Add news
March 2010 April 2010 May 2010 June 2010 July 2010
August 2010
September 2010 October 2010
November 2010
December 2010
January 2011
February 2011 March 2011 April 2011 May 2011 June 2011 July 2011 August 2011 September 2011 October 2011 November 2011 December 2011 January 2012 February 2012 March 2012 April 2012 May 2012 June 2012 July 2012 August 2012 September 2012 October 2012 November 2012 December 2012 January 2013 February 2013 March 2013 April 2013 May 2013 June 2013 July 2013 August 2013 September 2013 October 2013 November 2013 December 2013 January 2014 February 2014 March 2014 April 2014 May 2014 June 2014 July 2014 August 2014 September 2014 October 2014 November 2014 December 2014 January 2015 February 2015 March 2015 April 2015 May 2015 June 2015 July 2015 August 2015 September 2015 October 2015 November 2015 December 2015 January 2016 February 2016 March 2016 April 2016 May 2016 June 2016 July 2016 August 2016 September 2016 October 2016 November 2016 December 2016 January 2017 February 2017 March 2017 April 2017 May 2017 June 2017 July 2017 August 2017 September 2017 October 2017 November 2017 December 2017 January 2018 February 2018 March 2018 April 2018 May 2018 June 2018 July 2018 August 2018 September 2018 October 2018 November 2018 December 2018 January 2019 February 2019 March 2019 April 2019 May 2019 June 2019 July 2019 August 2019 September 2019 October 2019 November 2019 December 2019 January 2020 February 2020 March 2020 April 2020 May 2020 June 2020 July 2020 August 2020 September 2020 October 2020 November 2020 December 2020 January 2021 February 2021 March 2021 April 2021 May 2021 June 2021 July 2021 August 2021 September 2021 October 2021 November 2021 December 2021 January 2022 February 2022 March 2022 April 2022 May 2022 June 2022 July 2022 August 2022 September 2022 October 2022 November 2022 December 2022 January 2023 February 2023 March 2023 April 2023 May 2023 June 2023 July 2023 August 2023 September 2023 October 2023 November 2023 December 2023 January 2024 February 2024 March 2024 April 2024 May 2024 June 2024 July 2024
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23
News Every Day |

A Small Step Toward Ending Jawboning, a Big Need for Disclosure

A Small Step Toward Ending Jawboning, a Big Need for Disclosure

Will Duffield

supreme court

The government can’t command social media platforms to remove disfavored speech. But when does informal government speech notifying or suggesting cross the line into unconstitutional pressure or coercion? We still don’t know, because today, the Supreme Court reversed and remanded the Fifth Circuit’s decision in Murthy v. Missouri, rejecting the much‐​watched jawboning case for lack of standing.

Vaccine‐​skeptical doctors, supported by the states of Louisiana and Missouri, sued the Biden administration and various federal agencies over government exhortations to platforms to do more about COVID-19 misinformation. The court found that plaintiffs failed to plead a concrete injury caused by government pressure and redressible by the court. While facially a setback to efforts to prevent government censorship by proxy, the court’s decision sets future jawboning litigation on the right precedential track and showcases the pressing need for legislative action to impose disclosure on government communication with social media platforms.

While the court has not done away with social media jawboning today, it has set the stage for its end, and an end on ultimately speech‐​friendly terms. In NRA v. Vullo, decided at the end of May, the court found impermissible jawboning in the demands of a NY state banking regulator by applying the Bantam Books v. Sullivan standard. Relying on Bantam Books, it held that the government violates the First Amendment when it is “reasonably understood to convey a threat of adverse government action in order to punish or suppress the plaintiff’s speech”. Alito’s reliance on Bantam Books in his Murthy dissent indicates that the standard for finding social media jawboning is coming into focus.

Although Justice Barret does not explicitly rely upon Vullo or Bantam Books when delivering the opinion of the court, she puts the Fifth Circuit’s loose “significant encouragement” standard half‐​pulled from Blum v. Yaretsky to bed. Coupled with Alito’s decision to use Bantam Books and Vullo rather than attempt to resuscitate the Fifth Circuit’s Blum standard, Barrett’s approach indicates that jawboning cases will be decided around coercion rather than the significance of encouragement.

What remains to be decided is exactly how coercive government communications must be to violate the Constitution’s strictures. Vullo turned in some sense on the believability or actionability of government threats, a less important aspect of Bantam Books, but under either variation of the coercion standard, a clearer, smaller case is likely to bring justices Barrett and Alito together.

The real hurdle is standing and redressability, or how establishing standing and redressability shapes the sort of coercion the court is willing to address. The court must be able to offer a remedy likely to prevent future harm to plaintiffs. The injunction at issue here was deemed unlikely to do so given the loose connection between government communications and platform action.

“[W]ithout evidence of continued pressure from the defendants, it appears that the platforms remain free to enforce, or not to enforce, those policies—even those tainted by initial governmental coercion.”

Thus, in social media jawboning cases, standing and redressability effectively create a shadow requirement that coercion be directed toward particular speakers, and ongoing or likely to persist. Absent a clearer, longer term pattern of demands, the attenuation of plaintiffs injuries make it unlikely that an injunction targeting government officials will spur platforms to undo past content policy decisions. The fact that Facebook had limited some of the plaintiffs’ content before being jawboned seemed to weigh heavily on the court’s judgment. Unfortunately, even if a one‐​off demand shapes platform policy for everyone, these lingering effects won’t be captured by a single plaintiffs’ discovery of how the demand affected them.

From a standing standpoint, it is a problem that most plaintiffs were not named in the most obviously coercive communications. But these messages, sent privately by White House Communications Director Rob Flaherty and advisor Andy Slavitt, were unlikely to have been uncovered without the participation of such a wide set of plaintiffs. Nevertheless, the bevy of plaintiffs, claims, and potentially affected government agencies at play in the case always cut against a full hearing on the merits. Hard cases may make bad law, but too‐​large cases often make no law at all.

