Jalen Hurts proved his value (by not playing), 'Yer a Wizard, Joe Burrow' and 7 things we learned in Week 16
Week 16 presented some must-win games for teams across the NFL.
The Arizona Cardinals saw their playoff hopes evaporate against Bryce Young and the Carolina Panthers, marking their fourth loss in the last five weeks. The Los Angeles Rams firmed up their spot atop the NFC West with a comeback win over the increasingly hopeless New York Jets. The Atlanta Falcons, Indianapolis Colts, Miami Dolphins and Cincinnati Bengals all got victories that kept their slim playoff hopes alive.
So what can we glean from Week 16 as the postseason picture begins to come into focus? Well, Joe Burrow is having the best MVP season from a player with almost no chance to be MVP, the Detroit Lions are baffling in the best possible way and New York’s quarterback curse is taking root in other NFL franchises in unexpected ways.
What does that all mean? Let’s talk about Sunday’s action.
[Please bear with me for any Twitter embed issues. Our editing software has become a whole problem on that front the past couple weeks. Rest assured, if there’s a play alluded to in the text it’s worth clicking through to see if it didn’t make it into the article itself.]
1. The post Kirk Cousins Atlanta Falcons couldn’t have been clearer about their intentions
Dale Zanine-Imagn Images
Michael Penix emerged from his first NFL start with a win. Granted, it was over the New York Giants so it barely counts. Still, his arm strength and mobility from the pocket are a boon for a Falcons offense that had been severely limited by Cousins’s fading athleticism.
From Michael Penix Jr. did everything the Falcons couldn’t get from Kirk Cousins:
Penix wasn’t perfect, but he soared over a nearly subterranean bar against an overmatched opponent.
Play-action, layered throws from Michael Penix Jr. are what the #Falcons fell in love with throughout the predraft process… https://t.co/GplisvODXe pic.twitter.com/e45KQvNxJJ
— Jordan Schultz (@Schultz_Report) December 22, 2024
The Falcons didn’t reinvent their playbook around Penix. The shotgun snaps remained. He wasn’t given a directive to cut and run when pressured like fellow rookie Caleb Williams was given after Thomas Brown took over as the Chicago Bears’ interim offensive coordinator. He stood in the pocket and delivered clean passes through static, zipping the ball downfield on his best reads.
Michael Penix is ripping the ball.
Slow start but he had settled in and his connecting with Darnell Mooney. #Falcons pic.twitter.com/shMHdmX3SI
— Henry McKenna (@henrycmckenna) December 22, 2024
Cousins’s lack of mobility led to less time in the pocket, even against defenses that blitzed him less than ever (because they knew they just needed one guy to breach the pocket to create a problem). But when third-and-long situations made it easy and obvious to bring an extra pass rusher or two, things fell apart.
Cousins’s expected points added (EPA) per dropback dropped from neutral to negative when blitzed. In the five-game stretch that effectively closed the books on his Atlanta tenure, the Falcons converted 23 of 67 third downs — a 34.3 percent conversion rate roughly on par with the New England Patriots’ woeful offense this fall (fourth-worst in the NFL).
Penix, on the other hand, showed more comfort in the face of pressure.
3rd downs aren't scary anymore pic.twitter.com/7FrxcT9G0A
— Tre’Shon (@tre3shon) December 22, 2024
Granted, the lift was light. The opponent was Drew Lock and the New York Giants. Their 0.161 EPA/play allowed on dropbacks is fourth worst in the NFL. Ultimately, the box score will suggest Penix wasn’t much of an upgrade over the veteran he’s chasing out of Georgia. He finished with 18 completions on 27 attempts for 202 yards. He didn’t throw a single touchdown.
This fails to reflect his impact. Penix was stung by drops and pressure early — the kind of influence that could have derailed his debut. He didn’t panic. He ran when asked. He hung in the pocket when the play called for it. He threw an interception that aggressively was not his fault.
Juggled and picked off by the Giants at the goal line!
