsel, said that we also have to consider the intention of the legislator behind the 21st Amendment under which military courts were established with a sunset clause of two years.

Justice Rizvi, without naming anyone, referred to former Senate chairman Raza Rabbani who had signed the amendment with tears in his eyes.

“Perhaps he realised what the parliamentarians were doing, but felt his hands were tied,” Justice Mandokhail remarked. He added the Senate chairman would merely have risked his position had he resisted the amendment.

Khawaja Haris, however, replied that he would not comment on the issue since he respected him a lot for his great contribution to parliament.

Referring to Article 8(3)(a) of the Constitution, the counsel explained that no challenge to any trial before the military court could be raised under Article 184(3) of the Constitution on the touchstone of fundamental rights.

The counsel also cited the 2015 amendment in Section 2(1)(d)(iii) that stated any person who belongs to or supports a terrorist group and commits certain acts is subject to punishment under the Pakistan Army Act. At this, Justice Mandokhail reiterated that such terrorists or groups would not be tried by the military courts even today.

That’s why the 21st Amendment was introduced so that no challenge could be instituted on the basis of the fundamental rights, the counsel said, adding whatever came under Article 8(3) of the Constitution would be protected from any challenge under the fundamental rights.

The counsel argued that the nature of the crime determined where the trial would go, adding if the civilians were involved in crimes related to the armed forces, the military court would try such civilians.

Procedure for trials Justice Muhammad Ali Mazhar asked the counsel about a comparative study highlighting what procedure was adopted for the military trials, adding the court has to examine whether the accused facing military trial had access to a lawyer of their choice and whether the evidence was provided.

The counsel contended that in case the Supreme Court declared sections 2(1)(d)Ii) and (ii) of the PAA as valid law under the touchstone of Article 8(3), then the petitions challenging trials of the civilians by the military courts would have to be dec­lared inadmissible and not maintainable.

In a lighter vein at the fag end of the proceedings, senior counsel Faisal Siddiqi said that after hearing the arguments of Khawaja Haris, the lawyers were thinking of starting practising in military courts.

At this, Justice Mazhar observed let the court decide the matter and then whoever would like to practise, go and do it.

Published in Dawn, January 16th, 2025

Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Here’s more of what you’ll see through Meta’s $1,000 smart glasses

Will AI ever cure cancer? The multibillion-dollar race to bring the first AI-discovered drug to market

Tesla shares sink as deliveries miss forecasts by 'wide margin': report

Darts star leaks World Championship payslip as he reveals long list of ‘deductions’ left him with just £5,200 winnings

Ria.city
Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Осторожно, 1 стакан сжигает 3 кг жира! Запишите рецепт...

Вот это точно убьет лишний вес! -17кг за 5 дней! Перед сном съешьте...






Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "3 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...


Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "3 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...

Read also

Trump tariffs: five scenarios for the world's economy

'Parade of humiliation' has engulfed Elon Musk in just the last day: CNN Business reporter

Today's political cartoons - April 3, 2025

News Every Day |

The Ashton Jeanty Bears Smoke Just Got Even Thicker

The draft is three weeks away now. GM Ryan Poles and head coach Ben Johnson have pieced together an off-season that is earning widespread praise across the league. The question is whether they can stick the landing with their 1st round pick in the draft. Current projections have the top three picks likely being a mix of Cam Ward, Travis Hunter, and Abdul Carter. After that, it gets tricky. People in Chicago want to know where running back Ashton Jeanty will end once the dust settles.

Widespread belief has been that the Las Vegas Raiders are the heavy favorites to take him at 6th overall, with New Orleans at #9 also being a possibility. It makes sense. Las Vegas’ best option right now is a 33-year-old Raheem Mostert. New Orleans knows Alvin Kamara turns 30 in July. Both teams need to think about the future at that position. Both have head coaches who like to run the ball. One thing is clear. A source told SM that those around the league believe one thing is certain.

“He likely won’t get passed Chicago if he falls that far.”

Ashton Jeanty is a strong probability for the Bears.

Whispers from Halas Hall indicate they love the Boise State star. It isn’t hard to see why. He nearly broke Barry Sanders’ single-season rushing record in 2024, nearly winning the Heisman in the process. The guy carried his team to the college football playoffs. He’s built like a brick house with power, speed, contact balance, and vision. There aren’t any truly glaring weaknesses in his game. He’s earned comparisons to the likes of LaDainian Tomlinson and Marshawn Lynch. The Bears haven’t had a back of that caliber since Matt Forte.

Try to imagine what this offense could look like with Ashton Jeanty, Rome Odunze, D.J. Moore, and Cole Kmet all as options for quarterback Caleb Williams. Throw all of it into Johnson’s offense, and you can understand why some people around the league aren’t wild about the idea. They are quietly hoping Jeanty goes somewhere else. One thing is certain. If he gets past the Raiders, the noise will get loud in a hurry. It would mark the first time in 20 years the Bears have taken a running back in the 1st round.

Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this

Ria.city
Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "3 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...






Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "3 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...


Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "3 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...

Read also

Cikakken Tarihin Rabiu Rikadawa: Fitaccen Jarumin Kannywood da Nollywood » Labaran Yau

Laurence Fishburne Reveals He Offered to Be in ‘The Matrix Resurrections’ But ‘They Didn’t Respond Well’

76ers sign Colin Castleton

News, articles, comments, with a minute-by-minute update, now on Today24.pro

News Every Day

Tesla shares sink as deliveries miss forecasts by 'wide margin': report

Today24.pro — latest news 24/7. You can add your news instantly now — here


News Every Day

T-Mobile closes Lumos deal after dropping DEI



Sports today


Новости тенниса
Надежда Петрова

Петрова презентует книгу «Теннис. Методические рекомендации» 5 апреля в Москве



Спорт в России и мире
Москва

Росгвардейцы обеспечили безопасность матча ВХЛ в Челябинске



All sports news today





Sports in Russia today

Москва

ТАСС: рассмотрение дела блогера Шабутдинова перенесли на 17 апреля


Новости России

Game News

Call of Duty will finally let console players turn off crossplay to dodge PC cheaters, which is potentially terrible news for all the legit PC players


Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this

Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this

Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Russian.city

Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine


Эстрада

На сцене Театра Эстрады пройдёт Музыкальный фестиваль «Ровесники Победы»


Губернаторы России
Дональд Трамп

Mirror: Кремль резко отреагировал на угрозы Трампа — поведение Путина удивило Британию


Инжиниринговый центр в Москве: новый этап для российских производителей

НАТО СПОСОБНО НАНЕСТИ ЯДЕРНЫЙ УДАР ПО США И ЕВРОПЕ? НАТО СДЕЛАНО ДЛЯ ЭТОГО. СЕНСАЦИЯ! НОВОСТИ! СПЕЦOПЕРАЦИЯ "ЗИС". Россия, США, Европа могут улучшить отношения и здоровье общества?!

Когда слово объединяет: ГПМ Радио приглашает на «Тотальный диктант»

ТОП-5 лазерных устройств для татуажа в 2025 году: что нужно знать?


«Несчастный случай»: директор цинкового завода Павел Избрехт погиб под Челябинском

Кураторские Плейлисты.

«Не для работы создан я»: почему Прохор Шаляпин стал кумиром молодежи

Карди Би обвинила отца своих детей в покушении на убийство


Вероника Кудерметова одержала разгромную победу на старте турнира WTA-500 в Чарльстоне

Бухарест (ATP). 2-й круг. Гаске сыграет с Коболли, Баутиста-Агут – с Комесаньей, Баес – с Уго Карабелли

Медведев вылетел из топ-10 рейтинга ATP, Рублёв стал первой ракеткой России

12-е место в мировом рейтинге WTA, нелюбовь к России и нетрадиционная ориентация Касаткиной


Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine


Компания enKod на Global Tech Forum: как технологии меняют маркетинг

Инжиниринговый центр в Москве: новый этап для российских производителей

Конкурс «Построй свой мир с Турбозаврами» стартовал на телеканале «Мультиландия»

Московский Экономический Форум: главное


На курорте «Манжерок» состоялся Чемпионат СибМастерс среди любителей и ветеранов горнолыжного спорта

Юрист Хаминский: экс-жена Уткина может претендовать на часть его наследства

Руководитель фракции КПРФ в Мособлдуме Александр Наумов посетил отчет главы г.о. Домодедово

Глава Бурятии рассчитывает на «руку Москвы» в лице президента Путина


Аварийный жилой дом снесли в Серпухове

РОССИЯ И ДОНАЛЬД ТРАМП СПАСАЮТ США ОТ ЭКОНОМИЧЕСКОГО РАБСТВА?! СЕНСАЦИЯ! УЛУЧШИТЬ ПЕРЕГОВОРЫ! Новости. В.В. Путин. Россия, США, Европа могут улучшить отношения и здоровье общества?!

Более 25 медиахудожников и музыкантов из 11 стран примут участие в международного фестивале мультимедийного искусства INTERVALS

ТОП-5 лазерных устройств для татуажа в 2025 году: что нужно знать?


Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this


Путин в России и мире
Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this



Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine



Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this



Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this

Персональные новости Russian.city
Баста

Большой сольный концерт Басты в Новокузнецке: легенда хип-хопа раскачает дворец спорта



News Every Day

Darts star leaks World Championship payslip as he reveals long list of ‘deductions’ left him with just £5,200 winnings




Friends of Today24

Музыкальные новости

Персональные новости