Add news
News Every Day |

Honolulu’s climate claims and how they affect the ‘interests’ of the U.S.

7
WND

The Office of the Solicitor General — part of the Department of Justice —was created by the Statutory Authorization Act of June 22, 1870. The Act states that there shall be an officer “learned in the law,” to be called the Solicitor General, to assist the Attorney General in the performance of his or her duties. The “mission of OSG is to represent the interests of the United States before the Supreme Court and to oversee appellate and certain other litigation on behalf of the United States in the lower federal and state courts.”

The term “interests of the United States” is not defined in the Act, and it is obvious that any administration has an interest in keeping it undefined so as to keep its options open with respect to its future positions on legal questions that emerge. Can anyone believe that the political interests of a given administration will not affect its positions on “the interests of the United States? Those positions might be wholly inconsistent with the interests of the U.S. economy or citizenry or taxpayers or the many other groupings that could be subsumed under the heading “interests of the United States,” as distinct from the political interests of the current administration.

Which brings us to the climate case that the U.S. Supreme Court soon will decide as to whether to grant certiorari: Sunoco LP ET. AL. v City and County of Honolulu, Hawaii, ET. AL. In a nutshell: The City and County of Honolulu, pursuing litigation against the energy producers for — don’t laugh — having knowingly caused the purported climate crisis, won a ruling in the Hawaii Supreme Court to the effect that federal law does not preempt state/local legal actions. Accordingly, the Honolulu lawsuit was directed by the Hawaii Supreme Court to proceed in state court under Hawaii state law rather than federal law, despite several contrary rulings in federal courts that claims arising from greenhouse gas emissions are the purview of federal law and Congress.

The OSG has entered the case as an amicus curiae, but what is notable is that nowhere in its brief does OSG tell us what the “interest of the United States” is in the context of this case. Instead, the OSG brief merely asserts that it is in the interest of the United States that the “petitions for writs of certiorari should be denied,” because “this Court’s resolution of the federal issue ‘can await final judgment [after the case works its way through the Hawaii and federal courts] without any adverse effect upon important federal interests.’”

The OSG takes this position despite admitting (page 12) that “petitioners may ultimately prevail on their contention that respondents’ claims are barred by the Constitution — specifically, the Interstate and Foreign Commerce Clauses, the Due Process Clause, and federal constitutional structure — to the extent the claims rely on conduct occurring outside Hawaii.” Indeed, the OSG cites a precedent to the effect that “principles of state sovereignty and comity” mean “that a State may not impose economic sanctions on violators of its laws with the intent of changing the tortfeasors’ lawful conduct in other States.” No one claims that the ordinary business operations of the fossil producers — the production and sale of fossil fuels — was unlawful.

Nor does OSG argue — any such argument would not pass a laugh test — that “awai[ting] final judgment” would fail to create enormous costs for the fossil producers and for the economy as a whole. Instead, OSG argues implicitly that litigation inconsistent with “the Interstate and Foreign Commerce Clauses, the Due Process Clause, and federal constitutional structure” would not affect the “interests of the United States.” Seriously?

Put those constitutional issues aside. Do the “interests of the United States” not include national energy policies and the aggregate cost of fuels, employment, the effect of the Hawaii and similar litigation on national wealth, international trade flows for the U.S., and numerous other major parameters of U.S. economic performance? Do they not include a forced substitution of one set of environmental impacts attendant upon the use of fossil fuels with another set caused by the available alternatives? As the costs of energy rise hugely but unevenly across the country, do the “interests of the United States” not encompass the large resulting economic shifts and dislocations? Etc.

The Supreme Court should grant certiorari on this case. There is a clear conflict between several federal court rulings, specifically and most clearly the Second Circuit’s dismissal of New York City’s virtually identical lawsuit in 2021and the ruling by the Hawaii Supreme Court. Both court rulings reveal a conflict on the issue of whether federal law precludes claims brought under state law and whether a given state may apply its laws to address purported injuries caused by emissions from another state. Moreover, the Hawaii Supreme Court decision clearly is incorrect: Interstate emissions, international emissions, and negotiations with foreign governments inherently are issues for the federal government to address.

