Мобильный 1 Add news
March 2010
April 2010
May 2010June 2010July 2010
August 2010
September 2010October 2010
November 2010
December 2010
January 2011
February 2011March 2011April 2011May 2011June 2011July 2011August 2011September 2011October 2011November 2011December 2011January 2012February 2012March 2012April 2012May 2012June 2012July 2012August 2012September 2012October 2012November 2012December 2012January 2013February 2013March 2013April 2013May 2013June 2013July 2013August 2013September 2013October 2013November 2013December 2013January 2014February 2014March 2014April 2014May 2014June 2014July 2014August 2014September 2014October 2014November 2014December 2014January 2015February 2015March 2015April 2015May 2015June 2015July 2015August 2015September 2015October 2015November 2015December 2015January 2016February 2016March 2016April 2016May 2016June 2016July 2016August 2016September 2016October 2016November 2016December 2016January 2017February 2017March 2017April 2017May 2017June 2017July 2017August 2017September 2017October 2017November 2017December 2017January 2018February 2018March 2018April 2018May 2018June 2018July 2018August 2018September 2018October 2018November 2018December 2018January 2019February 2019March 2019April 2019May 2019June 2019July 2019August 2019September 2019October 2019November 2019December 2019January 2020February 2020March 2020April 2020May 2020June 2020July 2020August 2020September 2020October 2020November 2020December 2020January 2021February 2021March 2021April 2021May 2021June 2021July 2021August 2021September 2021October 2021November 2021December 2021January 2022February 2022March 2022April 2022May 2022
News Every Day |

A Traditional Yet Innovative Way Forward for the Church


On April 20, 2022, an article appeared in Crisis discussing the so-called “Truce of ’68,” the unofficial arrangement that has governed the unstable peace of the Church since 1968. As the author, Darrick Taylor, correctly describes, under the Truce, the ecclesial establishment uncritically accepts the reforms that followed the Second Vatican Council and also praises and defends Humanae Vitae (HV) as a courageous stand against the immoral demands of the modern world. At the same time, the establishment has long accepted a level of “dissent” from HV and a myriad of other social/sexual moral teachings. Praised in some circles and frowned upon in others, the dissenters, nonetheless, form a wing of the ecclesial “coalition government” that has ruled since the close of the Council. 

The “conservative” side of the ecclesial divide has generally lauded the Truce, at least insofar as it believes that the pontificate of John Paul II succeeded in righting the wrongs of the immediate post-Council period. In this view, the solution to the post-Council chaos was firm opposition to the Sexual Revolution, with HV as the foundational document that prevented the Church from destruction. While the world went off the rails with “free love,” the Church would stand firm! Church teaching doesn’t change! Birth control, premarital sex, and all the rest would be condemned by Catholics while everyone else gave up. 

The attraction of this approach for the conservative post-Council generation is obvious, and it made sense in its time. It allowed this group to embrace the official position of the Church regarding the necessity and greatness of the Conciliar age while at the same time permitting the conservatives to hail a form of Tradition and to associate themselves with the papacy. They promoted papal teachings of every variety as the ultimate arbiter of Tradition and Truth.

With the passage of time, however, the fundamental flaw in this approach has become apparent. Under the Truce, the conservatives implicitly posit that even the most central and ancient aspects of the Christian life can, even must, change. The Traditional Mass was a clumsy relic that was necessarily replaced by the Novus Ordo. The age-old lectionary, the untouchable Canon, may be discarded, along with innumerable pious customs, practices, and outward signs of Catholic identity. Yesterday, you were on the way to Hell for eating meat on Friday. Today, who cares??!! No problem!!!

But birth control? No, sorry, we cannot change that teaching. The Church doesn’t change! We can’t alter these moral teachings! How dare you dissent!! That is Catholic Lite!!! Do you want to be Protestants?  