: #NYGvsATL on FOX
: https://t.co/waVpO909ge pic.twitter.com/PdRfXIGHCa— NFL (@NFL) December 22, 2024
Penix made play action dropbacks look effortless instead of painful. He brought designed rollouts back to the playbook. He gave Atlanta an emotion other than anxiety on out-breaking routes to the sideline. He helped convert eight of 14 third down opportunities (57 percent).
He completed five of eight throws that traveled at least 10 yards downfield. Cousins, comparatively, had completed only 52 percent of such throws this season.
Read the full breakdown here.
2. Jalen Hurts proved his value to the Philadelphia Eagles (by getting hurt)
Geoff Burke-Imagn Images
Jalen Hurts left Sunday’s showdown with the Washington Commanders in the first quarter with a head injury. At the time, it didn’t seem like it would have too dramatic an impact on the rest of the game.
Kenny Pickett slung a quick-slate touchdown pass to A.J. Brown soon after. After 10 minutes of game time, Philadelphia led 14-0 and outgained its division rival 106 yards to eight.
Then, the world got to see why the Pittsburgh Steelers were eager to get off Kenny Pickett’s dilapidated roller coaster after just two seasons in order to roll the dice on a faded Russell Wilson this offseason.
Needed that
#PHIvsWAS FOX pic.twitter.com/zhj6VKfCld
— Washington Commanders (@Commanders) December 22, 2024
Pickett’s interception was an inflection point. The former first round pick hadn’t been magically fixed by backing up Hurts or playing behind one of the league’s best offensive lines. He remained a quarterback who struggles with reads and pressure. Behold as the third-year passer stares down his intended target on the left side of the field with such dedication that he completely blanks red death crashing down upon him to the right.
YEAH TAE @dantefowler
FOX | #ProBowlVote pic.twitter.com/6DtsYF8EzZ
— Washington Commanders (@Commanders) December 22, 2024
Indeed, Pickett’s best plays came when he targeted A.J. Brown and hoped for the best. The veteran wideout was shadowed by former All-Pro Marshon Lattimore all afternoon. He went deep into his bag of tricks to ensure big gains on balls that vacillated between under- and over-thrown all afternoon.
AJ Brown has drawn THREE PASS INTERFERENCE penalties on Marshon Lattimore in ONE QUARTER
— Christian D’Andrea (@trainisland.bsky.social) December 22, 2024 at 2:15 PM
A 68-yard Saquon Barkley run made the score 21-7 with three minutes to play in the first quarter. That was the last time the Eagles saw the end zone in Landover.
Philly’s lack of confidence in its new quarterback wasn’t limited to the passing game. Twice the Eagles punted the ball on fourth-and-short where a Hurts Tush Push would have likely been the call. When they faked like they might go for it, it wasn’t a classic Nick Sirianni “try and stop us” call. It was this shotgun nonsense Sirianni of which eventually thought better.
via Fox
Hurts’ two drives lasted an average of eight plays each. Pickett’s 11 drives after lasted an average of 5.4, even with 14- and 12-play field goal treks in the second half. His inability to maintain possession put the onus on a defense that started hot and faded late. Early in the game, Jalen Carter was busy doing stuff like this:
Jalen Carter knew exactly what was coming on this run play, beat Tyler Biadasz with ease and forced the fumble. terrifying stuff for the rest of the NFC pic.twitter.com/bG6zNWMxSV
— Christian D'Andrea (@TrainIsland) December 22, 2024
Later on, however, this unit had no recourse for Jayden Daniels. This manifested in a few different ways. There were multiple touchdown passes to Olamide Zaccheaus, certainly. There were also fourth-and-long pickups that made the rookie look like prime Barry Sanders by virtue of, uh, a slight change in direction.
Jayden Daniels, this is witchcraft
— Christian D’Andrea (@trainisland.bsky.social) December 22, 2024 at 2:30 PM
This created the leverage needed to turn a 13-point fourth quarter deficit into a three-point win. While Washington still needed a bit of luck to keep its comeback alive (via a DeVonta Smith third down drop), this was a comeback made possible through a fading defense and, more importantly, a suddenly impotent offense.
