News Every Day |

Judges punt retirement plans after Trump win, raising ethics questions

A handful of federal judges appointed by Democrats have put off retirement plans in the wake of President-elect Trump’s election victory, raising questions about the ethics of their decisions as judicial vacancies for the next administration dwindle.  

Legal experts said judges have discretion to decide when to retire, and while walk-backs are rare, it’s become increasingly common to hinge those decisions on who’s in the White House to pick their successors and in the Senate to confirm them. 

"As the Senate becomes more partisan, more polarized, more politicized, it seems like the assumption of senior status and retirement — when people leave the bench or go to senior status — has become similarly politicized, partisan," said Carl Tobias, a law professor at University of Richmond who studies federal judicial selection. “And I think that's unfortunate.” 

Judge James Wynn, an appointee of former President Obama on the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, on Friday reversed his decision to retire from active service on the bench and assume “senior status,” which is when a judge serves in a semi-retired capacity, creating a vacancy for their seat to be filled. 

The announcement came after President Biden’s intended replacement for Wynn’s seat withdrew his nomination once it became apparent he would not receive Senate confirmation. Senators reportedly struck a deal to let Biden's remaining district court nominees advance without stalling tactics by Republicans if Wynn and another appellate judge’s seats were left open for Trump to fill.  

The judge's decision to stay on effectively blocks Trump from seating a successor instead. 

U.S. District Judges Max Cogburn in North Carolina and Algenon Marbley in Ohio, both appointed by Democrats, also rescinded their intentions to assume senior status following the presidential election.  

The decisions drew sharp rebuke from top Republicans, who have criticized the “un-retirements” as open partisanship.  

Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) claimed decisions by Cogburn and Marbley to hold off on senior status exposed “bold Democratic blue where there should only be black robes.” Sen. Thom Tillis (R-N.C.) said ethics complaints and recusal demands against Wynn would be deserved.   

The conservative Article III Project, founded by Trump ally Mike Davis, filed judicial misconduct complaints against all three judges. 

But legal experts say strategic retirements from active service, based on which party controls the White House instead of other nonpartisan reasons, have grown more common in recent decades. 

“There are all sorts of personal considerations that are going to go into when somebody feels they are ready to retire," said John P. Collins, a law professor at George Washington University with expertise in judicial nominations. “As the data bears out, particularly recently, the party of the president who is going to appoint the replacement is clearly one of those factors.” 

A 2023 data analysis published in the Minnesota Law Review found that judges are increasingly taking senior status at politically advantageous times. 

Under former President George W. Bush, more than 70 percent of federal judges seeking senior status were appointed by a Republican president, the study found. That increased to more than 80 percent during Trump’s administration, and in about the first two years of Biden’s administration, about 65 percent of judges taking senior status were appointed by a Democratic president.

At least three Republican-appointed judges have also rescinded their decisions to take senior status in the past two decades: U.S. District Judges Rudolph Randa, after Obama’s 2008 election; Michael Kanne, after Trump didn’t select his preferred successor; and Karen Caldwell, after her preferred successor fell through. 

“It is pension plus politics that drives a lot of these decisions,” said Christina Boyd, a law professor at Washington University in St. Louis who studies judicial behavior. "You always wait until your pension vests, and then you oftentimes will also look to the political environment around you.” 

Think tanks and advocacy groups from judicial watchdog Fix the Court to the libertarian Cato Institute have condemned the practice of judges seeking to control the succession of their seat on the bench. 

But politics often infect the process anyway.  

Senate Judiciary Committee Chair Dick Durban (D-Ill.) noted on the floor earlier this month that McConnell blocked then-Judge Merrick Garland, whom Obama had nominated to serve on the Supreme Court in 2016, from even getting a hearing while Republicans controlled the upper chamber. Senate Republicans also kept Justice Antonin Scalia’s seat vacant for nearly a year following his death, giving Trump a chance to nominate Judge Neil Gorsuch in 2017. 

Trump’s election win sparked debate about retirement from the nation’s highest court, too, with members of both parties debating whether the Supreme Court’s oldest justices should step down before or during the next administration. 

Two of the court’s leading conservatives, Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito, are 76 and 74 years old, respectively. Justice Sonia Sotomayor, the court’s most senior liberal, is 70.  

“There's always been a political element to judicial retirements’ Venn diagram,” Collins said.  

