Our editors still swear by the Aritzia Super Puff years later — here's which styles have kept us warm over the last 3 winters

When you buy through our links, Business Insider may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Puffer jackets come in all sorts of shapes, sizes, and colors, but there are very few brands that offer an extensive variety of them all in one place. That's where the Aritzia Super Puff collection comes through. They're a more affordable luxury option than Moncler or Moose Knuckles, and to us, they achieve just about the same look and technical performance.

Just like luxury outerwear brands like Arc'teryx or Canada Goose, Aritzia is based in Canada, where the freezing winters are the ultimate test for down jackets. We've tested our own Super Puffs through seasons of icy winds and bitter cold, and still count them among the best women's winter coats and best men's winter coats you can buy.

At its debut in 2017, the Super Puff became a calling card for Aritzia. A campaign starring Kendall Jenner wearing a vivid red Super Puff made the rounds on Instagram, and now, you'll see them anywhere the temperature dips below 50 degrees. Below you'll find out why, with our style editors' reviews on the Super Puff's sizing, fit, and style options.

Super Puff Sizing

Anyone can wear any of Aritzia's Super Puff Jackets, but bear in mind that the Men's Super Puffs are bigger than Super Puffs designed for women.

Overall, we found all styles of the Super Puff to fit true to size. If you're in between sizes or want a roomier fit, we recommend sizing up, as you'll likely wear thick layers underneath the jackets during the winter. Sizing up will also achieve a more lofty, casual look.

The Original Super Puff

After growing tired of wearing a black parka for the past few winters, I decided to swap it out for one of Aritzia's Super Puff jackets. You're spoiled for choice when it comes to the Super Puff — there are almost too many options — but I love the matte blue color I chose, and it always draws compliments. I also went with the original style that falls just past hip-length, and it looks great with both jeans and workout leggings. 

The best part about the Super Puff is that it feels like being wrapped in a sleeping bag. I never want to take it off! I really like the fleece-lined pockets too. For sizing, I'm typically an XS but went with a 2XS because of the puffy style. It fits well, but the sleeve cuffs are a little tight. Like everyone else, I'd recommend going with your usual size. — Ashley Phillips, former style and beauty editor, Insider Reviews

The Men's Super Puff

Before Aritzia started making coats for men, I admired the Super Puff from afar. Whether it was a co-worker coming into the office or a stranger on the streets of New York City, I always thought the Super Puff looked amazing on women. It turns out that the men's version looks just as good, too. 

I went with the High Gloss Taupe Clair. I love that the Super Puff comes in a huge selection of colors and finishes — it gives you the opportunity to turn an essential item that often favors function over style into a statement piece. 

Super Puffs aren't all about looks, though — they're also equipped with serious cold weather protection. It features a lofty 700 fill-power using sustainably sourced down, a removable hood with adjustable cords, and storm cuffs to prevent cold air, rain, or snow from getting into your sleeves.  — Amir Ismael, editor, Insider Reviews

The Super Puff Long 

I tell this to everyone I know: The Super Puff from Aritzia is the best coat ever. I have two of the really long ones in different colors because I grew up in Florida and can't stand for any part of my body to be cold. It's so incredibly warm that I barely even realize how freezing it is when I'm outside! It's great in the snow thanks to its adjustable hood, and at the opening for your hands, there's an extra little sleeve with thumbholes that prevents any wind from getting in. It's the only coat I trust for the coldest, windiest, crappiest days of winter.

I'd recommend going with your usual size for the Super Puff. I'm between a medium and a large in most coats/tops and opted for the medium because I'm really short — so that was definitely the right call for me. If you're super tall and in between sizes, I'd recommend sizing up so you can layer chunky sweaters underneath. — Sally Kaplan, executive editor, Insider Reviews

The Super Puff Shorty

Living in Chicago means you can never have too many puffer coats. While the Aritzia Super Puff Shorty is not the only black winter coat I have in my closet, there are a few standout features that make it hard to resist reaching for. Its Liquid Shine black exterior has a shinier finish compared to my other jackets that give a sleek twist on the streetwear staple. Admittedly, it's easy for me to get behind any top with thumb holes. While this is the only coat I own with hand sleeves, it's one of those features that just makes sense.

Even though this coat is noticeably shorter than the others in the Super Puff collection, its fit is completely customizable. The hem is topped off with an adjustable cord that can be pulled taught and locked in place on either side. Luckily, the hood has the same corded detail which makes it easier to shield my face from brisk breezes in the windy city.  — Kayla Bickham, former style and beauty fellow, Insider Reviews

The Super Puff₂O

While all of the Super Puff silhouettes can absolutely handle light rain, it's not exactly the jacket you'd want to wear in a downpour. You might not get wet, but its outer layer is only water-resistant — not waterproof — which can lead to water seeping into the baffles. That's where the new Super Puff₂O comes into play. 

Featuring a 100% waterproof and windproof fabric, sealed seams and bonded channels, YKK AquaGuard zippers, and a non-removable integrated hood, the Super Puff₂O is well-equipped to keep you protected from rain. I haven't been caught in the rain yet, but based on the technical features compared to other winter jackets I've tested, it should have no problems when the time comes.

From the large and puffy baffles, to the warmth it provides, everything I love about the original Super Puff carries over to the Super Puff₂O.  

You won't find as many colors and finishes available as the Super Puff, but the colors that are available are easy to style and wear daily. I went with the Total Eclipse colorway, which is a shade of dark blue, and it's been one of my favorites to wear this season. 

At $100 more than the Super Puff, the Super Puff₂O is an excellent upgrade if you live in a rainy climate or if you simply want a more equipped jacket for the winter.  — Amir Ismael, editor, Insider Reviews

Materials and special features

The Aritzia Super Puff comes in a wide range of materials with different purposes and finishes:

• cliMATTE —Water-Repellent and Wind-Resistant
• (Re)CliMATTE — Water-Repellent and Wind-Resistant
• Hi-Gloss — Water-Repellent and Wind-Resistant
• (Re)Hi-Gloss - Water-Repellent and Wind-Resistant
• Rainstop — Waterproof and Windproof
• Satin Flex — Water-Resistant and Windproof
• Cushcord — Stretchy, Plush and Water-Resistant
• Hi-Vis — Reflective, Water-Resistant and Windproof
• Lacquer — Water-Repellent and Windproof
• Liquid Shine — Water-Resistant and Windproof

Regardless of what material you like best, you'll find useful features on Super Puff coats like brushed fleece-lined hand warmer pockets, removable hoods (with the exception of waterproof models), interior smartphone storage, "cinchable" waists, and storm wrist cuffs to keep cold air and snow from blowing up your sleeves.

Aritzia's return policy

When ordering online at Aritzia, you can receive a full refund within 14 days from the shipping date, or merchandise credit on an eGift Card within 30 days from the shipping date. During the holiday season, Aritzia will refund regular-priced items purchased as gifts until January 5. Due to its custom nature, The Super Puff Personalized is not eligible for returns or exchanges. Check here for full details on Artizia's return and exchange policies. 

The bottom line

Overall, Aritzia Super Puffs are a solid value. Even though the Super Puff Long is the most expensive version, it does provide full windproof coverage, so it's worth the spend if you live in a cold climate.

While none are particularly inexpensive, they're still more affordably priced in comparison to similar winter jackets. Each version is warm and well-equipped for cold weather, but also incredibly good-looking, regardless of how you define your style. The best part is that once you fall in love with the Super Puff, you can buy the exact same jacket in all of your favorite colors and finishes. 

Shop all Aritzia Super Puffs here.