In a season where Hurts had been outshined by his running game and a rising defense, Week 16 served as a reminder of the gravity he brings to the offense. Pickett only functioned in clean pockets with his first read open. His scrambles dissolved into the ether. His downfield strikes were poorly thrown pleas for pass interference penalties.
Hurts is several standard deviations better in every phase of the game. He serves as the blockade before the pit of each Eagles fan’s stomach, a reason to believe a comeback can be made rather than resignation to oblivion.
On Sunday, that value was on full display over the final 54 minutes of a 36-33 loss. Philadelphia cannot thrive without a fast processing, drive-extending quarterback no matter how good its skill players or blocking may be. Losing Hurts for an extended period of time could be the difference between a Super Bowl 59 run and another season spiraling out of control.
3. The Cincinnati Bengals probably won’t make the playoffs, but that isn’t Joe Burrow’s fault
USA Today Sports
Week 16 was the tune up the Bengals needed before a brutal stretch to end 2024. Dorian Thompson-Robinson’s Cleveland Browns played roughly as well as expected, finding the end zone only once in a 24-6 Cincinnati win. With games against the Denver Broncos and Pittsburgh Steelers looming, this was badly needed proof the Bengals’ defense can devastate a shaky quarterback.
Joe Burrow needed no such reassurance. An MVP-caliber 2024 has only furthered his legend. He leads the league in passing yards and ranks in the top three when it comes to passing touchdowns and passer rating and top five in expected points added (EPA) per dropback.
Some of this is because he has Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins on which to lean. Some of this is because Joe Burrow can occasionally bend the laws of physical nature to his will.
Joe Mahomes
— Sam Monson (@sammonson.com) December 22, 2024 at 12:19 PM
Burrow connected on 23 of 30 passes, bolstering his career 68.1 percent completion rate — best in NFL history. He threw three touchdown passes without a turnover, getting one each to Higgins and Chase and saving one for young wideout Andrei Iosivas, who could be primed for a bigger role in 2025 if Higgins leaves in free agency. He generated magic from his place in the backfield:
.@joeyb to @Real10jayy__#ProBowlVote + Joe Burrow#ProBowlVote + Ja'Marr Chase#CLEvsCIN on CBS pic.twitter.com/vmCKymoBSF
— Cincinnati Bengals (@Bengals) December 22, 2024
He spun big plays from the dying embers of a broken pocket.
*too stunned to speak*#ProBowlVote + @joeyb#CLEvsCIN on CBS pic.twitter.com/zkcqcBdTy6
— Cincinnati Bengals (@Bengals) December 22, 2024
The greatest trick he could deliver is getting Cincinnati back over .500. The playoffs are almost certainly out of the question. The Athletic pegs the Bengals’ postseason odds at six percent even with Sunday’s win. They’ve been the anti-Chiefs thanks to a 2-7 record in one score games. The culprit is a suddenly glitchy defense with no real pass rushing threat behind Trey Hendrickson and a leaky secondary that’s been a bottom-eight unit when it comes to EPA allowed. Only one team in the league has given up more points than Cincinnati.
As a result, Burrow can’t gain meaningful ground on Josh Allen or Lamar Jackson in the MVP race. He can extend the Bengals’ string of winning seasons to four, which would be the franchise’s longest since the Marvin Lewis era. Doing that would at least keep a twinkle of hope alive for Cincinnati fans who saw last year’s late playoff push derailed by Burrow’s thumb injury.
4. The Indianapolis Colts should build the whole plane out of Jonathan Taylor
Grace Hollars/USA Today Network via Imagn Images
In Week 15, Jonathan Taylor, five-year NFL veteran and former rushing leader, made an error so basic calling it a “rookie mistake” would have been gross understatement. He dropped the ball at the goal line, taking what should have been an easy touchdown off the board in a blowout loss to the Denver Broncos.
