Add news
News Every Day |

A lesson for CBS: Live fact-checking is incompatible with good debate moderation

Lindsey Davis and David Muir of ABC News moderated ABC's Sept. 10 presidential debate between former President Donald Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris. The debate, the second of the year, demonstrates the collapse of the traditional Commission on Presidential Debate forums that came into being in 1987. The commission originally planned to host a series of debates this fall that neither of the political parties would agree to for their campaigns. 

The collapse of that process led to the current regimen of media network debate events now hosted by CNN and ABC. Most analysts recognize that Muir and Davis engaged in arguably partisan fact checking against the Trump campaign, raising inherent questions about how the next debate among vice presidential candidates Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio) and Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz (D) might be moderated by CBS News journalists Norah O'Donnell and Margaret Brennan.  

In the CNN debate and the recent ABC debate, some positive progress toward better debate moderation was made. Chris Wallace in 2020 consumed 25 percent of the debate time with his own arguments. Moderator Steve Scully was disciplined prior to his debate for plotting to engage in attacks against candidate Trump.

The idea of journalist moderators “intervening” and “fact checking” candidates originates with the activism pursued by Candy Crowley in her debate moderation of Republican candidate Mitt Romney and President Obama in 2012. The first debate between Romney and Obama led to public polling suggesting Obama lost rather decisively. Believing that the result was tainted by a lack of “fact checking,” Crowley promised she would fact check the debate live, despite assurances that such measures were not allowed by moderators.

A similar dynamic was observed in the period between the June 27 debate and the Sept. 10 debate hosted by ABC. The June 27 debate featured less fact checking by CNN. President Biden suffered a decisive loss in that debate, leading to his withdrawal from the election. Lindsay Davis made clear after the Sept. 10 debate that she believes the CNN moderators failed to fact check, and that her own fact checking was a positive good. She and Muir fact-checked Trump five times without ever fact checking Harris, even though Harris made a number of provocative factual statements arguably worthy of fact-checking.

For example, Harris said that “Donald Trump left us the worst attack on our democracy since the Civil War.” This statement came made on the eve of the anniversary of Sept. 11 attacks, arguably the worst attack on our democracy since the Civil War.

She also said: “And as of today, there is not one member of the United States military who is in active duty in a combat zone in any war zone around the world, the first time this century.” However, there were (and still are) thousands of U.S. active duty military personnel serving in combat zones in Syria and Iraq, some of whom had been taking fire just about a month before the debate. 

This demonstrates that live fact-checking is incompatible with the true purposes of political debate. In political debate and speech, candidates make inherently contentious claims that are not easily verifiable, such as “best economy” and “worst war.”

In true debates, there are always fact checkers — namely, the opposing debater and the voters themselves. Biden and Trump had equal opportunities to fact check one another. When the journalist moderators refuse their ethical commitment to be unbiased, they depart from the non-partisan role of journalists.

Moreover, in the advent of televised presidential debates in 1960, Congress changed election campaign laws to allow the debates between Richard Nixon and John Kennedy. The key legal obstacle was the enshrined belief that broadcast companies should not abuse their power to unfairly influence presidential elections. The conduct of Muir and Davis is inconsistent with the general ethic of academic debates as practiced by high school and college students around the world. No debater expects the judge or time keeper to interrupt the debate and make pronouncements about how certain statements are misleading or false.

All of these problems point to an ethical concern that is well placed: Television broadcast companies and their employees should not unreasonably interfere with political election campaigns. This has been a concern since the inception of televised debates. 

Much like CNN, CBS now faces a dilemma about how to conduct the vice presidential debate on Oct. 1. Ideally, moderators would say almost nothing and candidates would have more time to make opening arguments that might outline a specific policy that many voters still want to hear.

Live fact checking by CBS journalists would add to the already dismal view the public holds about journalists reporting on politics in America. Surveys of journalists show a growing desire to affiliate openly with the Democratic Party (28 percent in 2013 to 36 percent in 2022) and a declining desire to affiliate with the Republican Party (7.1 percent in 2013 to 3.4 percent in 2022).

The public remains clear that they want more fair political debate in the United States. The high viewership numbers show a civic appetite for fair debate. Journalists need to observe their important ethical role in performing as a free press, rather than an ideologically captive one.