Back to the OSG amicus brief: It is a purely political document, reflecting the Biden administration efforts to force a substitution of expensive and unreliable unconventional energy in place of fossil fuels that have proven competitively superior for over a century. The arguments that the OSG’s brief presents have nothing to do with “the interests of the United States,” notwithstanding the various assertions presented therein. A grant of certiorari in this case implicitly will send a signal that the OSG arguments are poor and that future such briefs from OSG should substitute rigor in place of political posturing. That alone would be a real service for the true interests of the U.S.

 

Benjamin Zycher is a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. 
This article was originally published by RealClearEnergy and made available via RealClearWire.
Москва

Вдохновленный классикой в Симферополе стартовало строительство жилого комплекса «Моне»

Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Apple aims to build most iPhones for U.S. in India by end-2026

DOGE’s mass federal workforce cuts may cost taxpayers $135 billion this fiscal year alone

When will Liverpool lift the Premier League trophy?

World Champion’s Team Reveal ‘The Truth’ Of Conor Benn Sparring After Being Branded A Quitter

Ria.city
Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "28 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...






Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "28 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...


Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "28 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...

Read also

More than 100 undocumented immigrants detained in Colorado nightclub raid: DEA

Voting Open For Hibs End Of Season Awards

Second illegal migrant accused in Kristi Noem’s purse snatching ID’d, was released into US despite being handed notice of ‘expedited removal’

News, articles, comments, with a minute-by-minute update, now on Today24.pro

News Every Day

Apple aims to build most iPhones for U.S. in India by end-2026

Today24.pro — latest news 24/7. You can add your news instantly now — here


News Every Day

Evander Holyfield Names The One Heavyweight Champion Who ‘Embarrassed’ Him In The Ring



Sports today


Новости тенниса
Андрей Рублёв

Рублев проиграл Бублику в третьем круге «Мастерса» в Мадриде, Медведев станет первой ракеткой России



Спорт в России и мире
Москва

В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов



All sports news today





Sports in Russia today

Москва

В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов


Новости России

Game News

Popular board game publisher CMON—creator of Zombicide and Marvel United—is putting all future projects on hold and laying off creatives as tariffs continue to wreak havoc on the industry


Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this

Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this

Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Russian.city

Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine


Москва

Сергей Собянин сообщил о планах благоустройства вылетных магистралей


Губернаторы России
Ильхам Алиев

Новые контуры Закавказья: Алиев разворачивается на Восток, Европа теряет влияние в регионе


Сергей Собянин: Москва — мировая лидер по скорости прибытия скорой помощи

В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов

В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов

В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов


Волочкова покинула свадьбу дочери в спешке: скандал с женихом и неожиданное объяснение

В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов

"Тест показал, что я беременна". Валентина Иванова подогрела слухи о том, что ждёт ребёнка от Тимати

Снуп Догг рассказал, какой он на самом деле отец и дедушка


Бублик о победе над Рублевым: он лучше меня во всем, но я творец, художник

Россиянка Александрова вышла в четвертый круг теннисного турнира WTA в Мадриде

Александрова обыграла Данилович во втором круге турнира в Испании

Александрова достигла четвертьфинала на турнире WTA 1000



В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов

В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов

В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов

В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов


Газзаев: Надежная игра в обороне становится визитной карточкой ЦСКА

В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов

Кабинет Артиста в Яндекс. Кабинет Артиста в Яндекс Музыке. 

Пашиняну дали понять, что все будет так, как решат Россия и США


Сегодня в Дубне сделал остановку первый теплоход

Мишустин: Рост ВВП России превышает 4%, обгоняя развитые страны

Собянин рассказал о проекте «Серебряное наставничество»

ЖК «Поэма» — территория вдохновения и комфортной жизни


Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this


Путин в России и мире
Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this





Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this



Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Персональные новости Russian.city
Анастасия Волочкова

Зять Волочковой Никита Григорян сообщил, что свадьба с Ариадной состоялась



News Every Day

DOGE’s mass federal workforce cuts may cost taxpayers $135 billion this fiscal year alone




Friends of Today24

Музыкальные новости

Персональные новости