Add news
March 2010April 2010May 2010June 2010July 2010
August 2010
September 2010October 2010
November 2010
December 2010
January 2011
February 2011March 2011April 2011May 2011June 2011July 2011August 2011September 2011October 2011November 2011December 2011January 2012February 2012March 2012April 2012May 2012June 2012July 2012August 2012September 2012October 2012November 2012December 2012January 2013February 2013March 2013April 2013May 2013June 2013July 2013August 2013September 2013October 2013November 2013December 2013January 2014February 2014March 2014April 2014May 2014June 2014July 2014August 2014September 2014October 2014November 2014December 2014January 2015February 2015March 2015April 2015May 2015June 2015July 2015August 2015September 2015October 2015November 2015December 2015January 2016February 2016March 2016April 2016May 2016June 2016July 2016August 2016September 2016October 2016November 2016December 2016January 2017February 2017March 2017April 2017May 2017June 2017July 2017August 2017September 2017October 2017November 2017December 2017January 2018February 2018March 2018April 2018May 2018June 2018July 2018August 2018September 2018October 2018November 2018December 2018January 2019February 2019March 2019April 2019May 2019June 2019July 2019August 2019September 2019October 2019November 2019December 2019January 2020February 2020March 2020April 2020May 2020June 2020July 2020August 2020September 2020October 2020November 2020December 2020January 2021February 2021March 2021April 2021May 2021June 2021July 2021August 2021September 2021October 2021November 2021December 2021January 2022February 2022March 2022April 2022May 2022June 2022July 2022August 2022September 2022October 2022November 2022December 2022January 2023February 2023March 2023April 2023May 2023June 2023July 2023August 2023September 2023
News Every Day |

How to prove you've discovered alien life – new research

In 2021, scientists thought they had discovered phosphine in the clouds of Venus. NASA

In the past few decades, several phenomena have led to excited speculation in the scientific community that they might indeed be indications that there is extraterrestrial life. It will no doubt happen again.

Recently, two very different examples sparked excitement. In 2017, it was the mystery interstellar object ‘Oumuamua. And in 2021, it was the possible discovery of the gas phosphine in the clouds of Venus.

In both cases, it seemed possible that the phenomenon indicated some kind of extraterrestrial biological source. Notably, physicist Avi Loeb from Harvard University argued in favour of the oddly shaped ‘Oumuamua being an alien spaceship.

And phosphine in the atmosphere of a rocky planet is proposed to be a strong signature for life, as it is continuously produced by microbes on Earth.

These are just two of the latest cases of a long list of examples of such initially promising phenomena. But although a few of the examples are still controversial, most have turned out to have other explanations (it wasn’t aliens).

So how can we be sure we’ve come to the right conclusion for something as subtle as the presence of a certain gas or a strange looking space rock? In our new paper published in the journal Astrobiology, we have proposed a technique for reliably evaluating such evidence.

The word “possible” is strange, with a rather unfortunate degree of flexibility. There’s a sense in which it is possible that I’ll meet King Charles III today, but at the same time it is extraordinarily unlikely.

Many shouts of: “It might be aliens!” should be interpreted in this (strained) sense. By contrast, we often use the word “might” to express something that has high probability, as in “it might snow today.”

The concept of possibility incorporates these extremes, and everything in-between. Newspapers might capitalise on this flexibility with a cheeky headline that appears to indicate that something is a bit more exciting than it actually is. But the scientific world needs to express itself with rigour, transparently conveying the degree of confidence justified by the evidence.

Some would turn to Bayes’ Theorem, a common statistical formula, which gives the probability (Pr) of something, given some evidence.

One could, optimistically, input the available evidence into the Bayes formula, and achieve as output a number between 0 and 1 (where 0.5 is a 50:50 chance that a signal is produced by aliens). But the Bayesian approach doesn’t really help when it comes to extraterrestrial life.

Image of the Bayesian formula.
The Bayesian formula for alien evidence, produced by Anders Sandberg, University of Oxford. Author provided

For example, it requires an input for the prior probability that aliens exist. And intuitions about that vary dramatically (estimates for the number of inhabited planets in our galaxy range from one to billions).

It also requires a value for the probability of the phenomenon in question occurring naturally – not caused by aliens. For some kinds of “biosignatures” (such as a dinosaur skeleton) we know that the probability of it occurring without life is incredibly low. But for many others (say, a particular blend of gases) we don’t know much at all.

Diagram of how much possibility space we have explored.
How much of the relevant possibility space have we explored? Peter Vickers, CC BY-SA

Here one meets with the problem of “unconceived alternatives”. Put simply: we may know too little about alternative sources of the phenomenon. Perhaps we just haven’t explored the space of possible causes of the relevant phenomenon very much.

After all, humans have only carried out a limited amount of rigorous research – we don’t know about every single process that could produce a certain gas in an atmosphere.

New approaches

In 2021, a Nasa-affiliated group published a paper setting out the Confidence of Life Detection (CoLD) framework, designed to solve this problem.

It recommends seven steps to verifying a discovery, from ruling out contamination to getting follow-up observations of a predicted biological signal in the same region.

Unfortunately, the problem of unconceived alternatives remains a serious challenge. Level 4 in the framework requires that “all known non-biological sources of signal” are shown to be implausible. But this only starts to mean something when the relevant space of different possibilities has been thoroughly explored.

