EU gives conditional nod to Lufthansa's proposed ITA Airways stake
BRUSSELS, Belgium — The EU on Wednesday announced its conditional approval for German airline Lufthansa's proposed stake in ITA Airways, a deal that Italy called a "big European success".
Lufthansa, one of Europe's largest carriers, last year agreed to pay 325 million euros ($350 million) for a 41 per cent stake in ITA, with the Italian finance ministry also contributing 250 million euros as part of the capital increase.
The German airline's presence in Italy will be bolstered by the deal and said it would give more options for travel to Africa, South America and the Middle East.
But it has faced a turbulent process to get regulators' approval after the European Commission opened an in-depth probe in January, fearing it could hurt competition.
The commission, the EU's antitrust regulator, has now given the green light after Lufthansa and the Italian government offered a package of commitments to assuage those fears.
"Despite the comprehensive and far-reaching concessions, the investment in ITA Airways strengthens the Lufthansa Group's position in global competition," Lufthansa CEO Carsten Spohr said in a statement.
"This positive conclusion is truly a success," Italian Economy Minister Giancarlo Giorgetti told a press conference in Rome.
"It has been a complicated, troubled, difficult path, but... it is a big Italian success, it is a big German success, it is a big European success," Giorgetti said.
But European consumers group BEUC raised concerns over the limited information about commitments offered by the players involved.
"The current lack of clarity leads us to fear that consumers could pay the price for this merger in terms of higher fares, less choice of routes and degraded services," said Agustin Reyna, chief at BEUC, which represents consumers in 31 countries.
Concessions for rivals
The deal provided Lufthansa various options to increase its stake in ITA Airways — the successor to state-owned Alitalia — or acquire it outright at a later date.
The offered remedies that helped seal the deal include making it possible for one or two rival airlines to launch non-stop flights between Rome and Milan and central Europe, the commission said.
"These commitments fully address the competition concerns identified by the commission," it said. "The decision is conditional upon full compliance with the commitments."
Take-off and landing slots at Milan's Linate airport will also be transferred to competing airlines for short-haul routes.
Other commitments to fulfil include entering into agreements with rivals "to improve their competitiveness on the long-haul routes of concern", between Italy and the United States and Canada.
This could include slot swaps at airports or interlining agreements, which means airlines coordinate with each other on certain aspects of travel, such as ticketing.
"This will lead to increased frequencies of nonstop flights and/or improved connections for one-stop flights on each of the routes," the commission said.
'Lack of clarity'
ITA Airways was created from the ashes of Alitalia, which was placed under public administration in 2017.
Alitalia had accumulated losses of 11.4 billion euros between 2000 and 2020. It was eventually shut down in October 2021 before a rebirth as ITA.
The EU wanted to make sure the Lufthansa deal did not lead to higher prices for consumers.
Brussels had been concerned that on a number of short-haul routes between Italy and central Europe as well as long-haul routes between the United States and Canada there would be limited competition, leading to a reduction in quality for passengers.
"At a time when consumers are facing increasingly higher prices for air travel, it is very important to preserve competition in the sector," said the EU's competition chief, Margrethe Vestager.
The remedies would ensure "a sufficient level of competitive pressure remains on all relevant routes", she added.