Failure to rise to that ethical demand is not only problematic in terms of having an informed electorate, but may also rise to a legal violation of our campaign laws designed to protect the public from abuse of their broadcast powers. Election law presently states that every political debate “must include at least two candidates and must be structured so that it does not promote or advance one candidate over another.” 

ABC’s conduct of the Sept. 10 debate arguably failed that legal standard. CBS has a legal, ethical and civic obligation to raise the conduct of their moderators for the vice presidential debate of Oct. 1.

Ben Voth, PhD, is a professor of rhetoric and director of debate at Southern Methodist University in Dallas. He is author of six academic books on rhetoric and argument including “James Farmer Jr.: The Great Debaters” (Lexington, 2017) and “Debate as Global Pedagogy:  Rwanda Rising” (Lexington, 2021) detailing how public arguments positively change public policies.

Филипп Киркоров

Помощница Киркорова: после похорон отца певец перестал есть и сильно похудел

Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Darts star leaks World Championship payslip as he reveals long list of ‘deductions’ left him with just £5,200 winnings

Here’s more of what you’ll see through Meta’s $1,000 smart glasses

Tesla shares sink as deliveries miss forecasts by 'wide margin': report

Will AI ever cure cancer? The multibillion-dollar race to bring the first AI-discovered drug to market

Ria.city
Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "3 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...






Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "3 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...


Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "3 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...

Read also

Trump’s second term brings worst stock market start since 2001

I’ve Picked Chris Davies’ Brain – Barnsley Boss Admits Chats With Birmingham Manager

Miller Gardner, son of ex-Yankees star, died from carbon monoxide poisoning, officials say

News Every Day |

The Ashton Jeanty Bears Smoke Just Got Even Thicker

The draft is three weeks away now. GM Ryan Poles and head coach Ben Johnson have pieced together an off-season that is earning widespread praise across the league. The question is whether they can stick the landing with their 1st round pick in the draft. Current projections have the top three picks likely being a mix of Cam Ward, Travis Hunter, and Abdul Carter. After that, it gets tricky. People in Chicago want to know where running back Ashton Jeanty will end once the dust settles.

Widespread belief has been that the Las Vegas Raiders are the heavy favorites to take him at 6th overall, with New Orleans at #9 also being a possibility. It makes sense. Las Vegas’ best option right now is a 33-year-old Raheem Mostert. New Orleans knows Alvin Kamara turns 30 in July. Both teams need to think about the future at that position. Both have head coaches who like to run the ball. One thing is clear. A source told SM that those around the league believe one thing is certain.

“He likely won’t get passed Chicago if he falls that far.”

Ashton Jeanty is a strong probability for the Bears.

Whispers from Halas Hall indicate they love the Boise State star. It isn’t hard to see why. He nearly broke Barry Sanders’ single-season rushing record in 2024, nearly winning the Heisman in the process. The guy carried his team to the college football playoffs. He’s built like a brick house with power, speed, contact balance, and vision. There aren’t any truly glaring weaknesses in his game. He’s earned comparisons to the likes of LaDainian Tomlinson and Marshawn Lynch. The Bears haven’t had a back of that caliber since Matt Forte.

Try to imagine what this offense could look like with Ashton Jeanty, Rome Odunze, D.J. Moore, and Cole Kmet all as options for quarterback Caleb Williams. Throw all of it into Johnson’s offense, and you can understand why some people around the league aren’t wild about the idea. They are quietly hoping Jeanty goes somewhere else. One thing is certain. If he gets past the Raiders, the noise will get loud in a hurry. It would mark the first time in 20 years the Bears have taken a running back in the 1st round.

Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this

Ria.city
Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "3 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...






Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "3 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...


Реклама
  • ИП Попов А.П.
  • ИНН: 602715631406
Ревматолог: "3 апреля 2024 в г.Колумбус запущена квота"

Каждый человек с больными суставами имеет право получить...

