Add news
News Every Day |

Fact-Checking Was Too Good for Facebook

Yesterday, Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg announced that Facebook would end fact-checking on its platform. In the process, a partnership with the network of third parties that has provided review and ratings of viral misinformation since 2016 will be terminated. To some observers, this news suggested that the company was abandoning the very idea of truth, and opening its gates to lies, perversions, and deception. But this is wrong: Those gates were never really closed.

The idea that something called “fact-checking” could be (or could have been) reasonably applied to social-media posts, in aggregate, is absurd. Social-media posts can be wrong, of course, even dangerously so. And single claims from single posts can sometimes be adjudicated as being true or false. But the formulation of those distinctions and decisions is not fact-checking, per se.

That’s because fact-checking is, specifically, a component part of doing journalism. It is a way of creating knowledge invented by one particular profession. I don’t mean that journalists have any special power to discern the truth of given statements. Naturally, people attempt to validate the facts they see, news-related or otherwise, all the time. But fact-checking, as a professional practice linked to the publication of news stories and nonfiction books, refers to something more—something that no social-media platform would ever try to do.

[Read: This is how much fact-checking is worth to Facebook]

Here at The Atlantic, every story we put out goes through a fact-checking process. That usually takes place after the story has been reported, written, and edited. Some of that process is pretty straightforward: A quote from a source might be verified against an interview recording or transcript; dates, locations, or statistics might be compared to the sources from which they were drawn.

Other aspects of the process are more discursive. Is the writer’s sentence fairly paraphrasing someone’s statement? Does it—and the publication—mean to present that person’s statement as informative, dubious, or something else? Sometimes additional research, follow-up interviews, and internal negotiations will be required. In some cases, fact-checking has more to do with evaluation, judgment, and wordsmithing than getting any single line “right” or “wrong.” The process can be very strange. It’s often time-consuming.

Outside of newsrooms, though, fact-checking has come to have a different meaning, and a smaller scope. It may describe the surface-level checks of claims made by politicians in live debates—or of assertions appearing in a dashed-off post on social media. Small-bore inspections like these can help reduce the spread of certain glaring fabrications, a potential benefit that is now excluded from Meta’s platforms by design. But that’s a whack-a-mole project, not a trust-building exercise that is woven into the conception, research, authorship, and publication of a piece of media.

Fact-checking, in this broader sense, assumes its practitioners’ good-faith effort to find or construct truth, and then to participate in the interactive process of verification. When done seriously and deliberately, it imbues a published work with an ethos of care. Journalists retain detailed records of their reporting, annotate them, and submit them with the stories they file. They may be asked to provide additional support or to consider possible objections. The scope of each claim undergoes consideration. Scene-setting—writing that describes a situation or environment—will be subjected to the fact-check, too. “Even the bathroom wallpaper had a bovine theme,” I wrote about a filling-station bathroom in a profile of the children’s author Sandra Boynton, who puts lots of cows in her books. The fact-checker asked if I could prove it. Having anticipated the question, I had taken a photo in the filling-station restroom. Would we have printed the line had I not done so? That’s not the point. Rather, such evidentiary concern suffused the entire effort, not just the part where someone made sure I wasn’t lying.

This process sometimes fails. It may be foiled by sloppiness or haste. But many posts on social media lack even the aspiration to be true. Some people posting may intend to mislead, coerce, or delude their audiences into believing, buying, or simply clicking. Others are less malicious, but still, as a rule, they are not engaged in journalism and do not necessarily share its values. That makes their content not lesser, but different in kind. On social media, people share their feelings, the things they saw, the images they made of the activities they performed (or pretended to perform). They comment, like, and share posts that spark delight or fear, and they may do so without too much concern for their effects on other people’s choices or opinions.

As I’ve written before, giving everyone with a smartphone the ability to say anything they want, as often as they want, to billions of people, is a terrible idea. In the deluge that results, verification is impossible. Sure, one might take the time to affirm or reject the truth of a tiny subset of the claims posted to a platform, but even modest efforts run afoul of the fact that different people post for different reasons, with different goals.

The effort Facebook attempted under the name fact-checking was doomed. You can’t nitpick every post from every random person, every hobby website, every brand, school, restaurant, militia lunatic, aunt, or dogwalker as if they were all the same. Along the way, Facebook’s effort also tarnished the idea that fact-checking could be something more. The platform’s mass deployment of surface-level checks gave the sense that sorting facts from falsehoods is not a subtle art but a simple and repeating task, one that can be algorithmically applied to any content. The profession of journalism, which has done a terrible job of explaining its work to the public, bears some responsibility for allowing—even encouraging—this false impression to circulate. But Facebook was the king of ersatz checking. Good riddance.