It is, in essence, an incoherent, even bizarre position, and it has proven to be a poor foundation for the long-desired “renewal” of the Church. While not a total failure—the Truce did bring a measure of stability to the chaos of Paul VI’s papacy—the fact is, the world has marched on in its ways, continually pushing the Church toward irrelevancy. Outside of a small minority of the Catholic world that seems to dwell exceedingly upon the defense of HV, moral qualms about the use of artificial birth control are fairly estimated at zero. Even questions about homosexuality have been eclipsed by the onslaught of gender ideology and people proclaiming themselves this-or-that-sexual.  

As Mr. Taylor suggests in his article, it seems that there is a growing desire on all sides to discard the Truce. The progressives of the Francis era hope to complete the transformation of the Church into something else—as far as is discernible, into some sort of organization that promotes political causes and ideologies in line with the failed Western ruling classes’ obsessions. The conservatives oppose these radicals and seem to propose a return to the John Paul II settlement. Traditionalists, a party that was virtually nonexistent during the heyday of the Truce, propose a wholesale reexamination of the Council and its aftermath, with the goal of restoring the Traditional Mass and its attendant liturgical piety as the cornerstone upon which the Church can finally rebuild itself after decades of decay. 

In my view, the way forward lies down the Traditionalist path, but this path cannot (and will not) merely lead the Church back to a mythical pre-Conciliar mirage where every question is settled and everyone assents to the commands of the pope or the Curia.  

Consider the following scenario: What if, following the close of the Council, Pope Paul VI had announced an initiative to reinvigorate the liturgical life of the Church? What if he called for limits on the use of the Low Mass and exhorted dioceses to instruct and assist parishes to form choirs and to learn to sing the ancient chants of the Mass, with the High Mass given pride of place on Sundays? 

What if instead of encouraging the zest to tear out altar rails and strip down sanctuaries, Rome turned that zeal toward the encouragement of the singing of Sunday Vespers? What if it became fashionable to follow the customs of the Ember Days and to observe the vigils? What if Paul VI had added more holy days to the general observance—Epiphany, Candlemas, Annunciation, All Souls Day—insisting that the religious calendar interrupt the humdrum, secular work week?

What if Rome had praised traditional religious life and led a rediscovery of charisms that entailed a renewed attachment to the saintly ways of the founders of the many orders where teaching, nursing, and direct care for the poor were extolled as the finest flower of the Christian vocation?

What if the Church had replaced legalistic morality manuals with a new way of teaching that shows sin in its effects, like a disease that destroys the soul just as cancer ravages the body? What if, in the context of sexual morality, the Church had preached that addiction to lust and sensuality will eliminate the spiritual life and lead to shame, loneliness, ruined marriages, and general unhappiness, even if outwardly masked in a life of ease and fun, like that of Dorian Gray?

In other words, what if the Church had done the reverse of what it did? The consideration of this hypothetical, I think, points the way beyond the Truce. There must be a way that both restores and innovates; that is not defensive, yet is rooted in Tradition. This way cannot rely upon hyper-papalism and the desire to proclaim every matter settled and every dissent from the Catechism an outrage. Indeed, nothing is more traditional than controversy in the life of the Church. Omit dissents and controversies from any history and the book would be hardly a page. The Church cannot remain afraid that any possible development means the collapse of the entire moral teaching authority. That is a position born in fear, weakness, and panic. 

The Church must have confidence in herself, and in her perennial practices, knowing that there has never been, and never will be, any substitute for the Gospel and the Sacraments. 

The miracle of the post-Council Church is that there is a post-Council Church. It falls upon a new generation to consider what to do with what has been left to us by God—to go beyond a stale Truce and to rebuild the Temple again, just as our forefathers rebuilt it after every previous crisis during which it seemed the Church would not endure. 