Read also

Ex-Republican governor quotes Spider-Man to trash Trump isolationism

The 5 best foods to eat before bed for a better night’s sleep – as expert warns white bread and chicken among the worst

10 Best Zero Waste Makeup Remover Choices for Conscious Beauty

News, articles, comments, with a minute-by-minute update, now on Today24.pro

News Every Day

Darts star leaks World Championship payslip as he reveals long list of ‘deductions’ left him with just £5,200 winnings

Today24.pro — latest news 24/7. You can add your news instantly now — here


News Every Day

T-Mobile closes Lumos deal after dropping DEI



Sports today


Новости тенниса
Вероника Кудерметова

Кудерметова: Последние два года были очень трудными для меня



Спорт в России и мире
Москва

Ансамбль из Петрозаводска завоевал Гран-при международного конкурса



All sports news today





Sports in Russia today

Москва

Росгвардейцы обеспечили безопасность матча ВХЛ в Челябинске


Новости России

Game News

It's actually happening, everybody stay calm: Silksong properly confirmed for a 2025 release date at the Nintendo Direct with a whole 3 seconds of footage


Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this

Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine

Russian.city

Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this


Москва

«Был под чем-то»: подробности аварии с Lamborghini Егора Крида


Губернаторы России
Яндекс

Яндекс Недвижимость: в Рязани снизилась средняя стоимость вторичного жилья


НАТО СПОСОБНО НАНЕСТИ ЯДЕРНЫЙ УДАР ПО США И ЕВРОПЕ? НАТО СДЕЛАНО ДЛЯ ЭТОГО. СЕНСАЦИЯ! НОВОСТИ! СПЕЦOПЕРАЦИЯ "ЗИС". Россия, США, Европа могут улучшить отношения и здоровье общества?!

Инжиниринговый центр в Москве: новый этап для российских производителей

Когда слово объединяет: ГПМ Радио приглашает на «Тотальный диктант»

Рейтинг пяти лучших маркетинговых агентств: VICTORY GROUP занял первое место


Девушка рэпера Тимати Валентина снялась в комбинезоне с глубоким декольте

Кураторские Плейлисты.

Карди Би обвинила отца своих детей в покушении на убийство

Девушка Тимати показала себя с новым имиджем


Бухарест (ATP). 2-й круг. Гаске сыграет с Коболли, Баутиста-Агут – с Комесаньей, Баес – с Уго Карабелли

Собчак не видит причин осуждать Касаткину за смену гражданства

Игрока в пинг-понг Сидоренко дисквалифицировали за оскорбление женщины-судьи

WTA сменила флаг Касаткиной в рейтинге на австралийский


Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this


Московский Экономический Форум: главное

Когда слово объединяет: ГПМ Радио приглашает на «Тотальный диктант»

Инжиниринговый центр в Москве: новый этап для российских производителей

Компания enKod на Global Tech Forum: как технологии меняют маркетинг


Сергей Собянин: Построим и реконструируем семь городских вокзалов

Финляндия рассматривает восстановление отношений с Россией: новая стратегия?

Тайна имён. Что связывает наследников Петросяна с балетным миром

Александр Буйнов приглашает на свой 75-летний юбилей


РОССИЯ И ДОНАЛЬД ТРАМП СПАСАЮТ США ОТ ЭКОНОМИЧЕСКОГО РАБСТВА?! СЕНСАЦИЯ! УЛУЧШИТЬ ПЕРЕГОВОРЫ! Новости. В.В. Путин. Россия, США, Европа могут улучшить отношения и здоровье общества?!

ТОП-5 лазерных устройств для татуажа в 2025 году: что нужно знать?

Эксперт: реорганизация промзоны в Западном Дегунине повысит привлекательность района

В Нигере ждут открытия российского посольства


Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine


Путин в России и мире
Реклама
The most beautiful beach towns with cheap living

A huge number of people around the world dream of one day breaking out of the daily routine



Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this



Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this



Реклама
Top 6 nutrition questions men should ask themselves after 40

To maintain health and remain full of energy, men will be helped by this

Персональные новости Russian.city
Deep Purple

Deep Purple — Mandrake Root (French TV, 14th Nov, 1970)



News Every Day

Darts star leaks World Championship payslip as he reveals long list of ‘deductions’ left him with just £5,200 winnings




Friends of Today24

Музыкальные новости

Персональные новости