There Are Three Times More Attacks By Palestinians Than Israelis in the West Bank and Jerusalem

When are material omissions in media coverage evidence of something more than just sloppy journalism? Persistence is one factor to consider. So too is whether the omissions consistently skew toward one side of a conflict or debate. Both of these factors characterize CNN’s coverage of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Consider one of the network’s recent reports.

In their November 5 article, “Israeli attacks in West Bank killed at least eight people, officials and residents say,” Kareem Khadder and Sana Noor Haq manage to omit an impressive number of crucial details in a transparent effort to depict Israelis in the most cynical light possible.

The story is focused on Israeli operations in several areas of the West Bank on November 4-5, during which CNN says eight Palestinians were killed. The first major omission: the reason why the IDF was operating in the first place. The IDF arrested some 60 members of the terrorist organization Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP), seized weapons, and destroyed an explosives laboratory being used by terrorists.

But the worst omissions are when Khadder and Noor Haq get down into the details of the raids, or rather, into just some of the details.

They write that “[t]wo Palestinians were killed in the town of Tamoun.” But readers are left unaware that both Palestinians were members of Palestinian Islamic Jihad. The terrorist organization itself had announced that its “armed wing” members had clashed with Israeli forces in Tamoun on that day.

CNN continues: “In the village of Al-Shuhada, near the city of Jenin, an Israeli airstrike killed two people.” But according to the IDF, those “two people” were “armed terrorists” who had been shooting and throwing explosives at Israeli forces. The IDF’s statement was nowhere to be found in CNN’s story.

כוחות צה״ל, שב״כ ומג״ב ממשיכים במבצע במרחב חטיבת מנשה. הכוחות פועלים מאתמול בקבאטיה ובנור א-שמס>> pic.twitter.com/0WSlDMFE38

— צבא ההגנה לישראל (@idfonline) November 6, 2024

Khadder and Noor Haq also write: “in the city of Qabatya …. two others [were] killed when an Israeli military vehicle rammed a car and opened fire, according to residents and video seen by CNN.”

But both occupants were terrorists, including Majdi Hamza Ahmed Shkira, a member of Palestinian Islamic Jihad who was already wanted for acts of terrorism. Palestinian Islamic Jihad itself boasted about its terrorists “clashing” with Israeli forces in Qabatya, too.

Moreover, the evidence suggests the terrorists rammed into the Israeli military vehicle, not the other way around. The IDF’s version of events, which the journalists also omitted in violation of basic journalistic ethics, was that “soldiers identified a suspicious vehicle that sped towards them and crashed into them,” wounding two of them.

CNN notably doesn’t show the video it relied on to reach its conclusions, but footage and images available online support the IDF’s story.

The footage shows two IDF vehicles in a defensive position, blocking the road. This is standard practice: one can find dozens of images of Israeli forces operating in the West Bank positioning their vehicles in similar fashion. Just a few feet away from the IDF vehicles sits a sedan with severe damage to its front hood, indicating it hit something head on.

It’s difficult to make definitive conclusions based on these images, but these facts do provide some important clarity and a basis to determine the reliability of any conclusions. So why wouldn’t these pieces of information be included when they help shed light toward the truth? Is it because they cast doubt on CNN’s definitive conclusion of Israeli wrongdoing?

Khadder and Noor Haq’s pattern of omissions didn’t end there, though.

Continuing CNN’s tradition of giving its audience half-truths on violence in the West Bank, Khadder and Noor Haq claimed that “at least 775 Palestinians, including 167 children” have been killed by “Israeli troops and settlers” since October 7. They also claimed that “nearly 1,600 settler attacks against Palestinians have been recorded” during the same period.

But CNN leaves out the other side of the story: Palestinian violence. From October 2023 through September 2024 — excluding the month of January 2024, for which data was not immediately available — there have been 4,916 attacks by Palestinians against Israelis in the West Bank and Jerusalem, including 1,140 firebombs, 695 pipe bombs, 253 shooting attacks, and 277 arson attacks, as well as ramming attacks, stabbing attacks, car bombings, and even a suicide attack. That’s at least three times as many attacks against Israelis as there were against Palestinians.

These attacks have been deadly, too, killing 40 Israelis and wounding nearly 300 more.

The emphasis on Palestinian child casualties is also misleading. While every death of a child is tragic, it is an established fact that Palestinian children are regularly involved in terrorism. The data shows that this trend continues to be highly relevant to the story. Databases on Palestinian fatalities show that between October 7, 2023 and March 31, 2024, 17-year-olds accounted for 36% of all deaths of minors. More than three-quarters (76%) of all minors killed during the period were aged 15 or older. The circumstances of many of those deaths, even according to anti-Israel activist organizations like B’Tselem, indicate they were involved in violence.

Together, Khadder and Noor Haq’s omissions demonstrate an unmistakable bias. They work to erase the violence of Palestinians while depicting Israelis as needlessly violent and oppressive. For media consumers seeking straightforward and honest reporting, CNN is clearly not the answer.

David M. Litman is a Research Analyst at the Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting and Analysis (CAMERA).

The post There Are Three Times More Attacks By Palestinians Than Israelis in the West Bank and Jerusalem first appeared on Algemeiner.com.