Москва

Россия в 2024 году осталась четвертой экономикой мира

Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

When will Liverpool lift the Premier League trophy?

DOGE’s mass federal workforce cuts may cost taxpayers $135 billion this fiscal year alone

Man arrested in San Leandro BART station stabbing

New York lawmakers are moving to shut down Elon Musk’s Tesla sales across the EV-friendly state

Ria.city
Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "29 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...






Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "29 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...


Read also

Chris Haynes on Damian Lillard: 'He's confident that he's going to attack this recovery and come back a better player'

Amnesty accuses Israel of 'live-streamed genocide' against Gaza Palestinians

CBB’s AJ Odudu reveals she SAW moment JoJo Siwa ended relationship with Kath Ebbs at wrap party

News, articles, comments, with a minute-by-minute update, now on Today24.pro

News Every Day

Man arrested in San Leandro BART station stabbing

Today24.pro — latest news 24/7. You can add your news instantly now — here


News Every Day

DOGE’s mass federal workforce cuts may cost taxpayers $135 billion this fiscal year alone



Sports today


Новости тенниса
Арина Соболенко

Соболенко победила Мертенс в третьем круге турнира в Мадриде



Спорт в России и мире
Москва

Экс-хоккеист Рыбин оценил перспективы игроков «Динамо» в НХЛ



All sports news today





Sports in Russia today

Москва

Сотрудники СОБР Росгвардии преодолели дистанцию «Московского полумарафона»


Новости России

Game News

Microsoft Recall finally launches for AI PC users, along with some other new features, almost one year after Copilot+ was announced


Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this

Russian.city


Москва

Суд оставил блогера Лерчек и ее бывшего мужа под домашним арестом


Губернаторы России
Певец

Певец Михайлов вспомнил, что в детстве мечтал о велосипеде


Источник 360.ru: задымление случилось в больнице на востоке Москвы

LG QNED evo 2025: ЖК-ТЕЛЕВИЗОРЫ ПРЕМИУМ-КЛАССА С УЛУЧШЕННЫМИ ВИЗУАЛЬНЫМИ ЭФФЕКТАМИ, ТЕХНОЛОГИЕЙ TRUE WIRELESS И ПЕРСОНАЛИЗИРОВАННЫМ ИИ

В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов

Исинбаева после отъезда из России купила элитную квартиру в Москве


Завершился раздел имущества певицы Алсу и бизнесмена Яна Абрамова

VK Fest впервые пройдет в Казани: названа площадка и первые артисты

«Будет и моя свадьба». Волочкова честно рассказала, как выдала замуж дочь

В Москве прошел чемпионат России по грэпплингу среди студентов


Рублев: Турнир в Дохе был действительно особенным

Россиянка Александрова вышла в четвертый круг теннисного турнира WTA в Мадриде

Александрова достигла четвертьфинала на турнире WTA 1000

Елена Рыбакина разгромила Бьянку Андрееску во втором круге турнира WTA-1000 в Мадриде



Фестиваль «Dance4Kids/Танец будущего» и Leo Classics объединяют юных танцовщиков со всей России

ЦСКА пробился в полуфинал, обыграв "Пари Нижний Новгород" в серии 3-0

Суд оставил блогера Лерчек и ее бывшего мужа под домашним арестом

Тренд 100 тысяч шагов: врач предупреждает об опасности для жизни


Гаман: Бизнес приобрел у города более 50 крупных помещений в столице

Холодная погода накроет Россию на майские праздники

РБК: участие в параде Победы в Москве подтвердили лидеры 19 стран

Выставка Build Ural открыла строительный сезон на Урале


"Угроза для кораблей": на Западе испугались российского оружия

Спрос на платные места в вузах Москвы оказался вчетверо выше среднего по России

БеКон-2025: Ваш билет в мир актуальной контейнерной безопасности

Конференция ко «Дню жертв геноцида армян в Османской империи» прошла в Москве


Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this


Путин в России и мире
Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this



Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine





Персональные новости Russian.city
PRomoPulse

Новая песня от NARGIZA для Российских слушателей "До встречи мама"



News Every Day

New York lawmakers are moving to shut down Elon Musk’s Tesla sales across the EV-friendly state




Friends of Today24

Музыкальные новости

Персональные новости