Taylor didn’t make the same mistake in Week 16. With head coach Shane Steichen entrusting him with Indianapolis’s slim playoff hopes, Taylor answered the bell.
The former All-Pro tailback out-touched quarterback Anthony Richardson 29 to 21 despite not having a single target in the passing game. His 218 rushing yards were the second-most in his career and biggest performance since the end of the 2020 campaign.
The reasons for this explosion are multiple. On one hand, his blocking was clean, leading to untouched long runs like this.
65-yard touchdown
70-yard touchdown #ProBowlVote x @JayT23CBS pic.twitter.com/4rkXg1XN6r
— Indianapolis Colts (@Colts) December 22, 2024
Other times, Taylor made his own running lanes with waterbug-quick cutbacks.
65 yards in a flash. #ProBowlVote x @JayT23
CBS
— Indianapolis Colts (@Colts) December 22, 2024
Finishing through contact? Yep, he’s got that, too.
3 TDs, over 200 yards, and we’re only halfway through the 3rd quarter.#ProBowlVote x @JayT23
CBS pic.twitter.com/d6pUglhJv1
— Indianapolis Colts (@Colts) December 22, 2024
This all helped the Colts hang on despite giving up 23 unanswered points to end this game. Taylor was the foundation that allowed Anthony Richardson to have a very Anthony Richardson game. He kept his eyes downfield and threw clutch passes for big gains.
Nickel and Dimes.
CBS pic.twitter.com/meejsLzWyS
— Indianapolis Colts (@Colts) December 22, 2024
He also kept his eyes downfield and managed to blank extra defenders ready to undercut these big gains.
Anthony Richardson é INTERCEPTADO por Amani Hooker!
: Assista ao vivo no NFL Game Pass pic.twitter.com/T6ETCj3VxQ
— NFL Brasil (@NFLBrasil) December 22, 2024
His seven of 11 performance led to 131 passing yards and a touchdown — his second game of 2024 in which he’s thrown at least five passes and completed more than half of them. He added 70 more yards and a touchdown on the ground.
This is the best case scenario for the 2024 Colts. Richardson is a frustrating and flawed passer. The former case is heightened by the fact he can occasionally spin truly special plays out of thin air. He’s early stage Josh Allen, a quarterback who never looked like he’d quite put things together in the NFL until he suddenly did.
Indianapolis tried to bring out his best like the Bills did with Allen, only instead of one All-Pro wideout they gave him a cache of valuable wideouts with lower ceilings in more defined roles. Throwing to Michael Pittman, A.D. Mitchell and Josh Downs hasn’t led to a revolution, but leaning on a revived Taylor could create the runway the dynamic young passer needs for takeoff. It’s happened before with worse players than Richardson.
It’s what happened Sunday as well. While it also created a late scoring drought that nearly gave way to an epic Mason Rudolph Titans comeback (a truly cursed five-word string), it was a viable strategy against an average Tennessee run defense.
The Colts aren’t fixed, and that 23-0 run from Rudolph was proof. But with a 17 percent shot to make the postseason, they may have landed on a strategy that clears a path to a winning record and possibly more. One that doesn’t rely on Richardson having to do too much on any given week.
5. Geno Smith and Sam Darnold had a heavyweight fight while the New York Jets languished in bantamweight hell
Steven Bisig-Imagn Images
Smith came into Week 16’s Seattle Seahawks vs. Minnesota Vikings showdown hurt thanks to a tweaked knee. Sam Darnold eventually joined him there with finger and ankle injuries. This should have made this game a slog, instead, it was remarkable.
Smith and Darnold exchanged the lead four times in the second half. Each through three touchdown passes, the last coming with under four minutes to play on an absolutely beautiful throw from an about-to-be-crushed Darnold.