The court’s decision leaves obvious room for platform litigation, or mere participation in litigation around the issue. A suit by platforms would obviate the attenuation problem. For a social media firm, even a single, general threat may create expectations of direct future government retaliation. Such a pleading would be much more in line with Bantam Books, which was brought by publishers with longstanding commercial relations with the coerced distributor, who while not party to the suit, testified that he had stopped carrying the plaintiff publishers’ books in response to government threats. Even a small platform might be able to show a much more direct and redressible injury.

Ultimately, the court’s decision to reject Murthy for lack of standing lays clear the pressing need for disclosure of government communications with social media platforms. If bundled claims and the inchoate or general demands uncovered by state plaintiffs’ discovery and congressional fishing don’t pass muster, then more granular, regular reporting will be required to link government requests to platform action and lay bare the “continued pressure” the court requires.

Andrew Grossman and Kristen Shapiro have detailed the case for such a bill in a Cato Briefing Paper titled “Shining a Light on Censorship: How Transparency Can Curtail Government Social Media Censorship and More,” and I have published a corresponding model bill text. This approach remains the best way to discourage and discover jawboning, and in light of Murthy, the best way to ensure that future jawboning victims have the standing they require to prevail in court.

Елена Веснина

«Никто не вправе давать советы». Веснина рассказала, почему нужно ехать на Олимпиаду

Exclusive - Sayantani Ghosh expresses happiness as sets of her show Dahej Daasi shifted close to her home; says 'I've been manifesting this for quite some time now'

Suspect arrested for ‘threatening to kill Trump and his VP pick JD Vance’ in Florida days after assassination attempt

TV fame Drashti Dhami shares her workout routine during the pregnancy; see video

England U20 overpower France to be crowned world champions

Read also

Asylum hotel company ‘paid £16,000,000 to apparent offshore firm’

Man United have internally discussed star whose transfer fee has now dropped to £50m

Will replacing personal statements with application questions make university admissions fairer?

News, articles, comments, with a minute-by-minute update, now on

News Every Day

Suspect arrested for ‘threatening to kill Trump and his VP pick JD Vance’ in Florida days after assassination attempt — latest news 24/7. You can add your news instantly now — here

News Every Day

TV fame Drashti Dhami shares her workout routine during the pregnancy; see video

Sports today

Новости тенниса
Янник Синнер

Синнер не смог вылететь на Олимпиаду в Париж из-за проблем со здоровьем

Спорт в России и мире

Спортсменки из Красногорска выиграли «Кубок футбольных мам» в Коломне

All sports news today

Sports in Russia today


Росгвардейцы обеспечили безопасность во время футбольных матчей в Москве

Новости России

Game News

Today's Wordle answer for Saturday, July 20


Больше 46 тыс. случаев заражения хроническим гепатитом С выявили в 2023 году

Губернаторы России
Александр Мостовой

Экс-игрок Мостовой: в матче с "Акроном" я увидел обычный "Локомотив"

Суд обязал Сергея Шнурова и его агента вернуть 90 млн руб за сорванный концерт

Дело возбуждено после гибели российского блогера МотоТани при ДТП в Турции

Спортивные игры в СЛД "Москва-Сортировочная" филиала "Московский"

Кажетта Ахметжанова: какие цифры в дате рождения отвечают за денежный магнетизм человека

Нарколог Шуров: Глюкоза могла принять психоактивные вещества в Красноярске

Тимати, МОТ, «Руки Вверх!» и 205 000 гостей: в России прошел VK Fest. Как это было?

Релиз трека. Релиз новой песни. Релиз сингла. Релиз Музыкального альбома.

Дистрибьюция Музыки.

Синнер не смог вылететь на Олимпиаду в Париж из-за проблем со здоровьем

Медведев в матче против Синнера на Уимблдоне проявил характер, заявил Ольховский

Рафаэль Надаль сыграет в финале турнира ATP впервые с 2022 года

Саснович уступила в финале турнира WTA-250 в Будапеште

Путин назначил Романа Курынина замглавы МЧС России

Филиал № 4 ОСФР по Москве и Московской области информирует: За полгода 14,9 тысячи жителей Московского региона оформили страховую пенсию в автоматическом режиме на портале госуслуг

Филиал № 4 ОСФР по Москве и Московской области информирует: С начала 2024 года 140 тысяч женщин и новорожденных Московского региона получили услуги по родовым сертификатам

Представители «Метровагонмаш-Сервиса» посетили СЛД «Москва-Сортировочная» филиала «Московский» компании «ЛокоТех-Сервис» для обмена опытом

Больше ничто не держит: после смерти Анастасии Заворотнюк ее семья покинула Москву

Мать Заворотнюк и ее внучка уехали из Москвы после смерти актрисы

Релиз трека. Релиз новой песни. Релиз сингла. Релиз Музыкального альбома.

Певец Дмитрий Камский готовит к релизу новый сингл "Песня Земли"

Молодежь Подмосковья отправилась на Тавриду в Крым

Поздравить Ольгу с именинами 24 июля 2024 года стоит красивыми стихами и открытками

Глюкозу убрали с московских афиш после скандального концерта в Красноярске

Президент Федерации дзюдо России: «Вся страна поддержала позицию, которую заняли наши спортсмены»

Путин в России и мире

Персональные новости

Прима-балерина Ирина Сапожникова возвращается во Владивосток

News Every Day

Exclusive - Sayantani Ghosh expresses happiness as sets of her show Dahej Daasi shifted close to her home; says 'I've been manifesting this for quite some time now'

Friends of Today24

Музыкальные новости

Персональные новости