[Photo Credit: Unsplash]

Read also

Opposition state finance ministers welcome Supreme Court’s ruling on GST Council

A 400-year-old Italian church that's been converted into a home is on the market for $3.32 million — take a look inside

Jon Stewart reveals what he learned from George Carlin

Прямой эфир РБК. Главные новости России и мира сегодня (Прямой эфир ежедневно)

News, articles, comments, with a minute-by-minute update, now on Today24.pro

News Every Day

Andrew Nicholson: ‘Riders must use their gears when riding cross-country’

Today24.pro — latest news 24/7. You can add your news instantly now — here

News Every Day


Sports today

Новости тенниса
Даниил Медведев

Селиваненко: к сегодняшнему поражению Медведева от Гаске нужно относиться спокойно

Спорт в России и мире

Спортсмены Росгвардии стали победителями Открытого чемпионата Белоруссии по велоспорту на треке


All sports news today


Sports in Russia today


Фанаты «Зенита» перед выездом к «Спартаку» посетили Ржевский мемориал Советскому солдату

Новости России

Game News

Total War: Warhammer 3's 1.2 update means more siege defences, less towers, free mounts



Актер МХТ с женой рассказали о покупке квартиры в новом районе Москвы

Губернаторы России
Джо Байден

Аналитик Скотт Риттер: Байден «сделал одолжение» России, освободив её из ловушки западной экономики

Задержанный за убийство трех человек под Саратовом признал вину

За сутки в России выявили 4 732 случаев коронавируса

Более 20 новых светофоров установят в Петербурге до октября

Названы сочетания цветов, которые помогут создать дорогой образ

Луи Армстронг носил «звезду Давида»

В рамках Ночи музеев в Москве откроется выставка о Викторе Цое


Более 400 северян прошли обучение в рамках первого сезона работы образовательного центра Юрия Башмета

BBC: WTA не будет лишать травяные турниры в Истбурне, Ноттингеме и Бирмингеме рейтинговых очков

Теннисист Медведев высказался по поводу отстранения от Уимблдона

ATP не лишит теннисные турниры Великобритании рейтинговых очков

Селиваненко: к сегодняшнему поражению Медведева от Гаске нужно относиться спокойно

В Москве подготовят 386 машинистов и их помощников для МЦД-3

В ЕАЭС унифицируют подачу информации о растительном сырье в лекарствах

Загрутдинов: Физкультурно-оздоровительный комплекс с двумя бассейнами построят в районе Внуково

Фанаты «Зенита» перед выездом к «Спартаку» посетили Ржевский мемориал Советскому солдату

Аналитик Скотт Риттер: Байден «сделал одолжение» России, освободив её из ловушки западной экономики

Песков рассказал, купит ли Путин себе новый «Москвич»

Игорь Маковский поблагодарил энергетиков за оперативное восстановление электроснабжения жителей регионов ЦФО

Полина Гагарина получила «Звезду Авторадио»

Врач объяснил, что делать при резком повышении температуры

Мое самое крутое приключение лета. Подвесные мосты Подмосковья - маршрут с координатами

Строящийся детсад на улице Твардовского Балашихи готов более чем на 70%

Движение метро в субботу продлят до часу ночи в Нижнем Новгороде

Путин в России и мире

Персональные новости


Первое документальное кино о Басте выйдет на KION 24 мая

News Every Day


Friends of Today24

Музыкальные новости
"Воскресенье " Олег Митяев

Персональные новости
Близкий друг Путина миллиардер Пугачев. Вся правда о Путине, его семье и деньгах. В гостях у Гордона (2021)

Навальный об уволенном за пост священнике (2021)

Slava Marlow – суперуспех и депрессия в 21 год / вДудь (2021)

Обнаглевшие дети путинской элиты (2021)

Дайте собакам мяса (новый звук) -Владимир Высоцкий

Группа "Рождество" - песня "Так хочется жить!" (Видео с концерта в Киеве группы "РОЖДЕСТВО" в 2011 году в Доме офицеров)

Adriano Celentano Любимая песня Челентано (высочайшая энергетика) talentTV