.@JJettas2 CLUTCH.#ProBowlVote
: @NFLonFOX pic.twitter.com/HFiWQZibHR
— Minnesota Vikings (@Vikings) December 22, 2024
Darnold finished his day with 246 yards and three touchdowns without a turnover. Smith had 314 yards, three touchdowns and two interceptions, one of which came on a last-gasp deep heave trailing by three with no timeouts remaining in the final seconds. On a day where neither rushing attack averaged better than 3.9 yards per carry, this 27-24 showdown was a quarterback battle all the way.
This was a great win for the Vikings, a tough loss for the Seahawks and yet again more lemon juice in the never-closing wounds of the New York Jets. Both Darnold and Smith were supposed to be New York’s franchise quarterbacks in the 2010s. Both left after embarrassing stints in green and white. Both needed several years to wash the Jets stink from their games.
In one game, two former New York quarterbacks had as many three-touchdown performances as the Jets have had, total, in the last two years. Hours earlier, the latest link in a poorly pasted chain of Dollar Tree construction paper loops, Aaron Rodgers, led New York to a touchdown drive on his first possession and zero more after that. His offense turned the ball over on downs three times, all of which happened before the final eight minutes of the game.
Rodgers dropped back to pass on third down 13 times. He picked up enough yards for a first down only five times. One of these failures was a baffling display of poor awareness that would have been shocking in the 2010s.
Aaron Rodgers, fully committing to making “no self awareness” his entire brand
— Christian D’Andrea (@trainisland.bsky.social) December 22, 2024 at 2:11 PM
The Jets thought they were getting greatness and were forced, again, to settle for mediocrity. The Seahawks and Vikings bought low on former Jets quarterbacks in backup roles, expecting mediocrity. They’ve gotten performances ranging from “acceptable” to “legitimately great” since their New York castoffs were elevated to starting roles by unexpected circumstances.
Neither Smith nor Darnold played even close to this level as Jets. Since leaving, they’ve flourished in glorious, occasionally baffling ways. I don’t know what that means overall, but it does suggest Zach Wilson is gonna have one hell of a 2028 for the Miami Dolphins.
6. Ben Johnson is a mad man
Detroit Free Press
We already broke this into its own post. But I am going to repeat it because it bears repeating; this is lunatic behavior.
https://twitter.com/NFL/status/1870921618937299013
The Detroit Lions do not need trick plays to beat the Chicago Bears. But offensive coordinator Ben Johnson’s playbook is so thick with skullduggery he can afford to cast a few gadget plays out every week without ever giving up the plot to the NFL spy novel he writes on the field each Sunday. Sometimes that means Jared Goff has to pretend to fall down just to make a touchdown throw 15 percent easier. Other times it means the Lions’ swing tackle is able to become a red zone threat.
This makes the Lions an inscrutable team. They can beat you with a 1940s offense after averaging better than 4.6 yards per carry this fall. They can beat you with Goff, currently playing like a top four quarterback. Or they can devise a play where each member of the offensive line laterals the ball backward, Sam LaPorta fakes a free kick and Jahmyr Gibbs, hidden under a trench coat and glasses, quietly walks into the end zone for six points.
Crap, I think I just gave away the ending to Super Bowl 59.
7. Fantasy team you absolutely didn’t want to field in Week 16
Brian Fluharty-Imagn Images
- QB: Matthew Stafford, Rams (110 passing yards, one touchdown, one interception, -4 rushing yards, 9.8 fantasy points)
- RB: Brian Robinson Jr., Commanders (24 rushing yards, two catches, 17 receiving yards, two fumbles lost, 2.1 fantasy points)
- RB: Isiah Pacheco, Chiefs (26 rushing yards, one catch, -1 receiving yards, 3.5 fantasy points)
- WR: Jerry Jeudy, Browns (two catches, 20 yards, 4.0 fantasy points)
- WR: Amari Cooper, Bills (one catch, 10 yards 2.0 fantasy points)
- WR: Michael Pittman, Colts (two catches, 19 yards, 3.9 fantasy points)
- TE: Kyle Pitts, Falcons (one catch, seven yards, 1.7 fantasy points)
- D/ST: San Francisco 49ers (29 points allowed, -4.0 fantasy points)
Total: 23.0 points