Владимир Путин

Путин участвует в церемонии открытия новых транспортных объектов в РФ

Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Anmolpreet Singh smashes fastest List A hundred by an Indian

Gaurav Khanna on the possibility of Anuj returning to Anupamaa, says 'It is possible to return...'

'Ashwin retirement start of team's transition, next 3 weeks...'

'Not sending Gukesh to school was tough call': Mother

Ria.city
Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "23 декабря 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...






Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "23 декабря 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...


Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Если у вас диабет, прочтите это немедленно! Он лечится за 1 месяц

Калий ускоряет расщепление сахара снижая его уровень до 4,7. Утром съедайте 5 кислых…

Read also

Yuma Kagiyama soars to first national title

How billionaires have sidestepped a tax aimed at the rich

New ‘plane seat squatting’ trend that is driving passengers mad on flights

News, articles, comments, with a minute-by-minute update, now on Today24.pro

News Every Day

'Ashwin retirement start of team's transition, next 3 weeks...'

Today24.pro — latest news 24/7. You can add your news instantly now — here


News Every Day

France's Macron visits cyclone-devastated Mayotte as residents plead for aid



Sports today


Новости тенниса
WTA

WTA сделала заявление о матче Соболенко — Швёнтек



Спорт в России и мире
Москва

«Зима в Москве»: бесплатную лыжно-биатлонную трассу откроют в «Лужниках»



All sports news today





Sports in Russia today

Москва

Качканарцы на балу в Москве


Новости России

Game News

Today's Wordle answer for Friday, December 20


Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Russian.city

Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine


Москва

Три студента ПГУ стали победителями конкурсного трека «ПервопроХодец»


Губернаторы России
Сергей Брановицкий

Создании ИИ клипа. Создание клипа с помощью нейросети.


Умер диссидент Кузнецов, пытавшийся угнать советский самолет для побега из СССР

РОСГВАРДЕЕЦ ИЗ КАЛУГИ СТАЛ УЧАСТНИКОМ ФЕСТИВАЛЯ «КУЛЬТУРА ПОБЕДЫ»

РИАН: диетолог Стародубова не рекомендует есть больше 200 г мандаринов в сутки

Путин запустил движение по новым участкам в Московской и Ленинградской областях


Певец Юрий Лоза назвал Владимира Путина чудотворцем

Суд отказал Наталье Лапиной в исковых требованиях к адвокату Успенской

Певица МакSим и юные вокалисты из Школы искусств исполнили новогодний трек вместе с главным героем мультсериала «Детектив Финник»

«Идеальный отпуск глазами жены»: 41-летний Тимати намекнул, что женился


Лучший теннисист Эстонии чудом прошел на турнир первого Большого шлема

WTA сделала заявление о матче Соболенко — Швёнтек

Теннисиста хотели заставить сдать допинг‑тест во время матча молодежного Итогового турнира ATP

По стопам Синнера и Алькараса: молодёжный Итоговый турнир ATP выиграл 18-летний бразилец


Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this


Погоду на январь спрогнозировали россиянам

Хомяк, да не тот: что показали на последнем в 2024 году фестивале поп-культуры

Вышел новый рейтинг "Специалисты, к которым хочется возвращаться. Кем может гордиться Москва?"

В Москве на Исторической сцене Большого театра пройдет Новогодний гала-концерт


Конкурс «Наше поколение» получил три престижные награды на премии Dprofile Award 2024

Военнослужащие Росгвардии завоевали две серебряные медали на международном турнире «Кубок Владимира Сальникова»

«Металлург» примет «Авангард», «Ак Барс» против «Динамо» Москва. Превью 23 декабря

Группа студентов из МГППУ сопровождала интерактивный квест на молодежном форуме корпорации «Роскосмос»


РЕН ТВ 25 декабря покажет телепремьеру юбилейного концерта группы «Алиса»

Журналист Штир: история дала Польше и Прибалтике удостоверение на русофобию

Прибайкалье заняло 42 место в РФ по социально-экономическому развитию в этом году

Рита Дакота из Америки: «Хочется расплакаться и уехать обратно в Москву, в свою зону комфорта»


Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine


Путин в России и мире
Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this



Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this



Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine



Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this

Персональные новости Russian.city
Джиган

Грустный, но худой: Самойлова раскрыла секрет стройности Джигана



News Every Day

'Not sending Gukesh to school was tough call': Mother




Friends of Today24

Музыкальные новости

Персональные новости