Our new paper, published by the group Exploring Uncertainty and Risk in Contemporary Astrobiology (EURiCA), has come up with another proposal.

Or, rather, it is an idea borrowed from another context. For many years, it has been imperative for the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) to be clear on how confident they are concerning a great many propositions about climate change.

In order to express their degree of confidence, a framework has been in place for more than 20 years now, which combines the quantity and quality of the evidence with the degree to which experts agree (the degree of consensus, if any). While this has been robustly challenged, it has stood the test of time in the face of extraordinary scrutiny and the highest possible stakes.

This same framework could be used in the context of discovering extraterrestrial life. A dedicated team of experts would make a judgement based not only on their assessment of the scientific evidence (X-axis in image above), but also the extent of agreement across the community (Y-axis).

So the worst assessment would have low agreement among experts and limited evidence while the best would have high agreement and robust evidence.

What of unconceived alternatives? The community of experts will only agree that purported evidence for life is “robust” if the relevant possibilities have been thoroughly explored. If they haven’t, there’s a good chance some other explanation will turn up in the long run.

Astrobiologists mustn’t limit their research to the study of the signatures of life. They must also carefully investigate the possible ways that non-biological processes might mimic those same signatures.

Only when we know that, might we finally be able to say, “This time, it really could be aliens.”

The Conversation

Peter Vickers receives funding from Leverhulme Trust Research Project Grant (RPG-2021-274).

Sean McMahon receives funding from Leverhulme Trust Research Project Grant (RPG-2021-274) and the Royal Society of Edinburgh grant #1918.


Лукашенко: не всем западным демократиям нравится миролюбивая политика Минска

Tyreek Hill Modestly Gives Credit For Dolphins' Week 3 Success to Tua Tagovailoa

Stylish Fall Essentials You Need For 2023

LIV Golf in hot water again, faces lawsuit from Adidas over logo trademark issue

Fact or Fiction: Dolphins Could Flirt With 15 Wins, Packers Are Best In NFC North

Read also

Pumpkin Nights at the Bronx Zoo: 'It’s the most exciting thing ever'

Swap Santorini for this lesser-known Greek island that only locals visit – it’s cheaper & 22C in autumn

Swiss indict daughter of former Uzbek president in bribery, money laundering case involving millions

News, articles, comments, with a minute-by-minute update, now on

News Every Day

Fact or Fiction: Dolphins Could Flirt With 15 Wins, Packers Are Best In NFC North — latest news 24/7. You can add your news instantly now — here

News Every Day

Tyreek Hill Modestly Gives Credit For Dolphins' Week 3 Success to Tua Tagovailoa

Sports today

Новости тенниса

«Правильно сделала». Потапова поддержала Рыбакину в критике WTA

Спорт в России и мире

Опубликована спортивная программа Международного спортивного форума «Россия – спортивная держава»

All sports news today

Sports in Russia today


«Дженоа» разгромил «Рому» Моуринью в матче чемпионата Италии

Новости России

Game News

Mow My Lawn 1.24


Молодые деревья и кустарники посадили активисты в парке имени Воробьева

Губернаторы России

«585*ЗОЛОТОЙ» составила рейтинг курортных городов по продажам украшений

«585*ЗОЛОТОЙ» составила рейтинг курортных городов по продажам украшений

Прокуратура Москвы начала проверку после падения трехлетнего ребенка из окна

Индийские следователи вооружатся технологией блокчейн

Собянин рассказал о развитии инновационной экосистемы Москвы

KOBZOV: свежее звучание легендарной песни "Я это ты" Мурата Насырова

Помогает с собакой и познакомила с парнем: что происходит между дочерью Волочковой и ее мачехой

В Новосибирске записали джазовый альбом по мотивам песен Егора Летова и Янки Дягилевой

Снять свое Кино. Снять Кино.

Елена Рыбакина приняла неожиданное решение после критики WTA

Джокович поздравил Хачанова с победой на турнире в Чжухае

«Правильно сделала». Потапова поддержала Рыбакину в критике WTA

Тренер Елены Рыбакиной выступил с критикой в адрес WTA на фоне ситуации в Токио

Анастасия Щипанова и скульптор Виктор Джинджембер встретились в Париже

Цены на новостройки в РФ вновь пустились в рост

«585*ЗОЛОТОЙ» составила рейтинг курортных городов по продажам украшений

Индийские следователи вооружатся технологией блокчейн

Сотни лучников боролись за Кубок генпрокурора РФ: как это было

Народная артистка Лариса Долина присоединилась к акции «Поделись своим знанием» и провела творческую встречу с молодыми музыкантами Сахалина

Представитель Росгвардии выступил на учебно-методическом сборе руководителей ведомственной охраны Министерства транспорта

Президент Южного Судана Киир прилетел в Москву к Путину

Валентина Голубенко госпитализировали в Москве

За год Татарстан стал на 10% привлекательнее для туристов

Молодые деревья и кустарники посадили активисты в парке имени Воробьева

День учителя отметят в Красногорском филиале Музея Победы

Путин в России и мире

Персональные новости

Бывшая возлюбленная Тимати перенесла липосакцию после борьбы с анорексией

News Every Day

Stylish Fall Essentials You Need For 2023

Friends of Today24

Музыкальные новости

Персональные новости